This is a way weirder system than the name suggests. patio11 explains it in detail in the article, but the gist is:
1. You can contribute to rural areas in return for a tax credit, effectively allowing you to redirect a portion of your taxes to another town.
2. The most important quirk of the system is that you can choose any towns to contribute to. There is no requirement of previous residence or whatever. In fact, most people contribute to towns with which they have no personal connection.
3. This ended up causing tax competition among local governments. Quite a few towns started advertising expensive "gifts" to contributers ("Give us your taxes and we'll send you some goodies"). It went so far that some towns got banned from the hometwon tax system.
It was introduced with good intension, but resulted in a very inefficient tax system.
To me it seems like the main issue is that donations are not anonymous. The author explains that, for cultural reasons, in Japan gifts should be counter-gifted in ~30%, and that somehow explains this convoluted system. But these aren't gifts - they are taxes! There's no reason why towns should know the name and address of the people who transferred their taxes to them - they should receive the tax money in bulk. But of course now it's almost impossible to change this system because no town will agree to changing it.
Me, and quite a few people I know, have visited different towns that we would never go to just because of this. I’m not sure how it affects the towns in a national scale, but it’s weirdly fun.
"weird" is putting it lightly. patio11 paints over most of the issues. This is not a good system, and it absolutely does not solve the stated goal of distributing money back to the regions.
I wonder about secondary effects. There seems to be the possibility of "Disneyland economies", a main street fed up by cash from people who with no connection and who do not draw any local services. I could see this propping up towns with better marketing teams, or towns who cling to whatever esthetic most pleases their outsider benefactors. In the extreme, would local people lose political/financial power in favor of the outsider tax base?
> In the extreme, would local people lose political/financial power in favor of the outsider tax base?
Yes, in the same way that happens in any town that attracts tourists, or produces something to export to other places.
People complain about those effects, but in practise it's a lot worse to live somewhere that doesn't have anything worth exporting to the rest of the world.
Sounds like responsive government to me. You must live in a dictatorship that doesn't care about you at all if receiving benefits in exchange for taxes is not your natural interaction with your government.
The US should adopt that for state and local taxes. Donate to another state, get a write off in your own. Would create a nice incentive to not be hated by your own populace.
Of course, the architecture of the US government more or less precludes it, but it's fun to think about which states and cities would go instantly bankrupt.
But which state/county would be the winners? I see potential for spite-based decisions. I could see someone in NYC getting mad at his local city and redirecting their taxes to Hazzard County Kentucky for no other reason than it looked cool in the TV show.
[A very long time ago I ordered some custom arrows online and they were assembled in Hazard Kentucky, a city in Perry County.]
There's a lot of variables here. Appeal to out of states, distribution of in-state resentment.
Pretty much every city that drags its state around politically is resented internally and the real volume of political will comes from the "greater X area" but some cities are hated by their own populace (NYC comes to mind) whereas some aren't (Boston seems less hated IMO).
I think states like Tennessee and Vermont that aren't too resented internally but have a lot of tourism exposure would benefit.
So I think you've got to greatly consider the relative degrees and sizes of all the different effects.
And this is before you even discuss states gaming the system.
I'm kinda glad that the US "laboratory of democracy" of independent state governments makes you have to live wherever you pay taxes (or don't have to pay taxes). We all get to live in a dysfunctional bleeding heart dump or a laissez faire shooting range, vacationing in and snarking about the other side.
> We all get to live in a dysfunctional bleeding heart dump or a laissez faire shooting range,
Thanks for making my day. As a dysfunctional bleeding heart liberal with many laissez faire gun toting friends it’s nice to see someone enjoyably mischaracterizing everyone :)
I wonder how much better we’d all get along if there wasn’t the incentive for political parties to characterize the other half of the country as our enemies…
I live in Japan. I use this every year. Patrick explained the why and how it works. I'll summarize it for the person who this system is available to. It's basically free money. In the end it's simple, you go to https://www.satofull.jp/ you buy stuff there, you get the money back in tax season time.
There's a limit of course, it's higher the more you make. The stuff in that page is typically overpriced by 3-5x but since its free, it's fine. In theory you buy meat and fruit and regional delicacies but lately there's lots of stuff including electronics and whatnot. There are some truly bizarre things too, especially if you sort by price and select the most expensive ones, my favorites are the 10m yen tier I'm going off my memory but I just can't forget these:
- A custom statue of yourself
- A sauna to install in your backyard
- A whole frozen cow
- A local celebrity from that town records whatever you want for a ringtone
I would like the option of donating my taxes to the government department of my choice and the ability to deny funding to immoral or inefficient departments.
