I've been a frequent critic of starship. But the significance of this milestone is clear: it's the first demonstration of a reusable upper stage of a rocket system since the space shuttle.
Part of the importance is due to the fact that while the space shuttle was a technical success in terms of being able to build and operate a reusable upper stage, it was hella expensive. It required a lot of expensive refurbishment between missions. Launch cadence had a fairly low upper bound. And it wasn't safe enough.
The true believers will claim that catching a starship upper stage marks a new era. It marks the possibility of a new era. It proves it is plausible that a vertical landing upper stage could possibly be a better approach than a space plane. But it hasn't proven any of that. There are about a dozen major milestones between here and actually having a rocket system that meets all of its claimed specifications, both technical and financial. Here's just one big hairy example: to fly manned missions, starship either needs to be redesigned to accommodate an escape system, or it needs to show a level of reliability and safety never previously achieved by a rocket.
In my estimation, it will take at least another five years to know what starship really can do and what it will cost.
> what starship really can do and what it will cost.
The previous flight launched 20 sats and that is the equivalent (in Starlink bandwidth) to 10x F9 launches.
This one launched 26 sats. That'd be 13x F9 launches in Starlink bw.
F9 internal cost is 20M$.
Starship stack is rumoured to cost ~100M$ to build.
If they can launch a stack once every month, they've already achieved more "capacity" for Starlink than their best year using F9s (last year). At half the price.
So that's already proven, even if nothing else works (i.e. reusability, etc). But of course they'll keep working the problem and make it work. They're also scaling at a crazy pace (3 more pads in various stages of readiness, plus even more planned in the next ~5 years). They've just finished the gigabay and they're planning even more in Louisiana.
Anything they do from here on out is "the cherry on top".
> to fly manned missions, starship either needs to be redesigned to accommodate an escape system, or it needs to show a level of reliability and safety never previously achieved by a rocket.
I assume they'll do the latter. If the vehicle is truly rapidly reusable, that's less crazy than it sounds. Just fly it 10,000 times and fix all the problems you find :) Escape systems are only really useful during launch anyway. The only way to protect the crew from a failure during reentry is reliability.
How are you measuring "safe enough" in this context? My understanding is that the Shuttle didn't have programmatic probabilistic requirements for mission safety. Ie, they didn't use overall reliability estimates and instead relied on engineering judgement (which the Challenger report showed varied widely depending on who you interviewed). It's hard to make a claim on whether it was safe enough without explicitly defining the safety goal.
Early 1970s documents were given safety requirements of 1:20 flights being successful. [1] That's the closest I've found to an actual requirement, and the shuttle record falls well within that requirement. I do think such an early spec is not a good basis for final performance, though.
I think it is obvious by now that Starship was not designed for manned missions and that it was designed to provide cheap launch capabilities for very large payload capacity.
Flight 13 launched 20 Starlink v3 sats for a total payload of 34,100 kg.
Flight 14 launched 26 Starlink v3 sats for a total payload of 44,330 kg.
> it's the first demonstration of a reusable upper stage of a rocket system since the space shuttle
I'd argue not quite yet. They've shown that they can catch the upper stage and that of course is a big milestone and improves the chances of getting a reusable system tremendously. A demonstration of a reusable upper stage requires them to successfully re-fly a previously used upper stage. The catch demonstration is a very good step in that direction, but not quite yet (in my opinion).
The biggest problem they need to solve at this time is making the thermal tiles more damage resistant. At this time too many ceramic tiles get damaged and need replacement, repair or refurbishment just like with the Space Shuttle. That makes the dream of rapid reuse and lower launch costs unattainable.
I wonder why SpaceX didn't pioneer metal-ceramic or metallic heat shielding.
I'd respect your criticisms much more if they were more accurate, of if when shown to be inaccurate, you acknowledged that. But it seems like you just move from one criticism to another and ignore your mistakes.
For example, on flight 14 you claimed that SpaceX fudged their payload numbers by not fully fueling the satellites.[1] I pointed out that this must be false for two reasons: 1. Propellant is less than 5% of the mass of the satellites and 2. The FAA requires accurate masses for debris assessments.
You also suggested that flight 14 wasn't fully fueled to allow for RTLS, but the amount of propellant burned is the same for a water landing and a tower landing. The only difference is when they do the reentry burn.
Other times you've claimed that Starship hasn't met its payload goals. But Starship currently delivers a half payload because when launching from Texas, it must perform a dogleg maneuver to avoid flying over populated areas (such as Cuba). When they start launching from Florida, they they'll be able to put 100 tons into orbit per launch.[2]
You've also claimed that Starlink's addressable market is shrinking because terrestrial wireless will expand.[3] But a cell tower costs about 1/3rd as much as a V2 mini and can't serve nearly as many customers in rural areas. So even with Falcon 9, Starlink outcompetes cell towers in areas with low population density. If Starship lowers launch costs more by being reusable, then the tradeoff will favor Starlink in more areas, not fewer. The only way to reduce Starlink's TAM would be if cell towers somehow became much cheaper.
Even today you've claimed that the ship's engines don't have a heat shield.[4] But if you look at images of Starship or watch videos of reentry, you can see the engines are enclosed by the aft skirt. They already need to shield the engines for reentry because they operate during the landing burn.
These sorts of mistakes make it much harder to lend credence to your conclusions. Yes the Starship program has taken much longer than SpaceX planned, but if the program is going to be successful in the long term, outcomes like flight 15 are exactly what one should expect to see.
2. https://arstechnica.com/space/2026/11/spacex-now-fundamental... "Dontchev said a single Florida Starship launch will be able to carry up to 20 times the bandwidth of a single Falcon 9." SpaceX currently claims that each Starship launch carries 10x the bandwidth of a Falcon 9 launch, so this would put them at around 100 tons of payload.
> to fly manned missions, starship either needs to be redesigned to accommodate an escape system, or it needs to show a level of reliability and safety never previously achieved by a rocket.
Falcon rockets don't seem to be exploding on ascent anymore, they're doing 2-3 launches per week now, no explosions in a decade.
Perhaps an escape system could be deployed from the dorsal side of Starship, too.
Given their track record of achieving the impossible, I wouldn't bet against SpaceX as they head towards commercial deployment of Starship.
Sir, you are a programmer of Java applications for mobile phones. You’ve had an impressive career, and are a person I am honored to look up to, but please have some humility
I still feel like I am living in the future when I see these catches, but that last flip to vertical it does as it decelerates looks like everyone would be leaving their lunch all round the inside of the rocket.
> to fly manned missions, starship either needs to be redesigned to accommodate an escape system, or it needs to show a level of reliability and safety never previously achieved by a rocket.
What makes you think humans will be the primary passengers? My bet is they will send Optimus for the majority of "manned" missions, especially 5 years from now
>to fly manned missions, starship either needs to be redesigned to accommodate an escape system, or it needs to show a level of reliability and safety never previously achieved by a rocket.
Starship doesn’t need a 1960's style launch escape system. The whole ship is the crew vehicle. If the booster fails, Starship separates and flies away on its own Raptors. That’s the plan SpaceX has stuck with for years. NASA requires high reliability and failure tolerance for crewed flights, not a regulatorily mandated escape system.
If you extrapolate the safety record of Falcon onto Starship, which seems conservative given that Starship is going to be their focus, it will be far safer than the Space Shuttle.
The Space Shuttle blew up 2 out of 135 flights, 1.5%. Falcon has 3 blow-ups out of 720+ flights. That's more than 20x as safe, and includes the aggressive/early R&D.
Starship is still being developed. Unless they go under somehow, it's going to be safer than the Space Shuttle by similar orders of magnitude.
> Here's just one big hairy example: to fly manned missions, starship either needs to be redesigned to accommodate an escape system, or it needs to show a level of reliability and safety never previously achieved by a rocket.
I bet there are lots of people willing to fly on Starship even if it had Falcon 9’s level of reliability even without an escape system.
> Part of the importance is due to the fact that while the space shuttle was a technical success in terms of being able to build and operate a reusable upper stage, it was hella expensive.
This is a complete apples to oranges comparison.
A more apt comparison would be the space shuttle being a kin to Vasco da Gama's discovery of the sea route to India. After that point, the concept was demonstrated and the challenge was in optimizing cost-savings of commercial endeavours.
I mean, orbital lift services have been a thing for how many decades?
> while the space shuttle was a technical success in terms of being able to build and operate a reusable upper stage, it was hella expensive
stop repeating this lie, please
shuttle costs per-launch were on falcon 9 level
the only reason for the cost was lack of payloads (!) to spread per-year costs
there's a reason why spaceX now gets far far FAR largest part of its income from Starlink and most most MOST of its launches are Starlink. It's sattelite company with launch side business
If the heat shield holds up then this changes everything. Next step is double catch and re-flying the same ships and catching again, then payloads to orbit become significantly cheaper opening a new era in space flight.
Yeah, I'm eagerly awaiting results from inspection of the heat shield (which hopefully they will disclose). Reflight without refurbishment is the last goal they need to hit before the system can be considered a success. After that, optimizing for increased payload and nailing reliability will be the things to work on. And of course orbital refueling for HLS.
Even if it doesn't meet their goals of rapid reuse, I think we've still joined the new era. Replacing tiles is going to be substantially cheaper than building new upper stages, likely less than the cost of fuel for a launch.
Even if they haven't completely solved it. They have shown they can strip the old heat shield off, and put an entirely new design of heat shield on a ship in under 2 weeks. I believe that was one of the doomed block 2 ships that blew up in the Caribbean so it never got to re-entry.
I've been thinking about the catch system and I don't think the risks and problems are being properly accounted for.
For anyone unfamiliar, the Falcon 9 first stage booster reuse comes from landing the booster on a barge or on land and then recovering it and refurbishing it. Because the engines use RP1, there is coking and this is more expensive and slower to refurbish. Raptor engines use LNG instead to avoid coking but this is also more complex because now you have two cryogenic fuels instead of one (the other being liquid oxygen obviously).
The barges are ideal because the first stages will exhaust their fuel over the Atlantic. To land back at the pad they need to retain more fuel. This hurts payloads. But you have choices. Barges are relatively cheap. On land you can basically land on a relatively cheap concrete pad.
to have the structure and fins required to not collapse when landing, it adds an estimated 10% to the weight. That's a big deal. It's also why Starship opted for the catch system.
But here's the problem: you have to land back somewhere where you have a catcher. What happens if the catcher is down? Or the booster is suffering a fault (eg enough engines won't fire up so it isn't stable)? The catcher itself is a complicated and expensive engineering exercise. It's why on a recent test launch they opted for a water landing instead.
To have manned missions you're going to need redundancy. That means more than one catcher available most likely. You need an escape system if the booster itself is faulty. You risk the catcher every time you use it. All of that gets expensive in a way that landing on a barge or concrete pad doesn't.
Huge congratulations to the engineering team on this one! It's been quite interesting to watch the evolution of Starship. Had they put another couple of tonnes of propellant and oxidizer on the Booster they might have caught both of them. It is still unclear to me what the final mass fraction to orbit will work out to be, but something that is 100% re-usable is better than something 60% reusable[1].
[1] Estimate of Falcon 9's booster + fairings being 60% (by cost, not by mass) of the launch package.
I still remember watching Falcon 9 (Block V, iirc) successfully landing back on land (as opposed to droneships) after deploying Orbcomm OG2 satellites in December 2015 -- almost 11 years ago.
It blew my teen mind.
This day marks a fabulous advancement for the human species.
I'll be that guy: they still have to fly it again. That's the real question. Incredible achievement. We got used to landing and caught boosters real quick!
I guess it has to be a reference to A Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy, which is one of Elon's favorite books. In the story, the answer to life, universe and everything is 42, and the guidebook carries “Don’t Panic” on its cover. The ship is S42, so the match is clear.
Starship is, essentially, Space Shuttle done right: fully reusable booster without solid boosters (avoids Challenger disaster) and orbiter stacked on top instead of on the side (avoid Columbia disaster).
The original designs for the Space Shuttle had the booster (with wings!) return to the launch site, but the cost for two new crewed vehicles was too large, so they scaled it back to the compromised version.
Even more revolutionary, compared to Shuttle, Starship is built on an assembly line. They can build a booster ever 4 weeks and a ship every 2 weeks.
The future we were promised in the 1970s is about to become real.
But the Shuttle became what it became for reasons that Starship doesn’t have to deal with. Shuttle had multiple masters (NASA and DoD) driving a bastardized design. The non-assembly line of NASA is a feature, not a bug: by spreading work across many congressional districts it mitigates political defunding risk. Im not defending those, but they are important context for those who pretend the differences are a signal of government incompetence.
