For anyone on the fence about switching from Windows to Linux: it takes about a week, if that, of adjusting. If most of what you do is on the Web already (and the services you use provide a Web-based client), you have nothing to lose but your chains.
Take your pick - Ubuntu, Fedora, someone else mentioned Mint. All fine choices, no wrong answers.
As someone who owns and operaters Linux, Windows, and Mac systems at home, this just isn't true for a lot of people.
I have to keep my gaming PC as Windows because I can't play Madden, EA FC, or PUBG on my Linux machines nor my Steam Deck (unless I install windows). They all require kernel level anti-cheats that are only supported on Windows.
You also can't play a ton of other very popular games (that I don't happen to play, but millions do) like Call of Duty, Fortnite, League of Legends, Battlefield, etc. Those games have millions of players.
And this is just for gaming. There are plenty of other bits of software that don't run on Linux, even with all of the amazing work that has gone into compatibility tools like WINE.
I am not saying that many people shouldn't explore moving to Linux from Windows, but I don't think it is helpful to say everyone can switch without at least mentioning any of the reasons people can't.
You can still recommend that people switch, if people have their own specific reasons why they can't, they won't. It's not like anyone mandates that people switch.
For gaming, most games don't have issues. For the games that do, if enough people actually do switch, it gives more incentives for their publishers to make their games work on Linux without issues.
We are also no longer starved for potential alternative games that are very similar and do work on Linux.
Most other software has very good alternatives by now.
So overall I do think it is reasonable to recommend people make the switch rather than stay a hostage of a system they don't like because some software providers refuse to offer an alternative on Linux. If you have specific reasons not to switch, don't switch.
There's a wide, wide, wide gap between "doesn't give any useful information" and "explicitly list all software and hardware that doesn't support Linux, like a medicine informational sheet".
Saying 'you should switch to Linux because it respects your privacy and doesn't frustrate you with ads' is perfectly reasonable advice. The details come later and are based on what that person needs (why even mention gaming DRM if the user isn't a gamer, for example?).
I feel this is the biggest problem with the Linux community.
-Linux is fully customizable!, they'll say.
Well, so it your house. You could move the kitchen and the bathroom, but it's not done over night, and you need the skills to do so.
That beeing said, I've made the switch about at year ago. I do miss some software, I havent gotten to play Battlefield 6 because of it, but i really don't miss Windows at all.
Not to mention, it's a pretty big commitment if you only have 1 or 2 drives and are replacing a Windows installation rather than dual-booting.
It's annoying to be told something "just works" when it doesn't, and lose what you already were using just fine.
Reverting back to Windows in this situation means a full reinstall and setting everything up again, which for some people is enough friction to deter them.
I'm sure that there are a number of games that don't work under Linux, but I've finally installed Arch on my gaming computer (I've been running Linux on laptops since the 90s) and in 6 months, I've encountered a total of 1 game that doesn't WFM so far.
I'd call this highly encouraging.
Also... I'm not sure I'd want any kind of kernel-level anti-cheat on my computer.
> I'm not sure I'd want any kind of kernel-level anti-cheat on my computer.
I think more people should say this part more loudly. Most games that don't work on Linux don't work because they can't install their ~spyware~ anti cheat on your computer.
If that was the lead, instead of "but X game doesn't work on Linux" the response might be "no, Y root kits don't work on Linux" there might be more incentive for folks to stop playing those games.
My experience on Linux is the same. The only thing that hasn’t worked (and better, at that) is stuff with kernel anticheat which I want off my machine as fast as possible anyways
It doesn't, but tell that to my mom who bought a $1000 MacBook because her HP stopped working, then booted it up and decided instead to buy another HP (refurbished) because she didn't understand Mac.
I spent some time going through it with her but she just used to Windows
Those kinds of users are dark matter, they've never heard of Linux (or if they did, for them it falls into the same category as pacemakers) and will never install it on their own.
Techies routinely overestimate how much the average users cares about tech internals.
> You also can't play a ton of other very popular games (that I don't happen to play, but millions do) like Call of Duty, Fortnite, League of Legends, Battlefield
if these people don't start switching, there will be no incentives for developers to port games to Linux.