I feel this is great system honestly and should be expanded.
It would be a direct public referendum of government behavior and spending through the only language they understand. Money.
Indeed. Good system, I send a portion of my taxes to my hometown in Shimane prefecture and get in return some of the goods from local farmers. I have always wished a similar system existed in America.
I live in Japan. This is ridiculous take. It's not a good system: it creates perverse incentives to fight for everyone's tax money, rather than pay it where they live---i.e. where they consume the gov't services their tax money pays for. That means yes it can go from Tokyo to less populated regions, but it also means money that would have gone to regions starved for cash will now go to the region with the highest bidder, and the closer to cash, the more popular.
I live in a small city far from Tokyo, that desperately needs cash and that is bleeding youth to the bigger cities at a terrifying rate. But this is not the solution! Yes, paying taxes to where you live is not perfect. But furusato-nozei is so so much worse.
The original intent is to let you direct tax money to a place you have a connection to, maybe you were born in Tokyo but your parents came from Aomori and your grandparents and extended family still live there.
So even if you don't live there, you still go often and have a strong connection.
In practice it would be impossible to determine legally what's your "origin town" so letting people choose really is the only option.
I often thought it might be better if people could actually literally vote with their dollars, choose how their tax dollars are allocated.
I thought (briefly) about the consequences of this idea: different governments would then need to become concerned with "advertising"... or in this case ... sending their citizens cans of plums :) That's very cute.
> Tokyo, for its perspective, views the regions with the noblesse oblige that you would expect a cosmopolitan center of culture and learning to have with respect to their benighted country bumpkin cousins.
I've met several French people from small coastal villages who now live in Paris and it's been interesting to see that their perspective on Paris is basically:
a) The native Parisians think people from their area are country bumpkins.
b) The people who live in their hometowns almost universally think that Paris is dirty, crime-ridden, too crowded, too noisy, too expensive, etc.
It almost completely mirrors the attitude of certain small town Americans towards NYC or Chicago or LA.
Having lived in both Ireland and the UK, a similar dynamic between the capital city and rural towns exists in both countries. I think it must be near universal.
> think that Paris is dirty, crime-ridden, too crowded, too noisy, too expensive, etc.
It's made big improvements in the last decade regarding dirt and noise, at least in the city center (besides the areas with homeless encampments along the canal). But crime ridden, crowded, expensive - all 100% accurate. Bag snatchers and pickpockets are all over the place, especially on the metro.
Paris, many years ago, was just dogshit everywhere. I hope to go back if things have changed, but the smell, and the constant hopscotch was soul-destroying.
It's changed a lot. Far less traffic, far less pollution, and my experience is that all the people I interacted with were lovely, far from the Parisian stereotypes. I would also strongly disagree that it's just a tourist trap city. It feels vibrant and alive, it's a city that would be great to live in (if you're rich).
Japan has this plus a bunch of healthy(ish) big city rivalry. Osakans think Tokyoites are cold, boring and humorless, Kyotoites think Osakans are loud and boorish, Osakans think people from Kyoto are stuck up pricks, Kobe people pity everybody else for being unfashionable and poor, etc.
This last trio sounds funny to outsiders because Osaka, Kyoto and Kobe are 30 min away from each other by train and basically all part of the big Kansai blob, but try asking a New Yorker what they think about New Jersey, Westchester County, etc.
You'd probably need a deep level of local cultural understanding to 'get' any of it... But even as a person who only spends part of the time in NYC, I can 'get' why the gowanus canal area is marked as sludge, or other regionally specific humorous labels.
> To the extent that taxpayers donate to their hometowns, Tokyo no longer freerides on the substantial public expenditures required to raise and educate internal migrants.
This is really great idea and justice too.
For decades, the countryside in every country have sent off their youngsters to work for the country's economy. The real unsung heros are the rural families who spend everything on their children education and well being, only to be separated from their loved ones. It's not just families that got impacted; the entire communities, villages and districts became devoid of young work force who prefer to move to cities.
This was tolerated under the assumption that the cities provide better living conditions for the youngsters and the next generations. But cities survive in an ecosystem provided by the country side. Starve country side, you starve cities.
Nonsense, people aren't "sent" they leave because the rural areas are fundamentally obsolete, they offer very limited lives, and produce very little.