Private industry tends to be far more efficient at making “stuff that works” than a non-profit governmental organization.
Even for all the genuinely good and smart people that worked for NASA over the decades, the bureaucratic machinery that makes it run eventually becomes so convoluted, corrupt and bloated for its own good.
I should know; I worked there for over a quarter of a century. Nothing beats the private industry for “making shit that works.”
The Space Shuttle took 2 people into orbit on its first launch and returned them safely to earth. On the first attempt. On the first test of any of the hardware into space. In 1981.
Starship did not and has not done that and until it does I will continue to hold reservations.
I do not see this Starship and its mission profile ever being a human-rated system in this incarnation, ever.
A really cheap way to launch mass into LEO? Sure, I'll give it that.
> The original designs for the Space Shuttle had the booster (with wings!) return to the launch site, but the cost for two new crewed vehicles was too large, so they scaled it back to the compromised version.
Can you cite a source for this claim? My understanding is that the control algorithms for landing a rocket did not exist at the time of the space shuttle. The algorithms were invented in 2010s[1] and space shuttle operated from 1981-2011[2]
>> Even more revolutionary, compared to Shuttle, Starship is built on an assembly line. They can build a booster ever 4 weeks and a ship every 2 weeks.
Note that they are also scaling up production in a big way, because they want to launch weekly soon, and then daily. Not sure if we will get to the latter anytime soon but I'm also not going to bet against Elon.
Reusability is all about cost savings. The real question now is how much does it cost to turn Starship around for reuse - how much heat shield replacement, how do the vaccuum raptor engines survive the thermal cycling, what is the lifetime of parts involved in the catch mechanism, etc.
I don't think you intended to dis the space shuttle (much) but it's important to recognize that half a century has passed since the start of the shuttle design process. Comparing the two is like comparing the 747 to the Ford Tri-motor.
I think you forget that in Apollo time all people ever wanted was to get out of earth and see what's actually out there, with human presence. All the other stuff, would be done later, like this.
It's funny how people can look at the exact same program and draw wildly different conclusions. From where I'm sitting, Starship is a deeply flawed and highly risky program with an uncertain future. There are two keys problems:
1. It's not clear what the product-market fit for Starship really is, specifically there is limited demand for these super-heavy payloads. What's my evidence? Falcon Heavy. It averages about 1 launch a year, typically by the military, compared to >100 for Falcon 9.
There are five standard counterarguments to this:
a) "You can carry multiple payloads." Most of the time this simply isn't true. The payloads have to be on almost identical orbits for this to work. Different inclination? No shot. Different altitude? Almost no shot. This brings us to the second;
b) "But Starlink." Yes, Starlink can take advantage of this although to justify its massive expansion, Starlink really has to launch a satellite-based handheld mobile phone network and it has to be pretty much global. It's unclear if this can be from a legal and regulatory standpoint or if it will be able to effectively compete with traditional terrestrial 5G networks. It's unclear what customer density can be supported;
c) "It will induce demand for bigger payloads." Falcon Heavy is relatively cheap, particularly compared to the alternatives from Ariane and ULA yet launch cadence is still particularly slow. Satellites, which are the bread and butter of commercial rocketry, just don't need to be that big;
d) "Starship will replace Falcon 9 launches." Yes, but other companies will fill the Falcon 9 gap if SpaceX abandons it. If you're only carrying one payload to LEO (or even geostationary orbit) and you can do that with a smaller launch system that you can reuse, it's simply going to be better eventually; and
e) "Space based AI data centers." This is never going to happen. it doesn't make any sense. You can't get enough power or distribute the heat. You're subject to cosmic rays and solar radiation, which the atmosphere otherwise mostly protects you from, and you have no way to economically service the inevitable failures.
2. The whole Mars thing is BS, basically, kinda like space-based data centers. It's not happening. There's absolutely no reason to go;
3. Starship isn't suited for lunar missions, which is one reason (IMHO) why Elon tried to scuttle NASA's lunar program [1]. Basically, a 40 meter high vessel that has to land horizontally is hard to land, hard to get in and out of (with your astronauts 40 meters off the surface) and much harder to get off the Moon and back to Earth.
4. Between (2) and (3) a whole lot of new capabilities have to be developed anyway, none of which have even begun yet (eg in-orbit refueling).
Now the one really useful thing from the Starship program (IMHO) is the Raptor engine. For context, the Falcon 9's Merlin engine used oxygen and RP-1 (kerosene, basically). Only the oxygen had to be kept really cold. But it has coking issues (ie solid carbon build up from the RP-1 being consumed). Raptor replaces RP-1 with LNG. No coking but now you have two cryogenic fuels instead of one.
Just watched the catch stream live on the dome of a local planetarium - really feeling history is being made.
It was all so symbolic, they just had a talk about the Voyager probe reaching one light day from Earth accompanied by screening of the Startrek movie (which includes V'ger/Voyager) and ad hoc decided to stream the catch just after the movie ended.
Was a really surreal experience, first watching the tiny Enterprise zooming around the vast V'ger spacecraft only to see Starship zooming through the clouds and getting caught, all on the same planetarium dome projection! :-)
Interestingly, there's a similar large "block" recovery rig in the South China Sea. They use two sets of steel cables running in the X and Y directions — visually it's a lot like the Japanese cat's cradle string game. From a quick search, it appears to have shown up after SpaceX's chopsticks catch. Different engineering approach, but the same idea of catching the returning stage in a grid rather than with arms.
this doesn't make sense for Starship - Starship is RTLS (return to launch site), and a cable/net catch system creates an unnecessarily complex launch tower.
The cable catch system for long march 10B is superior to the landing legs of falcon 9 - of the 11 falcon 9 failures, a cable catch system would have avoided 4-6 of them. Removing the landing legs also reduces the rocket dry mass and increases payload mass to orbit.
If SpaceX did Falcon 9 again, they would likely use a cable catch system, as it resolves about half of falcon 9's historic landing failures.
The rocket that system catches (Long March 10B) is the size of Falcon 9. Starship is an order of magnitude larger and heavier. It may not be a practical solution for a significantly larger scale rocket.
Does someone with more knowledge than me know if the co2 emissions from these kinds of rocket launches are big enough to make frequently launching and re-launching rockets into space a problem re. climate change? That’s a refrain I hear frequently but have no idea how true it is.
There's about a thousand tons of methane on starship which come out to about 2750 tons of CO2.
For reference an average natural gas power plant produces 2000 tons 10000 tons of CO2 every day.
So if you fly a starship once per day that's as bad as one (1!) gas power plant.
The US emits 14 million tons of CO2 per day, out of which 4 million comes from power plants.
Now, suppose Starship is very successful and they have 10 launches a day. That will certainly have some environmental inpact, though it would hardly be noticable at the national scale.
However! It would be silly to restrict Starship, for the very simple reason that we have no alternative for space travel, when we do have alternatives for energy generation.
The CO2 factor is basically nothing, one rocket flight would be on the order of 10 commercial jet flights. The problem is soot from non-hydrolox launch vehicles, black carbon deposited directly into the upper atmosphere which apparently has a greater effect on warming than all of commercial aviation's CO2 emissions combined.
Starship is methalox so it's somewhat more ecological than the kerosene burning falcon, but with the increased launch capacity, the rate at which it can deliver stuff to orbit, practically all of which eventually burns up in the upper atmosphere when EoL will likely have much more of a polluting effect in total.
It’s a lot of fuel and significantly more than a single flight uses, but there’s orders of magnitudes more flights, so no, it doesn’t make a huge difference right now. With massively increased cadence it might eventually.
Starship plus Booster load roughly 1000 tons of methane. We use roughly 1,000,000 tons of kerosene a day (world wide).
Starship launching at a high enough frequency to affect climate change would also allow it to solve climate change, first with orbital shades, then perhaps with space based solar (or orbital mirrors for increased production of ground based solar). At a minimum it's going to offset a lot of natural gas that would otherwise be used for data centers, assuming Starmind works out as well.
The environmental limit for Starship launches will not be CO2, but rather water deposition in the stratosphere and above. This will still require a hefty launch rate to reach.
This happens. You do a remarkable thing, and then... it's anti-climactic because having done it means it's not so remarkable. If it really is remarkable you do it again and then it's really not anymore.
It's a bit of a curse in that this really is remarkable and they made it look so easy it seems unremarkable, but then again if you're looking for highs in the sense of doing remarkable things then every time you succeed you end up reaching for more rather than being depressed that your remarkable accomplishments turn out to be unremarkable.
I was nine. I remember our black and white TV, the crackling from the picture tube's high voltage wiring adding a tang of ozone. We stayed up late that night.
Er, no. Nothing like it. Grabbed from your bed in the middle of the night, bundled downstairs to watch (grainy) and hear (crackly) weird things on a black-and-white TV, while adults, including strangers, whooped and shouted drunkenly. I understood the Apollo 11 thing only in the days after, through news reports. The live event was as impenetrable to me as a dream. Then again, I was half-asleep and five years old.
My grandma was one of the only person with a TV where she lived, half of the town was in her living room, nothing comparable. I bet most people watched this on their toilet seat before scrolling to the next cool thing as if it was nothing
Slight underperformance in the engines resulted in the the booster not reaching where it was supposed to be and the GNC systems automatically aborted to the gulf for safety.
Apparently the booster signaled it didn't have enough fuel to risk it. Either because it consumed more then expected on the way up, or a measurement error potentially.
They don't need to pay the mass penalty of landing legs, just some much lighter pins that stick out to the side.
The Falcon 9 landing legs were some excellent engineering, but scaled up to the size of starship they would weigh many tons (note the square-cube law makes them more unfavorable proportionally, not just massive considered amsolutely).
This would be a big deal for the booster, but it's absolutely vital for Starship itself because any additional dry mass subtracts directly from the payload (actually, it's even worse since it also increases the fuel needed for landing).
Another advantage is that it's better for reuse, as they don't have to spend hours or days restowing legs, recharging deployment cylinders and replacing crush cores.
> The strong gravity of Earth makes the physics of a fully reusable rocket with positive payload margin extremely difficult to solve, which is why it has never been done before.
> Removing the mass of landing legs from the booster and ship by making the tower do the work of final velocity attenuation greatly improves payload margin.
> This architecture also simultaneously substantially increases launch cadence, because the same arms that lift the booster and ship onto the launch stand also catch them, allowing immediate placement of the booster back on the launch stand and the ship back on top of the booster.
What amazes me is how many Raptor 2 and 3s are sitting on the bottom the gulf and the Indian Ocean. Dissecting a Raptor 3 in particular would be a real cheat code for anyone wanting to know how to build something similar! Metallurgy alone would be huge!
If it’s really that important, some Russian sub will be down there scavenging parts. If it’s really that important, a US sub will be there first blowing up the debris.
The amount of stress that these vehicles go through as they ascend to orbit and then descend back through the atmosphere to the surface is mind-boggling. To create a rapidly usable vehicle that can do this pushes the limits of material science.
There hasn’t been anything like this in humanity for a very long time. It’s so emotional to watch and see what we are capable of and the bright future ahead of us. Thank you for everyone who made this happen.
I feel like the first live HD stream of reentry plasma from the early Starship tests were slightly ahead of this in terms of awesomeness. Entering the atmosphere, everyone expects it to go dark for a couple of minutes, just like during every reentry in history... lo and behold Starlink sends a decent stream ( the first one wasn't perfect, second one was ).
Nice catch (NPI)! Unfortunately I think it's a bit more mundane, it'll be a piece of ice breaking off the lower section of the body. If you scrub through the footage, particularly earlier in the flight (e.g. 1:43:37 on the SpaceX stream, T+54:05) you'll see other pieces of ice flying off that look very similar.
Prior catches were for boosters. These were coming down after ~7 minutes of flight, reaching height of ~80km and top speed of ~6000km/hr. This latest catch was of the the Spaceship, after multiple orbits around the planet, from height of ~270km and top speed of ~27000km/hr, having to survive the much higher stress during the re-entry into atmosphere. I think the Spaceship is a bit heavier than the booster at the time of catch as well.
Edit: Spaceship is also more delicate than the booster. They have to be careful to not damage the tiles during the catch.
They've only ever caught the booster portion of the rocket, not the part that actually goes to space and orbits and returns. So, this is the first time they caught the upper stage
Radiators are too big and too expensive for space datacenters to make sense. Also rather than depreciating a GPU, you'll be depreciating a GPU, massive solar array, massive radiator, electronics and housing, and the launch cost to get it all there.