For every "popular" game that isn't supported there are 10000s of ones which are. Gamers are spoilt for choice. This isn't the hill you want to die on.
I have two win11 machines (desktop and laptop), an m5 mbp and a steam machine (soon a steam frame as well) - plus dual booting. Other than kernel-level anti cheats, built-in codecs and friction around game mods (which agents can nowadays _really_ take care of), non-win gaming is just fine, including on ARM (although I'd love it if non-AppleSilicon consumer archs would implement TSO mode and other good stuff - for everything else, x87sidecar et al).
I just hate how much they (MS) enshittified an otherwise perfectly good OS.
> but I don't think it is helpful to say everyone can switch without at least mentioning any of the reasons people can't.
Which is funny because you don't mention that Epic is working on a native Linux anticheat solution for Fortnite. There are tradeoff everywhere, but most of those tradeoff also apply to Windows. Do you want to deal with an OS that at every importune moment or would prefer to sacrifice a small part of what you do on your computer just to not have to deal with that?
Does anyone know if anti-cheat on Linux is held back by any technical or licensing (meaning GPL) issues, or are game companies just not interested in even looking into it? I'd think that the Steam Deck would be making Linux popular enough to be worth porting them, but then again, Valve doesn't publish numbers on how many Steam Decks have sold, so maybe it's not that popular.
Technical issues is my understanding. There are Linux versions of many anti-cheat softwares, but they are a lot let effective than the Windows versions, so a lot of games turn Linux support off. But Epic Games recently started working on a new version of EasyAntiCheat for Linux that will supposedly be a lot more effective: https://onlineservices.epicgames.com/news/introducing-easy-a...
It'll mean you can't run a small, independent distro or even build your own kernel. When you choose to meet a publisher's demand for running kernel-level anti-cheat (yes, eBPF programs count), that system is no longer your PC; it's a console, albeit a Linux-based one.
Maybe it's something I'll do, but I'll probably have to dual-boot to do it on the machines I use the most, which means I might as well just devote a particular machine to consolehood. :-\
It still beats the hell out of running Windows, but I have mixed feelings about invasive/demanding software like this.
Anti-cheat has even less business being in the kernel than security software, and Crowdstrike proved that security companies can't be trusted to write safe kernel code. Any game that requires poking holes in the most sensitive part of your system is a game you can and should live without.
Do those have more or less business being in your kernel than thousands of other random developers who, on average, have orders of magnitude less security experience than anticheat and antivirus developers?
It's easier to mod the Linux kernel in a way that would fool kernel-level anticheats, since the Linux kernel is both open-source and an extremely well-understood API surface.
With Windows anticheat the anticheat driver is using a well-defined API the kernel exposes to block other kernel drivers being loaded, but with Linux you can change the code implementing those types of APIs by compiling a custom kernel and editing the source code. With Windows such a custom kernel would be a significant reverse engineering effort.
> but with Linux you can change the code implementing those types of APIs by compiling a custom kernel and editing the source code.
If you allow customized kernels to be used then you've already lost. That would give you a similar level of access as running under a hypervisor which has been exploited and banned a long time ago.
Isn't the main issue for the lack of support on Linux the absence of centralized authority that would verify that each kernel/module is locked down enough to prevent "unauthorized" access to your own kernel, and certify/sign the entire boot chain - approved bootloaders, kernels, kernel modules that would allow anticheat to properly attest the boot state?
But that's a near impossible task that's at odds with the philosophy with the entire ecosystem. Support would probably have to be narrowed down to 1 boot loader that supports 1 heavily modified kernel with a short list of most commonly used kernel modules.
In principle, since a Linux system already allows you to choose a kernel to boot from in GRUB or similar, the games manufacturers could provide a signed DRM-enabled kernel and use the TPM/attestation path so the game would only run on their kernel.
Back in the day, for some games you'd put the game's 3.5" diskette in your A: drive and boot from that instead of into your normal OS. A side-effect of that was "kernel level" DRM.
Seeing how games are being decompiled left and right, I wonder how long it will keep being a significant reverse engineering effort to tackle Windows...
Go read about 10 random articles there, preferably from different years, and you will realize that Windows has a formal and informal API surface that's probably close to the size of our entire solar system.
There's a reason Wine is doing only mostly ok after 30+ years of continuous development and several commercial funding rounds.