They offer no reason to stay.
Their government takes money from a productive area to subsidize a rural one, in a feelgood program to purchase the votes of the non productive at the cost of a higher tax burden elsewhere.
From the city's perspective the countryside is an incredibly expensive way to provide some quantity of raw material, not some wellspring of labour since the 19th century.
"Justice" is a wrong word to use here, I think, as its both vague and subjective. But your position is unsustainable. For starters you simply don't want your country to be a few 1st world cities within a 3rd world hinterland, cause it's sure way to cultural disintegration, political polarization, increased crime, and poor defensibility in military sense. You really want to maintain your country as a whole.
What's the justice? To me it seems that hometowns didn't give young people the opportunities they should and drove them away. And on top of that they now want to lay their hands on the juicy, juicy money that they didn't earn.
> their youngsters
No, everybody is their own person and deserves to keep what they worked hard to earn.
Was it tolerated, or did automation and more efficient transportation make most rural people’s labor unnecessary, hence necessitating they move for work?
This is a way weirder system than the name suggests. patio11 explains it in detail in the article, but the gist is:
1. You can contribute to rural areas in return for a tax credit, effectively allowing you to redirect a portion of your taxes to another town.
2. The most important quirk of the system is that you can choose any towns to contribute to. There is no requirement of previous residence or whatever. In fact, most people contribute to towns with which they have no personal connection.
3. This ended up causing tax competition among local governments. Quite a few towns started advertising expensive "gifts" to contributers ("Give us your taxes and we'll send you some goodies"). It went so far that some towns got banned from the hometwon tax system.
It was introduced with good intension, but resulted in a very inefficient tax system.
To me it seems like the main issue is that donations are not anonymous. The author explains that, for cultural reasons, in Japan gifts should be counter-gifted in ~30%, and that somehow explains this convoluted system. But these aren't gifts - they are taxes! There's no reason why towns should know the name and address of the people who transferred their taxes to them - they should receive the tax money in bulk. But of course now it's almost impossible to change this system because no town will agree to changing it.
Me, and quite a few people I know, have visited different towns that we would never go to just because of this. I’m not sure how it affects the towns in a national scale, but it’s weirdly fun.
"weird" is putting it lightly. patio11 paints over most of the issues. This is not a good system, and it absolutely does not solve the stated goal of distributing money back to the regions.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50530561
I wonder about secondary effects. There seems to be the possibility of "Disneyland economies", a main street fed up by cash from people who with no connection and who do not draw any local services. I could see this propping up towns with better marketing teams, or towns who cling to whatever esthetic most pleases their outsider benefactors. In the extreme, would local people lose political/financial power in favor of the outsider tax base?
> In the extreme, would local people lose political/financial power in favor of the outsider tax base?
Yes, in the same way that happens in any town that attracts tourists, or produces something to export to other places.
People complain about those effects, but in practise it's a lot worse to live somewhere that doesn't have anything worth exporting to the rest of the world.
> Give us your taxes and we'll send you some goodies
this doesn't count as corruption? if it does, it will solve itself
I send the city that I live in taxes and the local politcos get goodies. Getting something, anything, back for paying taxes would be great.
Sadly, this (my) comment is only slightly in jest.
Sounds like responsive government to me. You must live in a dictatorship that doesn't care about you at all if receiving benefits in exchange for taxes is not your natural interaction with your government.
The point is that this isn't your government.
You will get your DOGE check anytime now.
> receiving benefits in exchange for taxes
Schools. Bridges. Safe streets. Health care. Not fruit baskets.
how inefficient? At the very least I do find the idea entertaining!
The US should adopt that for state and local taxes. Donate to another state, get a write off in your own. Would create a nice incentive to not be hated by your own populace.
Of course, the architecture of the US government more or less precludes it, but it's fun to think about which states and cities would go instantly bankrupt.
But which state/county would be the winners? I see potential for spite-based decisions. I could see someone in NYC getting mad at his local city and redirecting their taxes to Hazzard County Kentucky for no other reason than it looked cool in the TV show.
[A very long time ago I ordered some custom arrows online and they were assembled in Hazard Kentucky, a city in Perry County.]
There's a lot of variables here. Appeal to out of states, distribution of in-state resentment.
Pretty much every city that drags its state around politically is resented internally and the real volume of political will comes from the "greater X area" but some cities are hated by their own populace (NYC comes to mind) whereas some aren't (Boston seems less hated IMO).