AI likely becomes much more efficient on earth than making sense in space for the foreseeable future.
I know engineering is about expediency, and price, but I’m still bummed that we aren’t getting ships with landing gear in this or likely the next generation of rockets either.
Seems that the heavier the rocket the more ground clearance to need to self-land, and so you can’t scale up the dragon’s landing system. I don’t think there’s anywhere near enough weight to shave off of the next rocket or enough specific impulse to add to bring the size back down.
I had to read the comment below (from u/modeless) before I realized by landing gear you meant the upright ones. I thought you wanted it to land sideways like a plane. (Arguably doable, though the control systems might add a lot more weight)
Yeah the Starship program isn't about landing on Mars or even going there.
It's about pumping mass into low Earth orbit, partly for commericial, but mostly military purposes such as Golden Dome. Been in the works for decades and finally here. The people who know are very excited.
I have no idea about Starship, but in one of the Environmental Assessment reports there was specific data on the fuel remaining in Falcon-9 after landing. It was <1270 kg of RP-1, which is equal to 14 seconds of firing at full thrust for one engine -- if one could use all of the fuel up, which is typically not possible. That was the upper bound.
I think Starship is like entering the wide-body jet age of aircraft. A lot of fine-tuning and efficiency gains from now until it's ubiquitous and cheap. But getting from that to another 10x gain is much harder, similar to aircraft where we haven't seen a "10x" jump since wide-body jets.
My bet: Moon based vehicle and propellant manufacturing. It's just so much easier to get stuff off of the moon that if you were going to build anything of any real size in space, the moon is where I'd get the bulk raw material given the choice.
In orbit refueling is likely next year. The goal is to have two shots at a moon landing in 2028.
And a nuclear ion rocket scheduled for 2028 as well.
The current NASA administrator is doing a good job getting rid of all the things keeping NASA from doing things. (And at least after Artemis II, both parties in congress seemed to be on his side.)
- longer in orbit missions for Starship of weeks or months. There are some non trivial issues with that probably; and you'd need that to not make refueling pointless.
- having two active launch sites. Nor strictly required but probably handy if you are going to have two Starships in orbit at the same time.
They might not get to all that in that order. But the important step today is that they get to inspect a "flight proven" Starship without water damage. I bet they are going to learn a lot of details of where exactly they need to iterate and improve. This took them some time with Falcon 9 as well. We've gotten used to this thing basically launching and landing without many issues. But that wasn't always the case. 2027 is probably going to see an increase launch rate.
Moon landings are going to be an interesting one because it depends on NASA as well and the decision making around that is very political. On the other hand, there's going to be increasing peer pressure from the Chinese. They have their own plans and it doesn't involve waiting for NASA to get there first. They are targeting 2030 for a manned mission. I expect the politics might get a bit more opinionated on that topic as that gets closer. The long term game here is not just landing and planting another flag but actually establishing a permanent presence on the moon. That involves flying useful payloads back and forth. Starship seems designed for that.
What happens after that is going to be an interesting one. IMHO, Starship is optimal for earth landings but not necessarily for the moon and Mars. What's currently flying is probably over engineered for a place with no atmosphere and one 6th of the gravity (the moon) or a very thin atmosphere and one third of the gravity (Mars). Would those flaps even work in the Mars atmosphere? However, it's a great launch vehicle to get components in space to build something more optimal. Also the booster might be used to launch other things than Starship. Like something that will never come down and can instead be fueled for deep space missions and Mars/Moon landings.
All I want are bigger and more cleverly located space telescopes, a couple of more probes and orbiters around other planets and asteroids, and I want those Mars samples that Percy has been pooping over the Mars surface returned to Earth and studied in a lab. And maybe a probe to Alpha Centauri or exo-planet viewers that use the Sun’s gravitational lensing in the next 5 or 6 decades.
I mean, you need to get money from somewhere to fund your dreams.
If it's datacenters in space then let be it. They are pretty cool as well. It seems a lot of people don't like them on Earth.
Only recently I read how the dust on Mars surface is toxic, contains those unhealthy ultrafine particles (PM2.5 and PM0.10) and sticks to almost all surfaces. It will be difficult to keep from getting inside a habitat.
And how the Apollo astronauts got "lunar hay fever", allergy-like symptoms from
the lunar dust that stuck outside their space suits and so got carried inside their lunar module.
What actually is the point of all this? I'm not trying to be a snarky contrarian, I've never had any interest whatsoever in space, star trek, "what's out there?", so I genuinely don't get it.
I'm not trashing people's interests, obviously I am the odd man out in not giving a damn, I just don't see what we're trying to achieve when there are so many issues we can't even figure out on earth.
It’s very cool and an amazing technological achievement. But I cannot stop thinking - do we need it? I know that’s a minority take. How much of a minority?
Launch itself isn't super profitable and doesn't have a very big TAM, especially if you carefully treat the TAM as a present value and discount future cash flows. Also, at least by my personal guesswork, Starlink alone shouldn't get close to a $1 trillion valuation. It seems like the current valuation is based on people's guesses about the likelihood that space data centers pan out in a big way.
We've seen the booster landing/catch before, but seeing the ship do it with the belly flop definitely looked cooler to me. I still remember the awe of watching two boosters land at the same time after a heavy launch. Watching the transition from bellyflop to landing gave me the same awe and being impressed.
Congrats to SpaceX engineers! But for those who are not fans of the guy at the top here's a video of Blue Origin landing their rocket. Competition is good!
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/XjSmNf3y37U
Kind of crazy to reduce the hardware on ship so much and move so much complexity to the ground. This can really only happen in a situation where anybody can throw out any dumb idea, because if you suggested this 20 years ago people would think you are an idiot.
That's...the point. You can hire commercial welders to work on the ground side and build everything out once, cheaply.
The issue with the shuttle era was that they needed huge teams of specialized technicians to refurbish the insanely complex orbiter after every mission.
If we ever get sufficiently improved materials science for heat shields and engines there's still always a possibility of returning to the SSTO space plane concept. That would allow a more austere launch and recovery environment, but given current limitations this is the local maxima.
>This can really only happen in a situation where anybody can throw out any dumb idea, because if you suggested this 20 years ago people would think you are an idiot.
Indeed.
Musk's biographer tweeted the pages from his book <https://x.com/WalterIsaacson/status/1844870018351169942> discussing how in late 2020 Musk suggested, then insisted against considerable opposition from his engineers, that Superheavy be caught with chopsticks instead of landing on legs like Falcon 9.
Also according to the book, Musk is the person who suggested and, against considerable opposition from his engineers, insisted on Starship switching to stainless steel instead of carbon fiber <https://x.com/richardprice100/status/1728106606616015097>.
(Hint to others: Musk was right and his engineers were wrong. Both times.)
I wish them good luck. Now we wait and see how many times they can do it without accident for either the ship or the booster. Propulsion by a controlled explosion is a fickle beast so I suspect the mileage will vary and I wonder how would future launch and landing failures (which I expect will unfortunately happen) will impact the programme in general.
Honestly if this thread had the actual number of points it deserved based on the kind of milestone this represents for humanity's future and access to space, it would be in the millions.
If you don't follow rocketry you can't possibly understand what this means.
This was the Trinity test.
And even if you hate Elon and all his businesses, this knowledge will proliferate. Either by talent movement / osmosis, by espionage or just being inspired ("if they can do it, maybe we have a chance as well").
Within a decade the average cost to LEO will drop 20x-50x and if you're not recovering both of your stages, you don't exist.
> And even if you hate Elon and all his businesses, this knowledge will proliferate. Either by talent movement / osmosis, by espionage or just being inspired ("if they can do it, maybe we have a chance as well").
It doesn't need to proliferate. It has existed in us for a very long time, albeit working the kinks out would take time.
The major factor on the trajectory space goes is a financial question, not a technological one. And it always has been this way.
Elon is a terrible person that's done a lot of bad for humanity (but also some good). But he's damn good at convincing people to fund his shit and so we get cool rockets until he goes out of favour.. probably that happens when we hit critical mass on the space pollution he puts up into our sky.
Previously they successfully caught the booster returning to the launch site from ~100 km about ~10 minutes from launch.
Here they caught the upper stage ,called starhip, which went to ~260 km orbit, deployed 50 tons of satellites and after 22 hours shed its orbital velocity and manuevered to be caught with centimeter precision. :)
It is very impressive that they can control the return trajectory accurately enough for a tower catch, and to coordinate the arms on the tower (which are very slow and heavy), to grab the rocket without damaging it.
But this was already convincingly demonstrated by catching the booster three times.
It is very hard to return the second stage from the orbit due to its vastly greater kinetic energy. Protecting the rocket from the heating during the reentry is something that has never been done until SpaceX started to practice with the Starship.
But they have already demonstrated this feat before, with pinpoint landings into the ocean.
The significance of today's event is mostly in demonstrating that they have such a high confidence in this system that they were able to satisfy the safety requirements for obtaining a licence to fly the Starship return trajectory over the populated landmass, crossing Mexican territory on the way to the tower. This is the cherry on the cake. Now all the pieces are in place, and once the remaining wrinkles in the system are ironed out, we can expect the flights to become routine, and eventually, the reuse of Starship to become routine as well.
The other, somewhat more modest, but still important milestone was that they kept the Starship in orbit for a whole day, and after that they still had the fuel for a deorbit and the landing burns. It did not all boil off.
Edit: Here is an interview with Lars Blackmore, the guy in charge of Entry, Descent, and Landing (EDL) for Starship, where he talks about flying the descent over land for the first time: https://youtu.be/POrMxoZbXVI?t=390
It's difficult to underline how huge this is. This marks the first time in the history of rocketry that the upper stage of a rocket has returned home from orbit to a safe, upright landing.
(And to preempt the obvious objection: yes, maybe you can call the Space Shuttle an "upper stage of a rocket" if you squint hard enough, but it didn't do upright landings, its external tank was not reusable and even the Shuttle itself was effectively rebuilt from scratch at exorbitant cost each time.)
It's sad to see a lot of media missing the point, eg as I type this BBC is reporting this as "SpaceX successfully catches part of Starship rocket on its return to Earth".
Edit: corrected to note that the SRBs were reusable, but the ET was not.
Notably, they were reusable! Sure, they had to refurbish them, same with the shuttle’s main engines. The only thing they threw away was the external tank which didn’t have any engines.
Whatever you call it, the Shuttle Orbiter wasn’t a complete stage in any case. It needed the external tank, which was never recovered.
SpaceX has now demonstrated all the pieces of a fully reusable launcher. Next comes putting them all together in the same flight, and hopefully demonstrating that the flights can become frequent and cheap. There’s no guarantee of that, but it’s looking good.
> yes, maybe you can call the Space Shuttle an "upper stage of a rocket" if you squint hard enough
Why wouldn't it count? It is not the first time in the history of rocketry that the part that is not the boosters returns home intact.
Sure, you can say "it's the first time in the history of rocketry that it lands upright", but you could also say "it's the first time in the history of rocketry that it is not white".
If you want to say how huge this is, tell me how different it is from landing the boosters. Because from the outside it sure as hell looks very similar.
I am trying to understand what's the big deal about this, other that massive weight and the money involved. The way I see it is software controls the fuel output and motion control. The only other challenge I have been hearing about is the heat shield. Other that this what's really special about the spaceship. The number of modules and the complexity seems not that huge. Any error or miscalculation in here is very costly and that is the only thing seems to be the bottleneck here.
Nice! I wonder how the engineering involved here compares to the engineering behind manufacturing TSMC chips (including ASML machines, Zeiss optics etc.). Which is harder?
As it seems building rockets has historically been a capital intensive business with low profits and limited demand, so there just wasn't much competition in the space industry.
I would say that they're orthogonal except for the requirement for exacting results and standards. Doing anything once is hard. Doing anything repeatably is hard^2.
just finished watching the new documentary about musk. not that ive learned anything new. its so sad that engineering achievements like these are being shadowed, at least for some people like myself, with the figure that runs these companies.
nevertheless, the people who made it work should be proud of themselves.
Reusable stages is very neat, but seems a little crazy to pay the tyranny of the rocket equation twice. I heard one person say that carrying fuel to land over the whole flight means it takes 23x more launches to get an equivalent payload to orbit.
Using modern technology, couldn't disposable first stages be produced much more cheaply than during the space race?
How much of modern manufacturing disposable booster's cost would be fuel vs metal?
It's not paying it twice. The rocket equation is about the ratio of the wet and dry mass, so for an expendable rocket you're always limited by the fact that there's an upper stage (and for the second stage the payload etc).
This is why SpaceX cares more about TWR for their engines than traditional rockets did. It goes from making a negligible difference to a huge component of how much fuel they need to keep for landing.
The 23x more launches figure comes from HLS (Nasa sponsored mission to the moon). They may well change the configuration of that anyway, but if you want to refuel in orbit, that's what it costs. It's hard to get fuel to orbit (or any sort of payload). Previous Moon missions haven't refueled anything, but they couldn't return anything heavy from the moon's surface, the vehicle got smaller and smaller as it went and many parts were left behind, so it's not comparable. You can be sure if it's cheaper to somehow do this mission with expendable boosters, they'll think about doing that.
On a normal mission just to earth orbit, there is one booster and one starship, and reusing the booster is more a question of why not save some money for a little more propellant use? The reususable booster doesn't contribute much extra weight, it uses little propellant for boostback and landing.
The booster also doesn't go all the way and you need a booster if you're going to reach orbit (due to that equation), so it doesn't take much to make it reusable. So all in all, why not make it reusable if you can? What would you save from using expendable ones?
"I heard one person say that carrying fuel to land over the whole flight means it takes 23x more launches to get an equivalent payload to orbit."
I don't think that this is the case when using the atmosphere to shed most of your velocity, which is what we do when landing on Earth. Propulsive braking would be another story, but you can avoid that on bodies that do have some atmosphere. In our proximity, only the Moon and Mercury would need propulsive braking, but Moon's gravity is low and Mercury is hard to visit anyway.
That said, once you use the atmosphere to cushion what is basically a fall, the weight of the necessary heat shield comes to the equation too.
That 23x number is trivially refuted simply by looking at the fact that this flight delivered 52 tons of cargo to orbit. Could a similarly sized expendable rocket like the Saturn V deliver 1196 tons?
It doesn't take the same amount of fuel to land as it does to lift.
Speaking as a Kerbal Space program playing, internet commentor, It's probably <1% of the fuel to briefly counteract terminal velocity as it is to lift off and reach space.
How is it twice? Braking on the way down doesn't take nearly as much fuel as lift off so the "tyranny of the rocket equation" should be paid only once.
If the fuel (+ oxidizer) ends up costing as much as 1% of the cost of launching a conventional single-use rocket then the people behind it will be very happy. That means that their rocket (+ cost of ground facilities + all the people prepping the rocket and monitoring the launch) is very cheap.
The fuel (+ oxidizer) is basically free compared to all the other costs.
We don't have to look past it. Musk said it failed because engine underperformance caused too little fuel margin. He added that they have upgrades due on future flights.
If they ran out of fuel with 50 tons of payload it certainly begs the question of whether they will get to the goal of 100 tons of payload even with upgrades.
They also had engine fail on boostback. Reliability has been a persistent problem, they'll have to fix it for refueling and manned operations.
You could go to LinkedIn and look at people in the:
* structures
* propulsion
* avionics
* flight software
departments, because they all work together to make this happen, along with support from IT/SRE. The person most responsible for ensuring that it happens is Lars Blackmore[1], who was also the Responsible Engineer in charge of making sure Falcon 9 landed successfully
He's actively holding the program back at this point. Top engineers in this industry are increasingly reluctant to join a company with a such a toxic culture and public reputation tainted by musk.
Congrats to the everyone involved (more than just engineers!).
Here's hoping Musk gets kicked before he sinks this project too, as he's already severely burdened it with his short-sighted fascistic endeavors. As a formerly very enthusiastic follower of SpaceX's activities the specter of Musk's evil beliefs really ruins the messaging of making progress for all of humanity.
Elon Musk is a real life version of D.D. Harriman, the protagonist of Heinlein's The Man Who Sold the Moon. An excerpt taken from Wikipedia:
""I", he says, "would cheat, lie, steal, beg, bribe—do anything to accomplish what we have accomplished". Children donate money for a promise of all contributors' names engraved on a plaque left on the Moon. The names, however, will be microscopic in size. Harriman sells land and naming rights to craters, and plans to sell postal covers canceled on the Moon to collectors. He starts rumors that diamonds exist in moondust, intending to secretly place gems in the rocket to convince people that the rumors are true."
And anyone who's read Machiavelli knows what kind of man it takes to succeed at this level in non-fiction.
Given the fact that men of his abilities and motivations have existed throughout history, and will continue to exist as long as we have men, for all his perceived flaws I'm quite pragmatically relieved he is ensconced with a Western power rather than any other in the world.
I've been a frequent critic of starship. But the significance of this milestone is clear: it's the first demonstration of a reusable upper stage of a rocket system since the space shuttle.
Part of the importance is due to the fact that while the space shuttle was a technical success in terms of being able to build and operate a reusable upper stage, it was hella expensive. It required a lot of expensive refurbishment between missions. Launch cadence had a fairly low upper bound. And it wasn't safe enough.
The true believers will claim that catching a starship upper stage marks a new era. It marks the possibility of a new era. It proves it is plausible that a vertical landing upper stage could possibly be a better approach than a space plane. But it hasn't proven any of that. There are about a dozen major milestones between here and actually having a rocket system that meets all of its claimed specifications, both technical and financial. Here's just one big hairy example: to fly manned missions, starship either needs to be redesigned to accommodate an escape system, or it needs to show a level of reliability and safety never previously achieved by a rocket.
In my estimation, it will take at least another five years to know what starship really can do and what it will cost.
> what starship really can do and what it will cost.
The previous flight launched 20 sats and that is the equivalent (in Starlink bandwidth) to 10x F9 launches.
This one launched 26 sats. That'd be 13x F9 launches in Starlink bw.
F9 internal cost is 20M$.
Starship stack is rumoured to cost ~100M$ to build.
If they can launch a stack once every month, they've already achieved more "capacity" for Starlink than their best year using F9s (last year). At half the price.
So that's already proven, even if nothing else works (i.e. reusability, etc). But of course they'll keep working the problem and make it work. They're also scaling at a crazy pace (3 more pads in various stages of readiness, plus even more planned in the next ~5 years). They've just finished the gigabay and they're planning even more in Louisiana.
Anything they do from here on out is "the cherry on top".
> it's the first demonstration of a reusable upper stage of a rocket system since the space shuttle.
And even Space Shuttle wasn't a demonstration of that, since the propellant tankage (the largest volume of any stage) wasn't reusable.
SpaceX has pretty conclusively shown the Shuttle architecture (stage and a half, using LH2 at launch) was not the right choice.
> to fly manned missions, starship either needs to be redesigned to accommodate an escape system, or it needs to show a level of reliability and safety never previously achieved by a rocket.
I assume they'll do the latter. If the vehicle is truly rapidly reusable, that's less crazy than it sounds. Just fly it 10,000 times and fix all the problems you find :) Escape systems are only really useful during launch anyway. The only way to protect the crew from a failure during reentry is reliability.
>And it wasn't safe enough.
How are you measuring "safe enough" in this context? My understanding is that the Shuttle didn't have programmatic probabilistic requirements for mission safety. Ie, they didn't use overall reliability estimates and instead relied on engineering judgement (which the Challenger report showed varied widely depending on who you interviewed). It's hard to make a claim on whether it was safe enough without explicitly defining the safety goal.
Early 1970s documents were given safety requirements of 1:20 flights being successful. [1] That's the closest I've found to an actual requirement, and the shuttle record falls well within that requirement. I do think such an early spec is not a good basis for final performance, though.
[1] page 326: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/19700005884/downloads/19...
I think it is obvious by now that Starship was not designed for manned missions and that it was designed to provide cheap launch capabilities for very large payload capacity.
Flight 13 launched 20 Starlink v3 sats for a total payload of 34,100 kg.
Flight 14 launched 26 Starlink v3 sats for a total payload of 44,330 kg.
The Space Shuttle's max payload capacity was only 22,780kg (https://i.redd.it/8t8j1n4032lh1.png)
Idk imo the hard part is catching the giant rocket, everything else is “known”
> needs to show a level of reliability and safety never previously achieved by a rocket.
Why does it need to be so much more reliable/safe than any other rocket that's existed before?
Seems unfair to hold it to a different standard than anything else?
> it's the first demonstration of a reusable upper stage of a rocket system since the space shuttle
I'd argue not quite yet. They've shown that they can catch the upper stage and that of course is a big milestone and improves the chances of getting a reusable system tremendously. A demonstration of a reusable upper stage requires them to successfully re-fly a previously used upper stage. The catch demonstration is a very good step in that direction, but not quite yet (in my opinion).
The biggest problem they need to solve at this time is making the thermal tiles more damage resistant. At this time too many ceramic tiles get damaged and need replacement, repair or refurbishment just like with the Space Shuttle. That makes the dream of rapid reuse and lower launch costs unattainable.
I wonder why SpaceX didn't pioneer metal-ceramic or metallic heat shielding.
I'd respect your criticisms much more if they were more accurate, of if when shown to be inaccurate, you acknowledged that. But it seems like you just move from one criticism to another and ignore your mistakes.
For example, on flight 14 you claimed that SpaceX fudged their payload numbers by not fully fueling the satellites.[1] I pointed out that this must be false for two reasons: 1. Propellant is less than 5% of the mass of the satellites and 2. The FAA requires accurate masses for debris assessments.
You also suggested that flight 14 wasn't fully fueled to allow for RTLS, but the amount of propellant burned is the same for a water landing and a tower landing. The only difference is when they do the reentry burn.
Other times you've claimed that Starship hasn't met its payload goals. But Starship currently delivers a half payload because when launching from Texas, it must perform a dogleg maneuver to avoid flying over populated areas (such as Cuba). When they start launching from Florida, they they'll be able to put 100 tons into orbit per launch.[2]
You've also claimed that Starlink's addressable market is shrinking because terrestrial wireless will expand.[3] But a cell tower costs about 1/3rd as much as a V2 mini and can't serve nearly as many customers in rural areas. So even with Falcon 9, Starlink outcompetes cell towers in areas with low population density. If Starship lowers launch costs more by being reusable, then the tradeoff will favor Starlink in more areas, not fewer. The only way to reduce Starlink's TAM would be if cell towers somehow became much cheaper.
Even today you've claimed that the ship's engines don't have a heat shield.[4] But if you look at images of Starship or watch videos of reentry, you can see the engines are enclosed by the aft skirt. They already need to shield the engines for reentry because they operate during the landing burn.
These sorts of mistakes make it much harder to lend credence to your conclusions. Yes the Starship program has taken much longer than SpaceX planned, but if the program is going to be successful in the long term, outcomes like flight 15 are exactly what one should expect to see.
1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49893773
2. https://arstechnica.com/space/2026/11/spacex-now-fundamental... "Dontchev said a single Florida Starship launch will be able to carry up to 20 times the bandwidth of a single Falcon 9." SpaceX currently claims that each Starship launch carries 10x the bandwidth of a Falcon 9 launch, so this would put them at around 100 tons of payload.
3. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45617326
4. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50510264
> to fly manned missions, starship either needs to be redesigned to accommodate an escape system, or it needs to show a level of reliability and safety never previously achieved by a rocket.
Falcon rockets don't seem to be exploding on ascent anymore, they're doing 2-3 launches per week now, no explosions in a decade.
Perhaps an escape system could be deployed from the dorsal side of Starship, too.
Given their track record of achieving the impossible, I wouldn't bet against SpaceX as they head towards commercial deployment of Starship.
> I've been a frequent critic of starship
Sir, you are a programmer of Java applications for mobile phones. You’ve had an impressive career, and are a person I am honored to look up to, but please have some humility
I still feel like I am living in the future when I see these catches, but that last flip to vertical it does as it decelerates looks like everyone would be leaving their lunch all round the inside of the rocket.
> to fly manned missions, starship either needs to be redesigned to accommodate an escape system, or it needs to show a level of reliability and safety never previously achieved by a rocket.
What makes you think humans will be the primary passengers? My bet is they will send Optimus for the majority of "manned" missions, especially 5 years from now
I wouldn't fly on one for a very long time. They aren't close to being reliable.
>to fly manned missions, starship either needs to be redesigned to accommodate an escape system, or it needs to show a level of reliability and safety never previously achieved by a rocket.
Starship doesn’t need a 1960's style launch escape system. The whole ship is the crew vehicle. If the booster fails, Starship separates and flies away on its own Raptors. That’s the plan SpaceX has stuck with for years. NASA requires high reliability and failure tolerance for crewed flights, not a regulatorily mandated escape system.
If you extrapolate the safety record of Falcon onto Starship, which seems conservative given that Starship is going to be their focus, it will be far safer than the Space Shuttle.