I think states like Tennessee and Vermont that aren't too resented internally but have a lot of tourism exposure would benefit.
So I think you've got to greatly consider the relative degrees and sizes of all the different effects.
And this is before you even discuss states gaming the system.
I'm kinda glad that the US "laboratory of democracy" of independent state governments makes you have to live wherever you pay taxes (or don't have to pay taxes). We all get to live in a dysfunctional bleeding heart dump or a laissez faire shooting range, vacationing in and snarking about the other side.
> We all get to live in a dysfunctional bleeding heart dump or a laissez faire shooting range,
Thanks for making my day. As a dysfunctional bleeding heart liberal with many laissez faire gun toting friends it’s nice to see someone enjoyably mischaracterizing everyone :)
I wonder how much better we’d all get along if there wasn’t the incentive for political parties to characterize the other half of the country as our enemies…
I live in Japan. I use this every year. Patrick explained the why and how it works. I'll summarize it for the person who this system is available to. It's basically free money. In the end it's simple, you go to https://www.satofull.jp/ you buy stuff there, you get the money back in tax season time.
There's a limit of course, it's higher the more you make. The stuff in that page is typically overpriced by 3-5x but since its free, it's fine. In theory you buy meat and fruit and regional delicacies but lately there's lots of stuff including electronics and whatnot. There are some truly bizarre things too, especially if you sort by price and select the most expensive ones, my favorites are the 10m yen tier I'm going off my memory but I just can't forget these:
- A custom statue of yourself
- A sauna to install in your backyard
- A whole frozen cow
- A local celebrity from that town records whatever you want for a ringtone
It's a bit sad that this concept of directing your taxes to prefectures you choose simply became an Amazon marketplace.
The wacky world of incentives
I would like the option of donating my taxes to the government department of my choice and the ability to deny funding to immoral or inefficient departments.
I feel this is great system honestly and should be expanded.
It would be a direct public referendum of government behavior and spending through the only language they understand. Money.
Indeed. Good system, I send a portion of my taxes to my hometown in Shimane prefecture and get in return some of the goods from local farmers. I have always wished a similar system existed in America.
https://farm.ewg.org/region.php
Another subsidy is the government pays more to doctors in rural areas. Rural areas get enormous subsidies in the US.
I thought America taxes their citizens wherever they go.
And they don't even have a public health care system to abuse (leave while young/healthy - come back once old/ill).
I live in Japan. This is ridiculous take. It's not a good system: it creates perverse incentives to fight for everyone's tax money, rather than pay it where they live---i.e. where they consume the gov't services their tax money pays for. That means yes it can go from Tokyo to less populated regions, but it also means money that would have gone to regions starved for cash will now go to the region with the highest bidder, and the closer to cash, the more popular.
I live in a small city far from Tokyo, that desperately needs cash and that is bleeding youth to the bigger cities at a terrifying rate. But this is not the solution! Yes, paying taxes to where you live is not perfect. But furusato-nozei is so so much worse.
I don't understand why they let you choose a city
The original intent is to let you direct tax money to a place you have a connection to, maybe you were born in Tokyo but your parents came from Aomori and your grandparents and extended family still live there.
So even if you don't live there, you still go often and have a strong connection.
In practice it would be impossible to determine legally what's your "origin town" so letting people choose really is the only option.
Why wouldn't they let you choose cities? From lived experience, cities are better in every way compared to the alternatives
I often thought it might be better if people could actually literally vote with their dollars, choose how their tax dollars are allocated.
I thought (briefly) about the consequences of this idea: different governments would then need to become concerned with "advertising"... or in this case ... sending their citizens cans of plums :) That's very cute.
Some city offered that donate for project instead of gift. Ex. build a museum, create a park, save a cat, etc.
And everyone would want to fund things like schools while ignoring essential services like prisons which don’t directly benefit them.
Finally, after decades on the internet this is something uniquely Japanese, not just another "thing - thing™ Japan™" case.
In Sweden rich counties pay a tax to poor counties, it is about 1500USD per person and year from a rich county.
https://sv.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kommunala_utj%C3%A4mningssyste...
*municipalities, since County is the usual translation of Län, which is the mid level division.
In the US this effectively happens because poorer states get more federal tax funds than they pay.
Fascinating! Will probably appear in economics text books if it isn't in there already.