The Space Shuttle blew up 2 out of 135 flights, 1.5%. Falcon has 3 blow-ups out of 720+ flights. That's more than 20x as safe, and includes the aggressive/early R&D.
Starship is still being developed. Unless they go under somehow, it's going to be safer than the Space Shuttle by similar orders of magnitude.
> Here's just one big hairy example: to fly manned missions, starship either needs to be redesigned to accommodate an escape system, or it needs to show a level of reliability and safety never previously achieved by a rocket.
I bet there are lots of people willing to fly on Starship even if it had Falcon 9’s level of reliability even without an escape system.
Ironically I think it's going to take as long as the Space Shuttle did to get to first orbital flight. And be less safe.
Blatant moving of the goal posts. HN is so prone to this, that much is clear. Another example of how HN is prone to this is regarding LLM denialists.
> Part of the importance is due to the fact that while the space shuttle was a technical success in terms of being able to build and operate a reusable upper stage, it was hella expensive.
This is a complete apples to oranges comparison.
A more apt comparison would be the space shuttle being a kin to Vasco da Gama's discovery of the sea route to India. After that point, the concept was demonstrated and the challenge was in optimizing cost-savings of commercial endeavours.
I mean, orbital lift services have been a thing for how many decades?
> while the space shuttle was a technical success in terms of being able to build and operate a reusable upper stage, it was hella expensive
stop repeating this lie, please
shuttle costs per-launch were on falcon 9 level
the only reason for the cost was lack of payloads (!) to spread per-year costs
there's a reason why spaceX now gets far far FAR largest part of its income from Starlink and most most MOST of its launches are Starlink. It's sattelite company with launch side business
If the heat shield holds up then this changes everything. Next step is double catch and re-flying the same ships and catching again, then payloads to orbit become significantly cheaper opening a new era in space flight.
Yeah, I'm eagerly awaiting results from inspection of the heat shield (which hopefully they will disclose). Reflight without refurbishment is the last goal they need to hit before the system can be considered a success. After that, optimizing for increased payload and nailing reliability will be the things to work on. And of course orbital refueling for HLS.
Even if it doesn't meet their goals of rapid reuse, I think we've still joined the new era. Replacing tiles is going to be substantially cheaper than building new upper stages, likely less than the cost of fuel for a launch.
Why is catching them by better than landling them to the degree that it would open a new space era?
Even if they haven't completely solved it. They have shown they can strip the old heat shield off, and put an entirely new design of heat shield on a ship in under 2 weeks. I believe that was one of the doomed block 2 ships that blew up in the Caribbean so it never got to re-entry.
Falcon9 already made it a lot cheaper but i don't see much market opening up? other then launching their starlink's
I've been thinking about the catch system and I don't think the risks and problems are being properly accounted for.
For anyone unfamiliar, the Falcon 9 first stage booster reuse comes from landing the booster on a barge or on land and then recovering it and refurbishing it. Because the engines use RP1, there is coking and this is more expensive and slower to refurbish. Raptor engines use LNG instead to avoid coking but this is also more complex because now you have two cryogenic fuels instead of one (the other being liquid oxygen obviously).
The barges are ideal because the first stages will exhaust their fuel over the Atlantic. To land back at the pad they need to retain more fuel. This hurts payloads. But you have choices. Barges are relatively cheap. On land you can basically land on a relatively cheap concrete pad.
to have the structure and fins required to not collapse when landing, it adds an estimated 10% to the weight. That's a big deal. It's also why Starship opted for the catch system.
But here's the problem: you have to land back somewhere where you have a catcher. What happens if the catcher is down? Or the booster is suffering a fault (eg enough engines won't fire up so it isn't stable)? The catcher itself is a complicated and expensive engineering exercise. It's why on a recent test launch they opted for a water landing instead.
To have manned missions you're going to need redundancy. That means more than one catcher available most likely. You need an escape system if the booster itself is faulty. You risk the catcher every time you use it. All of that gets expensive in a way that landing on a barge or concrete pad doesn't.
This changes nothing, in space fuel transfer between ships is the make it or break it.
How many payloads are we going to put in the orbit before we end up with a new set of problem?
> new era in space flight
More like a new era in littering space.
Huge congratulations to the engineering team on this one! It's been quite interesting to watch the evolution of Starship. Had they put another couple of tonnes of propellant and oxidizer on the Booster they might have caught both of them. It is still unclear to me what the final mass fraction to orbit will work out to be, but something that is 100% re-usable is better than something 60% reusable[1].
[1] Estimate of Falcon 9's booster + fairings being 60% (by cost, not by mass) of the launch package.
It looks like they delivered 50 tons today. Even if it stays this way, it will still reduce price to orbit significantly.
To everyone who works at SpaceX and read this. You are all amazing.
I hope other great minds at SpaceX are well remembered into the far future.
Agreed its a great time to be alive!
[flagged]
[flagged]
Insane achievement! It is the dawn of a new era! One that has been 10+ years in the making.
I still remember watching Falcon 9 (Block V, iirc) successfully landing back on land (as opposed to droneships) after deploying Orbcomm OG2 satellites in December 2015 -- almost 11 years ago.
It blew my teen mind.
This day marks a fabulous advancement for the human species.
I'll be that guy: they still have to fly it again. That's the real question. Incredible achievement. We got used to landing and caught boosters real quick!
I'm still not really convinced this is better than a space-shuttle style landing.
Seems like the same design principles that goes into Starship could create a version with more aerodynamic surface.
Is the idea that Starhship will be considered safe enough for human crews?
I like that they wrote "dont panic" on the fuselage above the s42 badge
I guess it has to be a reference to A Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy, which is one of Elon's favorite books. In the story, the answer to life, universe and everything is 42, and the guidebook carries “Don’t Panic” on its cover. The ship is S42, so the match is clear.
[flagged]
Did it carry a towel?
Starship is, essentially, Space Shuttle done right: fully reusable booster without solid boosters (avoids Challenger disaster) and orbiter stacked on top instead of on the side (avoid Columbia disaster).
The original designs for the Space Shuttle had the booster (with wings!) return to the launch site, but the cost for two new crewed vehicles was too large, so they scaled it back to the compromised version.
Even more revolutionary, compared to Shuttle, Starship is built on an assembly line. They can build a booster ever 4 weeks and a ship every 2 weeks.
The future we were promised in the 1970s is about to become real.
I agree this is a good approach.
But the Shuttle became what it became for reasons that Starship doesn’t have to deal with. Shuttle had multiple masters (NASA and DoD) driving a bastardized design. The non-assembly line of NASA is a feature, not a bug: by spreading work across many congressional districts it mitigates political defunding risk. Im not defending those, but they are important context for those who pretend the differences are a signal of government incompetence.
Private industry tends to be far more efficient at making “stuff that works” than a non-profit governmental organization.
Even for all the genuinely good and smart people that worked for NASA over the decades, the bureaucratic machinery that makes it run eventually becomes so convoluted, corrupt and bloated for its own good.
I should know; I worked there for over a quarter of a century. Nothing beats the private industry for “making shit that works.”
Space shuttle was a reliable recovery vehicle too.
I see a need for maintenance crews and large payload recovery in the future.
Starship doesn't seem like the tool for that, and no tool is in development for it TMK?
The Space Shuttle took 2 people into orbit on its first launch and returned them safely to earth. On the first attempt. On the first test of any of the hardware into space. In 1981.
Starship did not and has not done that and until it does I will continue to hold reservations.
I do not see this Starship and its mission profile ever being a human-rated system in this incarnation, ever.
A really cheap way to launch mass into LEO? Sure, I'll give it that.
> Starship is, essentially, Space Shuttle done right
There's lots to praise here, but they haven't flown a single manned mission yet
(Also hindsight is 20:20)
> without solid boosters (avoids Challenger disaster) and orbiter stacked on top instead of on the side (avoid Columbia disaster)
We know of the failure modes of the Shuttle, we don't know about the failures of Starship
Or better, the two obvious ones: it will fail to be caught or it will fail to bellyflop
And of course Starship benefits immensely from computers getting thousands of times better and lighter (and cheaper)
> Even more revolutionary, compared to Shuttle, Starship is built on an assembly line
Yes this is a big win
> The original designs for the Space Shuttle had the booster (with wings!) return to the launch site, but the cost for two new crewed vehicles was too large, so they scaled it back to the compromised version.
Can you cite a source for this claim? My understanding is that the control algorithms for landing a rocket did not exist at the time of the space shuttle. The algorithms were invented in 2010s[1] and space shuttle operated from 1981-2011[2]
[1] https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/6428631
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Shuttle
>> Even more revolutionary, compared to Shuttle, Starship is built on an assembly line. They can build a booster ever 4 weeks and a ship every 2 weeks.
Note that they are also scaling up production in a big way, because they want to launch weekly soon, and then daily. Not sure if we will get to the latter anytime soon but I'm also not going to bet against Elon.
Reusability is all about cost savings. The real question now is how much does it cost to turn Starship around for reuse - how much heat shield replacement, how do the vaccuum raptor engines survive the thermal cycling, what is the lifetime of parts involved in the catch mechanism, etc.
In any case, a cool spectacle.
Incredible, had no idea they were assembled so quickly.
I don't think you intended to dis the space shuttle (much) but it's important to recognize that half a century has passed since the start of the shuttle design process. Comparing the two is like comparing the 747 to the Ford Tri-motor.
I think you forget that in Apollo time all people ever wanted was to get out of earth and see what's actually out there, with human presence. All the other stuff, would be done later, like this.
What’s the alternative to building on an assembly line? Is there a “theory” of the assembly line building relative to more ad-hoc approaches?
It's funny how people can look at the exact same program and draw wildly different conclusions. From where I'm sitting, Starship is a deeply flawed and highly risky program with an uncertain future. There are two keys problems:
1. It's not clear what the product-market fit for Starship really is, specifically there is limited demand for these super-heavy payloads. What's my evidence? Falcon Heavy. It averages about 1 launch a year, typically by the military, compared to >100 for Falcon 9.
There are five standard counterarguments to this:
a) "You can carry multiple payloads." Most of the time this simply isn't true. The payloads have to be on almost identical orbits for this to work. Different inclination? No shot. Different altitude? Almost no shot. This brings us to the second;
b) "But Starlink." Yes, Starlink can take advantage of this although to justify its massive expansion, Starlink really has to launch a satellite-based handheld mobile phone network and it has to be pretty much global. It's unclear if this can be from a legal and regulatory standpoint or if it will be able to effectively compete with traditional terrestrial 5G networks. It's unclear what customer density can be supported;
c) "It will induce demand for bigger payloads." Falcon Heavy is relatively cheap, particularly compared to the alternatives from Ariane and ULA yet launch cadence is still particularly slow. Satellites, which are the bread and butter of commercial rocketry, just don't need to be that big;
d) "Starship will replace Falcon 9 launches." Yes, but other companies will fill the Falcon 9 gap if SpaceX abandons it. If you're only carrying one payload to LEO (or even geostationary orbit) and you can do that with a smaller launch system that you can reuse, it's simply going to be better eventually; and
e) "Space based AI data centers." This is never going to happen. it doesn't make any sense. You can't get enough power or distribute the heat. You're subject to cosmic rays and solar radiation, which the atmosphere otherwise mostly protects you from, and you have no way to economically service the inevitable failures.
2. The whole Mars thing is BS, basically, kinda like space-based data centers. It's not happening. There's absolutely no reason to go;
3. Starship isn't suited for lunar missions, which is one reason (IMHO) why Elon tried to scuttle NASA's lunar program [1]. Basically, a 40 meter high vessel that has to land horizontally is hard to land, hard to get in and out of (with your astronauts 40 meters off the surface) and much harder to get off the Moon and back to Earth.
4. Between (2) and (3) a whole lot of new capabilities have to be developed anyway, none of which have even begun yet (eg in-orbit refueling).
Now the one really useful thing from the Starship program (IMHO) is the Raptor engine. For context, the Falcon 9's Merlin engine used oxygen and RP-1 (kerosene, basically). Only the oxygen had to be kept really cold. But it has coking issues (ie solid carbon build up from the RP-1 being consumed). Raptor replaces RP-1 with LNG. No coking but now you have two cryogenic fuels instead of one.
[1]: https://futurism.com/elon-musk-scrap-nasa-moon-program
Starship is effectively another falling car that doesn't crash.
It's taken 100 years for humans to build a rocket that lands itself.
Gonna take even longer to establish a humans on Mars.
Ya need supply lines, radiation shielding, water... all in the next 2-3 decades if you want any shot at seeing it.
There's no guarantee future generations can justify the effort, resource use.
Yall gonna stay around 2-3 more generations to make sure they do?
The space shuttle is infinitely sexier sorry
Challenger and Columbia were caused by Normalization of Deviance and groupthink. How did they solve those problems?
The reusable Starship will carry 100+ tons of weight or 1100 cubic meters of volume per launch.
Obligatory “what’s wrong with space shuttle” link: https://idlewords.com/2005/08/a_rocket_to_nowhere.htm
Government had to get out of the way. A visionary from Private Sector like Elon Musk was needed
[flagged]
[dead]
[dead]
Let me know when Starship makes it to the moon. Apollo got there after 2 launches. and only had 1x problem and everyone got home.
"fully reusable" is highly aspirational.
They have barely reflown a handful of tiles, and have not reflown any engines.
Essentially, the two things you'd expect to break will probably still break.
It'll become real whether we want it or even benefits us or not. Nothing we can do but trust the billionaires.
Just watched the catch stream live on the dome of a local planetarium - really feeling history is being made.
It was all so symbolic, they just had a talk about the Voyager probe reaching one light day from Earth accompanied by screening of the Startrek movie (which includes V'ger/Voyager) and ad hoc decided to stream the catch just after the movie ended.
Was a really surreal experience, first watching the tiny Enterprise zooming around the vast V'ger spacecraft only to see Starship zooming through the clouds and getting caught, all on the same planetarium dome projection! :-)
Which planetarium showed this, if you don't mind answering? If it's near me I'd love to attend!
If this makes even me want to go study engineering I know it will inspire millions of youngsters into making the future we all want. Bravo!
The engineering of this is just mind boggling awesome. The culmination of so many fields, so many factors, to this. Congrats!!!
It is. It's a great achievement for Gwynne Shotwell.
Nothing new. Flight controls and automatic navigation of a high speed ballistic missle is much more impressive and had existed for decades.
> bind boggling
mind bottling
Interestingly, there's a similar large "block" recovery rig in the South China Sea. They use two sets of steel cables running in the X and Y directions — visually it's a lot like the Japanese cat's cradle string game. From a quick search, it appears to have shown up after SpaceX's chopsticks catch. Different engineering approach, but the same idea of catching the returning stage in a grid rather than with arms.
TIL that the Chinese have also started catching rockets out at sea.
I had trouble visualizing your comment until I saw 2 YouTube videos from another commenter down thread of their alternate rocket catching mechanism.
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/GJ-wZLLuh9M
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zt1V9UWhuKk
From https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50502490
this doesn't make sense for Starship - Starship is RTLS (return to launch site), and a cable/net catch system creates an unnecessarily complex launch tower.
The cable catch system for long march 10B is superior to the landing legs of falcon 9 - of the 11 falcon 9 failures, a cable catch system would have avoided 4-6 of them. Removing the landing legs also reduces the rocket dry mass and increases payload mass to orbit.
If SpaceX did Falcon 9 again, they would likely use a cable catch system, as it resolves about half of falcon 9's historic landing failures.
The rocket that system catches (Long March 10B) is the size of Falcon 9. Starship is an order of magnitude larger and heavier. It may not be a practical solution for a significantly larger scale rocket.
Yeah, it makes the chopsticks look unnecessarily unforgiving.
Watched it with my 5 year old daughter (3 year old son was sadly uninterested), and we were both cheering and high fiving. Very exciting.
Does someone with more knowledge than me know if the co2 emissions from these kinds of rocket launches are big enough to make frequently launching and re-launching rockets into space a problem re. climate change? That’s a refrain I hear frequently but have no idea how true it is.
Not an issue.
There's about a thousand tons of methane on starship which come out to about 2750 tons of CO2.
For reference an average natural gas power plant produces 2000 tons 10000 tons of CO2 every day.
So if you fly a starship once per day that's as bad as one (1!) gas power plant.
The US emits 14 million tons of CO2 per day, out of which 4 million comes from power plants.
Now, suppose Starship is very successful and they have 10 launches a day. That will certainly have some environmental inpact, though it would hardly be noticable at the national scale.
However! It would be silly to restrict Starship, for the very simple reason that we have no alternative for space travel, when we do have alternatives for energy generation.
The CO2 factor is basically nothing, one rocket flight would be on the order of 10 commercial jet flights. The problem is soot from non-hydrolox launch vehicles, black carbon deposited directly into the upper atmosphere which apparently has a greater effect on warming than all of commercial aviation's CO2 emissions combined.
Starship is methalox so it's somewhat more ecological than the kerosene burning falcon, but with the increased launch capacity, the rate at which it can deliver stuff to orbit, practically all of which eventually burns up in the upper atmosphere when EoL will likely have much more of a polluting effect in total.
It’s a lot of fuel and significantly more than a single flight uses, but there’s orders of magnitudes more flights, so no, it doesn’t make a huge difference right now. With massively increased cadence it might eventually.
Starship plus Booster load roughly 1000 tons of methane. We use roughly 1,000,000 tons of kerosene a day (world wide).
Starship launching at a high enough frequency to affect climate change would also allow it to solve climate change, first with orbital shades, then perhaps with space based solar (or orbital mirrors for increased production of ground based solar). At a minimum it's going to offset a lot of natural gas that would otherwise be used for data centers, assuming Starmind works out as well.
Are you equally concerned about the shipping industry?
The environmental limit for Starship launches will not be CO2, but rather water deposition in the stratosphere and above. This will still require a hefty launch rate to reach.
So precise it was almost boring - incredible work. Kudos.
This happens. You do a remarkable thing, and then... it's anti-climactic because having done it means it's not so remarkable. If it really is remarkable you do it again and then it's really not anymore.
It's a bit of a curse in that this really is remarkable and they made it look so easy it seems unremarkable, but then again if you're looking for highs in the sense of doing remarkable things then every time you succeed you end up reaching for more rather than being depressed that your remarkable accomplishments turn out to be unremarkable.
Booster didn't make it back though this time, becasue of one engine not relighting out of 33. Space Shuttles became boring before Challenger too.
Congratulations to the steely eyed missile men and women of SpaceX.
I wonder if John Aaron was watching. Or Gene Kranz. Both are still alive.
I imagine this is what it was like to witness Apollo 11 55 years ago.
This isn't even remotely close to that.
I was nine. I remember our black and white TV, the crackling from the picture tube's high voltage wiring adding a tang of ozone. We stayed up late that night.
Er, no. Nothing like it. Grabbed from your bed in the middle of the night, bundled downstairs to watch (grainy) and hear (crackly) weird things on a black-and-white TV, while adults, including strangers, whooped and shouted drunkenly. I understood the Apollo 11 thing only in the days after, through news reports. The live event was as impenetrable to me as a dream. Then again, I was half-asleep and five years old.
Different vibe.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-VfYjPzj1Xw
My grandma was one of the only person with a TV where she lived, half of the town was in her living room, nothing comparable. I bet most people watched this on their toilet seat before scrolling to the next cool thing as if it was nothing
I dont think this remotely compares to watching dudes walk on the moon.
[flagged]
The "Baby Come Back" soundtrack really brought this home for me. What an incredible achievement. Very moving.
Unbelievable that this post is about a video showing technical history being made, but the video[0] doesn't show in Firefox.
[0] Clicking the "Watch" button (`.spx-button.primary`) on the OP.
Holy ship, it was picture perfect capture!
Do we know why they didn't try to catch the booster?
https://x.com/elonmusk/status/2121648438144024943
booster was low on fuel, plus no mood of risking tower with boom, boosters are cheaper than towers.
Slight underperformance in the engines resulted in the the booster not reaching where it was supposed to be and the GNC systems automatically aborted to the gulf for safety.
Apparently the booster signaled it didn't have enough fuel to risk it. Either because it consumed more then expected on the way up, or a measurement error potentially.
Two reasons floating around. 1.)They lost communication with tower 2.)They ran out of fuel for safe land.
source: Scott Manley https://youtube.com/shorts/m2oGDCvDmdE?si=0AlX8sgHDihXCED6
"Slightly low on fuel."
If I understand correctly, the margin was tight enough not to take the risk of damaging the tower.
Do we know what sea life just died as the booster exploded? What are the impacts to the Texas Gulf when a booster detonates into the ocean?
What is the advantage of catching over just landing it?
They don't need to pay the mass penalty of landing legs, just some much lighter pins that stick out to the side.
The Falcon 9 landing legs were some excellent engineering, but scaled up to the size of starship they would weigh many tons (note the square-cube law makes them more unfavorable proportionally, not just massive considered amsolutely).
This would be a big deal for the booster, but it's absolutely vital for Starship itself because any additional dry mass subtracts directly from the payload (actually, it's even worse since it also increases the fuel needed for landing).
Another advantage is that it's better for reuse, as they don't have to spend hours or days restowing legs, recharging deployment cylinders and replacing crush cores.
Could be that stretching load is better then compression for a structure that resembles a tube rolled of aluminum foil
This question was answered by the Chief Engineer of SpaceX https://x.com/elonmusk/status/1845829120959156376
> The strong gravity of Earth makes the physics of a fully reusable rocket with positive payload margin extremely difficult to solve, which is why it has never been done before.
> Removing the mass of landing legs from the booster and ship by making the tower do the work of final velocity attenuation greatly improves payload margin.
> This architecture also simultaneously substantially increases launch cadence, because the same arms that lift the booster and ship onto the launch stand also catch them, allowing immediate placement of the booster back on the launch stand and the ship back on top of the booster.
That was incredible to watch!
Huge congratulations to the team.
We witnessed history today
The heat shield looks very good. Excited to see how much work it will take to fly this again. I'm in awe. I like the future sometimes.
Seemed to me two tiles were missing, including one right in the center of the ship's belly, but no hull damage.
This is absolutely incredible!! I can’t wrap my head around this.
That was incredible impressive, what a feat of engineering!
The Chinese one was more impressive
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/GJ-wZLLuh9M
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zt1V9UWhuKk
You can pilot Starship to try to land it too https://www.dockship42.com
If you ignore the scale it doesn’t seem all the impressive. But the scale is bonkers.
Ah man I just missed it. The live feed is just stock footage. Any links to the catch?
https://youtu.be/jHlpfNSpBmw?t=3233
Last few minutes here:
https://x.com/spacex/status/2121316300702056595
different angle of view with Elon commenting https://www.youtube.com/shorts/M-krN98_Vy4
Damn, that looked smooth and glorious. This is how I'd like the future to be.
Damned impressive.
Anyone else have trouble watching this 8 hours after? I tried on SpaceX page, X, only YT seems to work fine.
I connect from EU.
What amazes me is how many Raptor 2 and 3s are sitting on the bottom the gulf and the Indian Ocean. Dissecting a Raptor 3 in particular would be a real cheat code for anyone wanting to know how to build something similar! Metallurgy alone would be huge!
They blow them up.
does debris like that do anything bad for the oceans?
If it’s really that important, some Russian sub will be down there scavenging parts. If it’s really that important, a US sub will be there first blowing up the debris.
The amount of stress that these vehicles go through as they ascend to orbit and then descend back through the atmosphere to the surface is mind-boggling. To create a rapidly usable vehicle that can do this pushes the limits of material science.
Best thing ever built and it works!!!
There hasn’t been anything like this in humanity for a very long time. It’s so emotional to watch and see what we are capable of and the bright future ahead of us. Thank you for everyone who made this happen.
I feel like the first live HD stream of reentry plasma from the early Starship tests were slightly ahead of this in terms of awesomeness. Entering the atmosphere, everyone expects it to go dark for a couple of minutes, just like during every reentry in history... lo and behold Starlink sends a decent stream ( the first one wasn't perfect, second one was ).
My mind exploded watching that plasma.
While the real name of the rocket is 042.Don't Panic.
Once the drone ship landings were incredible (they still are!), but now they’re normal.
I can’t wait for the time in the near future when catching starship and its booster is old hat.
Amazing day today!
You can see a plane passing underneath it at video timestamp 22:44:43!
Nice catch (NPI)! Unfortunately I think it's a bit more mundane, it'll be a piece of ice breaking off the lower section of the body. If you scrub through the footage, particularly earlier in the flight (e.g. 1:43:37 on the SpaceX stream, T+54:05) you'll see other pieces of ice flying off that look very similar.
Impressive how reliable they've made those engines!
Haven' they had engine failures on every Starship launch? They lost one this time during the boostback burn.
does someone know what is different about this compared to them catching the thing they did before?