> Tokyo, for its perspective, views the regions with the noblesse oblige that you would expect a cosmopolitan center of culture and learning to have with respect to their benighted country bumpkin cousins.
I've met several French people from small coastal villages who now live in Paris and it's been interesting to see that their perspective on Paris is basically:
a) The native Parisians think people from their area are country bumpkins.
b) The people who live in their hometowns almost universally think that Paris is dirty, crime-ridden, too crowded, too noisy, too expensive, etc.
It almost completely mirrors the attitude of certain small town Americans towards NYC or Chicago or LA.
Having lived in both Ireland and the UK, a similar dynamic between the capital city and rural towns exists in both countries. I think it must be near universal.
> think that Paris is dirty, crime-ridden, too crowded, too noisy, too expensive, etc.
It's made big improvements in the last decade regarding dirt and noise, at least in the city center (besides the areas with homeless encampments along the canal). But crime ridden, crowded, expensive - all 100% accurate. Bag snatchers and pickpockets are all over the place, especially on the metro.
That's any tourist-trap city.
Paris, many years ago, was just dogshit everywhere. I hope to go back if things have changed, but the smell, and the constant hopscotch was soul-destroying.
It's changed a lot. Far less traffic, far less pollution, and my experience is that all the people I interacted with were lovely, far from the Parisian stereotypes. I would also strongly disagree that it's just a tourist trap city. It feels vibrant and alive, it's a city that would be great to live in (if you're rich).
Japan has this plus a bunch of healthy(ish) big city rivalry. Osakans think Tokyoites are cold, boring and humorless, Kyotoites think Osakans are loud and boorish, Osakans think people from Kyoto are stuck up pricks, Kobe people pity everybody else for being unfashionable and poor, etc.
This last trio sounds funny to outsiders because Osaka, Kyoto and Kobe are 30 min away from each other by train and basically all part of the big Kansai blob, but try asking a New Yorker what they think about New Jersey, Westchester County, etc.
I wonder if any Japanese humor publishers have thought of something similar to this:
https://www.reddit.com/r/nyc/comments/23dev1/judgemental_nyc...
You'd probably need a deep level of local cultural understanding to 'get' any of it... But even as a person who only spends part of the time in NYC, I can 'get' why the gowanus canal area is marked as sludge, or other regionally specific humorous labels.
This one is a 2d chart but similar flavor https://www.reddit.com/r/Tokyo/comments/1siotg/tokyo_town_ma...
The original map in that post is perhaps closer https://share.google/pDd86jU8DMBair5PN
(2018)
AFAIK basically nothing has changed since.
I (live in Japan) agree to that.
The Amazon join the game, I'm afraid it attention from gov but not yet.
You can no longer earn points from purchases. Otherwise, yeah.
> To the extent that taxpayers donate to their hometowns, Tokyo no longer freerides on the substantial public expenditures required to raise and educate internal migrants.
This is really great idea and justice too.
For decades, the countryside in every country have sent off their youngsters to work for the country's economy. The real unsung heros are the rural families who spend everything on their children education and well being, only to be separated from their loved ones. It's not just families that got impacted; the entire communities, villages and districts became devoid of young work force who prefer to move to cities.
This was tolerated under the assumption that the cities provide better living conditions for the youngsters and the next generations. But cities survive in an ecosystem provided by the country side. Starve country side, you starve cities.
Nonsense, people aren't "sent" they leave because the rural areas are fundamentally obsolete, they offer very limited lives, and produce very little.
They offer no reason to stay.
Their government takes money from a productive area to subsidize a rural one, in a feelgood program to purchase the votes of the non productive at the cost of a higher tax burden elsewhere.
From the city's perspective the countryside is an incredibly expensive way to provide some quantity of raw material, not some wellspring of labour since the 19th century.
"Justice" is a wrong word to use here, I think, as its both vague and subjective. But your position is unsustainable. For starters you simply don't want your country to be a few 1st world cities within a 3rd world hinterland, cause it's sure way to cultural disintegration, political polarization, increased crime, and poor defensibility in military sense. You really want to maintain your country as a whole.
What's the justice? To me it seems that hometowns didn't give young people the opportunities they should and drove them away. And on top of that they now want to lay their hands on the juicy, juicy money that they didn't earn.
> their youngsters
No, everybody is their own person and deserves to keep what they worked hard to earn.
Was it tolerated, or did automation and more efficient transportation make most rural people’s labor unnecessary, hence necessitating they move for work?