Prior catches were for boosters. These were coming down after ~7 minutes of flight, reaching height of ~80km and top speed of ~6000km/hr. This latest catch was of the the Spaceship, after multiple orbits around the planet, from height of ~270km and top speed of ~27000km/hr, having to survive the much higher stress during the re-entry into atmosphere. I think the Spaceship is a bit heavier than the booster at the time of catch as well.
Edit: Spaceship is also more delicate than the booster. They have to be careful to not damage the tiles during the catch.
They've only ever caught the booster portion of the rocket, not the part that actually goes to space and orbits and returns. So, this is the first time they caught the upper stage
Radiators are too big and too expensive for space datacenters to make sense. Also rather than depreciating a GPU, you'll be depreciating a GPU, massive solar array, massive radiator, electronics and housing, and the launch cost to get it all there.
AI likely becomes much more efficient on earth than making sense in space for the foreseeable future.
I know engineering is about expediency, and price, but I’m still bummed that we aren’t getting ships with landing gear in this or likely the next generation of rockets either.
Seems that the heavier the rocket the more ground clearance to need to self-land, and so you can’t scale up the dragon’s landing system. I don’t think there’s anywhere near enough weight to shave off of the next rocket or enough specific impulse to add to bring the size back down.
Starship HLS has landing gear. For Earth landings everything is so marginal that the weight penalty of landing gear is too high.
The space shuttle orbiter definitely had a lot more cool factor.
I had to read the comment below (from u/modeless) before I realized by landing gear you meant the upright ones. I thought you wanted it to land sideways like a plane. (Arguably doable, though the control systems might add a lot more weight)
I think Stoke Space's is supposed to land on it's metal base. Launch supposedly soon.
Yeah the Starship program isn't about landing on Mars or even going there.
It's about pumping mass into low Earth orbit, partly for commericial, but mostly military purposes such as Golden Dome. Been in the works for decades and finally here. The people who know are very excited.
i wonder how much fuel was left over after landing? What is their safety margin in seconds of burn remaining?
Probably 2 to 3 seconds max? You pay a massive penalty for carrying any extra fuel.
I have no idea about Starship, but in one of the Environmental Assessment reports there was specific data on the fuel remaining in Falcon-9 after landing. It was <1270 kg of RP-1, which is equal to 14 seconds of firing at full thrust for one engine -- if one could use all of the fuel up, which is typically not possible. That was the upper bound.
23:21:40 is when it happens
Curious what will be next 10x design? Nuclear propulsion? Same rocket made by robots ?
I think Starship is like entering the wide-body jet age of aircraft. A lot of fine-tuning and efficiency gains from now until it's ubiquitous and cheap. But getting from that to another 10x gain is much harder, similar to aircraft where we haven't seen a "10x" jump since wide-body jets.
My bet: Moon based vehicle and propellant manufacturing. It's just so much easier to get stuff off of the moon that if you were going to build anything of any real size in space, the moon is where I'd get the bulk raw material given the choice.
Momentum-exchange tether: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skyhook_(structure)
Space elevator?
How many years until the next milestones?
- in orbit refueling
- moon landing
- Mars rendez-vous
- Mars landing
- humans on Mars
Nah, the game is to put data centers in space. Plus the Space Force dreams.
It's important to be able to set aside cynicism, even if for a single hour, to enjoy technological achievements like this.
In orbit refueling is likely next year. The goal is to have two shots at a moon landing in 2028.
And a nuclear ion rocket scheduled for 2028 as well.
The current NASA administrator is doing a good job getting rid of all the things keeping NASA from doing things. (And at least after Artemis II, both parties in congress seemed to be on his side.)
Couple of milestones before that:
- flying reused booster + Starship
- longer in orbit missions for Starship of weeks or months. There are some non trivial issues with that probably; and you'd need that to not make refueling pointless.
- having two active launch sites. Nor strictly required but probably handy if you are going to have two Starships in orbit at the same time.
They might not get to all that in that order. But the important step today is that they get to inspect a "flight proven" Starship without water damage. I bet they are going to learn a lot of details of where exactly they need to iterate and improve. This took them some time with Falcon 9 as well. We've gotten used to this thing basically launching and landing without many issues. But that wasn't always the case. 2027 is probably going to see an increase launch rate.
Moon landings are going to be an interesting one because it depends on NASA as well and the decision making around that is very political. On the other hand, there's going to be increasing peer pressure from the Chinese. They have their own plans and it doesn't involve waiting for NASA to get there first. They are targeting 2030 for a manned mission. I expect the politics might get a bit more opinionated on that topic as that gets closer. The long term game here is not just landing and planting another flag but actually establishing a permanent presence on the moon. That involves flying useful payloads back and forth. Starship seems designed for that.
What happens after that is going to be an interesting one. IMHO, Starship is optimal for earth landings but not necessarily for the moon and Mars. What's currently flying is probably over engineered for a place with no atmosphere and one 6th of the gravity (the moon) or a very thin atmosphere and one third of the gravity (Mars). Would those flaps even work in the Mars atmosphere? However, it's a great launch vehicle to get components in space to build something more optimal. Also the booster might be used to launch other things than Starship. Like something that will never come down and can instead be fueled for deep space missions and Mars/Moon landings.
All I want are bigger and more cleverly located space telescopes, a couple of more probes and orbiters around other planets and asteroids, and I want those Mars samples that Percy has been pooping over the Mars surface returned to Earth and studied in a lab. And maybe a probe to Alpha Centauri or exo-planet viewers that use the Sun’s gravitational lensing in the next 5 or 6 decades.
Launches, Starlink, military provide cash. SpaceX needs to be profitable at least to some extent.
I mean, you need to get money from somewhere to fund your dreams. If it's datacenters in space then let be it. They are pretty cool as well. It seems a lot of people don't like them on Earth.
I don't know how long it will take, but I'll be here watching you seethe as they hit each one and you post another list.
That's your reaction to watching this? Pretty sad.
Those exploration dreams can only exist via the bankrolling of government contracts and riding bubbles.
Google is only able to fund Waymo, Quantum Computing, etc because of their questionably moral ads cash cow.
> humans on Mars
Only recently I read how the dust on Mars surface is toxic, contains those unhealthy ultrafine particles (PM2.5 and PM0.10) and sticks to almost all surfaces. It will be difficult to keep from getting inside a habitat.
https://www.space.com/astronomy/mars/mars-dust-is-toxic-how-...
And how the Apollo astronauts got "lunar hay fever", allergy-like symptoms from the lunar dust that stuck outside their space suits and so got carried inside their lunar module.
https://www.esa.int/articles/about-us/directorates/human-and...
What actually is the point of all this? I'm not trying to be a snarky contrarian, I've never had any interest whatsoever in space, star trek, "what's out there?", so I genuinely don't get it.
I'm not trashing people's interests, obviously I am the odd man out in not giving a damn, I just don't see what we're trying to achieve when there are so many issues we can't even figure out on earth.
Holy cow.
https://xnotme.com/SpaceX/status/2121316300702056595
Amazing, kudos SpaceXAI. You folks just don't give up!
Amazing achievement for SpaceX and for humanity
It's very impressive
Magical era. What a feat!
Picture perfect catch with amazing views all along!
I feel the website deserves special attention!
It’s very cool and an amazing technological achievement. But I cannot stop thinking - do we need it? I know that’s a minority take. How much of a minority?
This is exactly the most impressive feat of engineering I have ever seen.
Only catching both the booster and the rocket would top this one. But the rocket only being caught is still impressive regardless.
SpaceX below $1T is criminally undervalued.
SpaceX below $1T is criminally undervalued.
Launch itself isn't super profitable and doesn't have a very big TAM, especially if you carefully treat the TAM as a present value and discount future cash flows. Also, at least by my personal guesswork, Starlink alone shouldn't get close to a $1 trillion valuation. It seems like the current valuation is based on people's guesses about the likelihood that space data centers pan out in a big way.
We've seen the booster landing/catch before, but seeing the ship do it with the belly flop definitely looked cooler to me. I still remember the awe of watching two boosters land at the same time after a heavy launch. Watching the transition from bellyflop to landing gave me the same awe and being impressed.
Well, both booster and ship catches have been demonstrated now.
Why is Space-X undervalued because they can catch a rocketship?
You do understand that a company needs to have a business case equivilient to its valuation right?
Going to Moon only costs money, going to Mars only costs money.
Our whole planet sends 1000-2000t of payload into space, most of it is now starlink.
A fool and his money...
will scaling the size of the rocket continue to be the way to go? will doing a three stage setup make sense?
The tyranny of the rocket equation says no, probably not. As you add mass the amount of fuel you need goes up exponentially.
There has been some mention of a stretched Starship.
It's crazy how far you have to scroll to even see this on the front page of NYT.
Maybe people have bigger problems ? War, cost of living crisis etc ?
[flagged]
I wonder if it has anything to do with the CEO being a fascist?
This is incredible. Huge respect for the engineering team. What a time to be alive.
As an aside, it’s been fun watching the number of UFO posts on Reddit while Starship orbited Earth. They all refused to believe it was SpaceX.
Congrats to SpaceX engineers! But for those who are not fans of the guy at the top here's a video of Blue Origin landing their rocket. Competition is good! https://www.youtube.com/shorts/XjSmNf3y37U
They're likely not fans of the other guy either.
What great top comments in here. The others finally keep quiet. Facts speak for themselves.
Kind of crazy to reduce the hardware on ship so much and move so much complexity to the ground. This can really only happen in a situation where anybody can throw out any dumb idea, because if you suggested this 20 years ago people would think you are an idiot.
That's...the point. You can hire commercial welders to work on the ground side and build everything out once, cheaply.
The issue with the shuttle era was that they needed huge teams of specialized technicians to refurbish the insanely complex orbiter after every mission.
If we ever get sufficiently improved materials science for heat shields and engines there's still always a possibility of returning to the SSTO space plane concept. That would allow a more austere launch and recovery environment, but given current limitations this is the local maxima.
>This can really only happen in a situation where anybody can throw out any dumb idea, because if you suggested this 20 years ago people would think you are an idiot.
Indeed.
Musk's biographer tweeted the pages from his book <https://x.com/WalterIsaacson/status/1844870018351169942> discussing how in late 2020 Musk suggested, then insisted against considerable opposition from his engineers, that Superheavy be caught with chopsticks instead of landing on legs like Falcon 9.
Also according to the book, Musk is the person who suggested and, against considerable opposition from his engineers, insisted on Starship switching to stainless steel instead of carbon fiber <https://x.com/richardprice100/status/1728106606616015097>.
(Hint to others: Musk was right and his engineers were wrong. Both times.)
What do you mean? Reducing the complexity of the drive doesn't mean moving anything to ground?
Or do i miss something?
my 10 year old: "shame they can't fix their video player though" (the one on the x website)
Amazing. Doesn't even look real.
truly an amazing accomplishment, such an exciting time. go spacex!
New tech tree unlocked for humanity.
I wish them good luck. Now we wait and see how many times they can do it without accident for either the ship or the booster. Propulsion by a controlled explosion is a fickle beast so I suspect the mileage will vary and I wonder how would future launch and landing failures (which I expect will unfortunately happen) will impact the programme in general.
Legendary ♥
Feels good.
Honestly if this thread had the actual number of points it deserved based on the kind of milestone this represents for humanity's future and access to space, it would be in the millions.
If you don't follow rocketry you can't possibly understand what this means.
This was the Trinity test.
And even if you hate Elon and all his businesses, this knowledge will proliferate. Either by talent movement / osmosis, by espionage or just being inspired ("if they can do it, maybe we have a chance as well").
Within a decade the average cost to LEO will drop 20x-50x and if you're not recovering both of your stages, you don't exist.
> And even if you hate Elon and all his businesses, this knowledge will proliferate. Either by talent movement / osmosis, by espionage or just being inspired ("if they can do it, maybe we have a chance as well").
It doesn't need to proliferate. It has existed in us for a very long time, albeit working the kinks out would take time.
The major factor on the trajectory space goes is a financial question, not a technological one. And it always has been this way.
Elon is a terrible person that's done a lot of bad for humanity (but also some good). But he's damn good at convincing people to fund his shit and so we get cool rockets until he goes out of favour.. probably that happens when we hit critical mass on the space pollution he puts up into our sky.
I'm looking forward to the bright future where coca-cola adverts can shine out across the night sky, beautifully lit, majestic.
This achievement likely changes the course of life in this solar system.
What?
Why?
Are suddenly aliens on the moon or mars and now because its cheaper to send stuff there, its now suddenly economically worthwhile to do so?
Can anyone explain this to an idiot like to me? I follow information tech, but am pretty ignorant on engineering/space.
I recall the SpaceX chopsticks catch from about a year ago, which looked great.
This looks similar (heavy thing lands smoothly on a platform) but I gather it's very different from the comments?
Previously they successfully caught the booster returning to the launch site from ~100 km about ~10 minutes from launch.
Here they caught the upper stage ,called starhip, which went to ~260 km orbit, deployed 50 tons of satellites and after 22 hours shed its orbital velocity and manuevered to be caught with centimeter precision. :)
It is very impressive that they can control the return trajectory accurately enough for a tower catch, and to coordinate the arms on the tower (which are very slow and heavy), to grab the rocket without damaging it.
But this was already convincingly demonstrated by catching the booster three times.
It is very hard to return the second stage from the orbit due to its vastly greater kinetic energy. Protecting the rocket from the heating during the reentry is something that has never been done until SpaceX started to practice with the Starship.
But they have already demonstrated this feat before, with pinpoint landings into the ocean.
The significance of today's event is mostly in demonstrating that they have such a high confidence in this system that they were able to satisfy the safety requirements for obtaining a licence to fly the Starship return trajectory over the populated landmass, crossing Mexican territory on the way to the tower. This is the cherry on the cake. Now all the pieces are in place, and once the remaining wrinkles in the system are ironed out, we can expect the flights to become routine, and eventually, the reuse of Starship to become routine as well.
The other, somewhat more modest, but still important milestone was that they kept the Starship in orbit for a whole day, and after that they still had the fuel for a deorbit and the landing burns. It did not all boil off.
Edit: Here is an interview with Lars Blackmore, the guy in charge of Entry, Descent, and Landing (EDL) for Starship, where he talks about flying the descent over land for the first time: https://youtu.be/POrMxoZbXVI?t=390
SpaceX made me watch engineering feats live on stream. I love it!
Congratulations
Nice, great
perfect. hyperbole failure moment
It's difficult to underline how huge this is. This marks the first time in the history of rocketry that the upper stage of a rocket has returned home from orbit to a safe, upright landing.
(And to preempt the obvious objection: yes, maybe you can call the Space Shuttle an "upper stage of a rocket" if you squint hard enough, but it didn't do upright landings, its external tank was not reusable and even the Shuttle itself was effectively rebuilt from scratch at exorbitant cost each time.)
It's sad to see a lot of media missing the point, eg as I type this BBC is reporting this as "SpaceX successfully catches part of Starship rocket on its return to Earth".
Edit: corrected to note that the SRBs were reusable, but the ET was not.
> none of its boosters were reusable
Notably, they were reusable! Sure, they had to refurbish them, same with the shuttle’s main engines. The only thing they threw away was the external tank which didn’t have any engines.
Whatever you call it, the Shuttle Orbiter wasn’t a complete stage in any case. It needed the external tank, which was never recovered.
SpaceX has now demonstrated all the pieces of a fully reusable launcher. Next comes putting them all together in the same flight, and hopefully demonstrating that the flights can become frequent and cheap. There’s no guarantee of that, but it’s looking good.
> none of its boosters were reusable
The SRBs of the shuttle landed by parachute and were recovered from the water and reused
Everyone saw the space shuttle be reusable, no one cares in the public when the cost of living is so high.
I get it’s exciting but it means almost nothing for 99% of people.
> yes, maybe you can call the Space Shuttle an "upper stage of a rocket" if you squint hard enough
Why wouldn't it count? It is not the first time in the history of rocketry that the part that is not the boosters returns home intact.
Sure, you can say "it's the first time in the history of rocketry that it lands upright", but you could also say "it's the first time in the history of rocketry that it is not white".
If you want to say how huge this is, tell me how different it is from landing the boosters. Because from the outside it sure as hell looks very similar.
Don't forget the X37
You know what was huge? James Webb telescope.
Look its cool to see a catch like this, it doesn't necessarly feels that difficult tbh?
And I just don't get it? Is it cool to watch? yes, but whats the endgoal besides reducing costs for starlink and military stuff?
bee eff dee
Congratulations Elon Musk and to those who work at his company. He is a true visionary.
"pls make a reusable rocket, make no mistakes!!" This is probably some AI slop rocket XD
nice
Congratulations to SpaceX and Elon Musk! Another huge step to the stars!
I see you're being downvoted. HN is increasingly becoming anti-Elon for no particular reason. Cult behavior.
I hope they can make significant progress before the socialists take over. They were practically begging for launch permits under Biden.
[dead]
[flagged]
The most amazing thing i've seen in a while.
[flagged]
[flagged]
[dead]
[dead]
[dead]
[dead]
[flagged]
[flagged]
[dead]
I am trying to understand what's the big deal about this, other that massive weight and the money involved. The way I see it is software controls the fuel output and motion control. The only other challenge I have been hearing about is the heat shield. Other that this what's really special about the spaceship. The number of modules and the complexity seems not that huge. Any error or miscalculation in here is very costly and that is the only thing seems to be the bottleneck here.
If its that trivial, why did nobody came up with this on their own so far?
Nice! I wonder how the engineering involved here compares to the engineering behind manufacturing TSMC chips (including ASML machines, Zeiss optics etc.). Which is harder?
As it seems building rockets has historically been a capital intensive business with low profits and limited demand, so there just wasn't much competition in the space industry.
Many countries are capable of space flight & deploying satellites.
Only a few companies in the world can manage the top-tier fab processes for modern chips.
Only one company in the world has successfully caught a rocket. *Edit: 2!
It's hard to directly compare, safe to say they are 2 of the pinnacle examples of modern human engineering.
I would say that they're orthogonal except for the requirement for exacting results and standards. Doing anything once is hard. Doing anything repeatably is hard^2.
Chips are harder.
The traitorous handling by SpaceX of the starlink product with our allies makes me greatly anticipate nationalizing this corrupt business entity.
Impressive feat of engineering but I have troubles getting excited about this and don't see the point in this endeavour.
Has anybody access to.measures like how much CO2 (and other material) emissions costs this kind of Rocket Catch?
Less than an airline flight.
just finished watching the new documentary about musk. not that ive learned anything new. its so sad that engineering achievements like these are being shadowed, at least for some people like myself, with the figure that runs these companies.
nevertheless, the people who made it work should be proud of themselves.
They only have a 60% catch rate on the booster. The elimination of the landing feet has reduced it's reusability.
And at a similar testing point F9 had a 0% catch rate. What’s your point?
Reusable stages is very neat, but seems a little crazy to pay the tyranny of the rocket equation twice. I heard one person say that carrying fuel to land over the whole flight means it takes 23x more launches to get an equivalent payload to orbit.
Using modern technology, couldn't disposable first stages be produced much more cheaply than during the space race?
How much of modern manufacturing disposable booster's cost would be fuel vs metal?
I heard one person say that carrying fuel to land over the whole flight means it takes 23x more launches to get an equivalent payload to orbit.
I recommend talking with people who know more about spaceflight.
It's not paying it twice. The rocket equation is about the ratio of the wet and dry mass, so for an expendable rocket you're always limited by the fact that there's an upper stage (and for the second stage the payload etc).
This is why SpaceX cares more about TWR for their engines than traditional rockets did. It goes from making a negligible difference to a huge component of how much fuel they need to keep for landing.
This seems a little confused.
The 23x more launches figure comes from HLS (Nasa sponsored mission to the moon). They may well change the configuration of that anyway, but if you want to refuel in orbit, that's what it costs. It's hard to get fuel to orbit (or any sort of payload). Previous Moon missions haven't refueled anything, but they couldn't return anything heavy from the moon's surface, the vehicle got smaller and smaller as it went and many parts were left behind, so it's not comparable. You can be sure if it's cheaper to somehow do this mission with expendable boosters, they'll think about doing that.
On a normal mission just to earth orbit, there is one booster and one starship, and reusing the booster is more a question of why not save some money for a little more propellant use? The reususable booster doesn't contribute much extra weight, it uses little propellant for boostback and landing.
The booster also doesn't go all the way and you need a booster if you're going to reach orbit (due to that equation), so it doesn't take much to make it reusable. So all in all, why not make it reusable if you can? What would you save from using expendable ones?
"I heard one person say that carrying fuel to land over the whole flight means it takes 23x more launches to get an equivalent payload to orbit."
I don't think that this is the case when using the atmosphere to shed most of your velocity, which is what we do when landing on Earth. Propulsive braking would be another story, but you can avoid that on bodies that do have some atmosphere. In our proximity, only the Moon and Mercury would need propulsive braking, but Moon's gravity is low and Mercury is hard to visit anyway.
That said, once you use the atmosphere to cushion what is basically a fall, the weight of the necessary heat shield comes to the equation too.
That 23x number is trivially refuted simply by looking at the fact that this flight delivered 52 tons of cargo to orbit. Could a similarly sized expendable rocket like the Saturn V deliver 1196 tons?
Fuel is so much cheaper than ships.
Those numbers don't make sense.
It doesn't take the same amount of fuel to land as it does to lift.
Speaking as a Kerbal Space program playing, internet commentor, It's probably <1% of the fuel to briefly counteract terminal velocity as it is to lift off and reach space.
How is it twice? Braking on the way down doesn't take nearly as much fuel as lift off so the "tyranny of the rocket equation" should be paid only once.
This claim doesn't make sense to me, you need most of the fuel to escape gravity. Coming back is almost free.
If the fuel (+ oxidizer) ends up costing as much as 1% of the cost of launching a conventional single-use rocket then the people behind it will be very happy. That means that their rocket (+ cost of ground facilities + all the people prepping the rocket and monitoring the launch) is very cheap.
The fuel (+ oxidizer) is basically free compared to all the other costs.
They use the atmosphere to brake, not fuel.
That's like saying we shouldn't reuse airplanes after one flight because you'd have to fly it 23 times to have it pay for that reuse.
That's still 1000x cheaper than... building a new airplane every flight.
And anyway those numbers area about moon missions, not low earth orbit.
Starship is finished - jsut ask Elon, thats why he sold it.
Do we just look past the failed primary booster objective? (I didn't write the brief)
Edit: Yes, ignore that bit.
We don't have to look past it. Musk said it failed because engine underperformance caused too little fuel margin. He added that they have upgrades due on future flights.
If they ran out of fuel with 50 tons of payload it certainly begs the question of whether they will get to the goal of 100 tons of payload even with upgrades.
They also had engine fail on boostback. Reliability has been a persistent problem, they'll have to fix it for refueling and manned operations.
Booster catch has been done as has booster re-flight. The only remaining part of the full functionality that has not been proven out is ship reuse.
Please go back to reddit
bet they used lidar
(let's see who gets the joke)
seriously though, do we know the names of the engineers who made this possible or is it a secret?
You could go to LinkedIn and look at people in the:
* structures
* propulsion
* avionics
* flight software
departments, because they all work together to make this happen, along with support from IT/SRE. The person most responsible for ensuring that it happens is Lars Blackmore[1], who was also the Responsible Engineer in charge of making sure Falcon 9 landed successfully
[1] - https://linkedin.com/in/lars-blackmore-78a237
Congrats to the engineers.
(But lose the bastard at the top, OK?)
He's actively holding the program back at this point. Top engineers in this industry are increasingly reluctant to join a company with a such a toxic culture and public reputation tainted by musk.
Congrats to the everyone involved (more than just engineers!).
Here's hoping Musk gets kicked before he sinks this project too, as he's already severely burdened it with his short-sighted fascistic endeavors. As a formerly very enthusiastic follower of SpaceX's activities the specter of Musk's evil beliefs really ruins the messaging of making progress for all of humanity.
Elon Musk is a real life version of D.D. Harriman, the protagonist of Heinlein's The Man Who Sold the Moon. An excerpt taken from Wikipedia:
""I", he says, "would cheat, lie, steal, beg, bribe—do anything to accomplish what we have accomplished". Children donate money for a promise of all contributors' names engraved on a plaque left on the Moon. The names, however, will be microscopic in size. Harriman sells land and naming rights to craters, and plans to sell postal covers canceled on the Moon to collectors. He starts rumors that diamonds exist in moondust, intending to secretly place gems in the rocket to convince people that the rumors are true."
And anyone who's read Machiavelli knows what kind of man it takes to succeed at this level in non-fiction.
Given the fact that men of his abilities and motivations have existed throughout history, and will continue to exist as long as we have men, for all his perceived flaws I'm quite pragmatically relieved he is ensconced with a Western power rather than any other in the world.
[flagged]
[flagged]
[flagged]
[flagged]
[flagged]
[flagged]
I want you to comment on the first commercial fusion reactor too, please
A+ hacker news comment