AFAIK, Hunt: Showdown successfully uses some anticheat on Linux.
But performance on Nvidia Linux is as bad as with f.ex. Cyberpunk, so I play it on A Windows instead.
On linux you(the end user) get the full source and ability to load or compile whatever kernel or kernel modules you want. So this avenue provides little utility to the anti-cheat vendors, the only reason they can pretend it works on windows, is that theoretically microsoft provides a known unchangeable kernel, and kernel modules are enumerated and signed, that is, impossible to hide and hard to install. Yeah, stop laughing, but that is what they hope to get out of it.
It's so easy to game on Linux, that next time I'll be setting up a new system I'm going to have separate users for gaming and for work/studying. It's just too easy to lose time playing Factorio, KSP, Total War, or any of the myriad indie games that somehow always work on Linux.
Like Songs of Syx, that didn't want to launch. But the demo worked. So I've set a local LLM to fix it. It just reverse engineered java code and created a fix. I followed it's work until I got overloaded with explanations how some graphic buffers were not correctly passed to the game launcher.
At the same time I joined devs' discord and reported how some rare Linux NVIDIA driver's issue could be fixed by adding an option to modify global vars that game is starting with. Next dev branch version had an editable file with global vars.
It's not that I don't like AAA games (tho I definitely stopped paying and quit League of Legends after they banned Linux to reduce amount of botters by some 5-10%). But it's a completely different experience of playing games where you can participate in the process of creation. And surprisingly, even though the Linux market is fragmented and requires lot of work to support small numbers of players (deb vs rpm vs arch, X11 vs Way, Nvidia vs AMD), when it comes to non-AAA games it's often that Linux players are not only accepted, but welcome.
Another reason to have separate users is to not give full system access to LLMs in a place where I have my personal stuff.
It took me several months of extremely sporadic effort, but it did finally happen. The first big effort was just proving to myself that I could move my entire business over to Linux. The final thing was the archaic spreadsheet that I used for generating serial numbers from a Dymo label printer. That's now a Python script, and the labels print just fine.
And then I still discover pesky little things once in a while, but it seems like there's always a Linux solution. My main hobby, playing music, makes minimal use of a computer, just for moving files around and watching YouTube videos. My other hobbies, electronics and programming, already lend themselves to Linux better than Windows anyway.
I thought my son would be impressed, but he had already switched to Mac.
Can also recommend mint + cinnamon. You type task manager and it points you to the system monitor. You type cmd and it points you to the terminal. It is the little things that helps you adapt to get off your Windows muscle memory. Some things will work worse than on windows, some things work better. But you will be amazed how good a clean operating system can be without the immense shit Windows comes with these days.
Mint uses the Ubuntu package ecosystem and it does play all games I tried (there are some multiplayer games with anti-cheat "solutions" that won't work yet, you would need dual boot here).
If you want to play games, I recommend Steam + Lutris + Heroic (I use the latter for GOG + the single Epic game I have, works perfectly).
> If all you do is web, then use your phone or a tablet.
Moving from windows device to a phone/table because it collects names of coding agents would be a perfect example of out of the frying pan to the fire, given the choice of OS we have for those.
If those caveats are not a big deal(depends on the person) compared to the privacy issues, linux is still a better option.
It worked pretty well for a long time and I was able to skip a few versions of windows which was nice.
Some more automation would probably have helped. I still needed to remotely fix problematic/broken updates etc. The automations should have worked but didn't for various reasons over the years.
Her broadband internet was flaky for long time which made it tricky. At some stage I put a pi zero in so I could check the connection without having to tell her where to click on the screen over the phone etc.
Living a continent or two away makes it tricky. Even the pi effectively needed an in-person upgrade to get it to Bookworm.
I switched my gaming machine to Bazzite a year ago or so, and it has literally worked just perfect since then. I think I've had one game crash, but that might have happened on Windows as well.
In retrospect, I should probably have gone Fedora or Ubuntu instead of Bazzite, as the immutable image setup is probably great for gaming but mostly gets in the way of other tasks, but I've been too lazy to reinstall it, and as I said, it works pretty well.
I just do my other tasks in a Ubuntu distrobox, with a separate $HOME.
If it ever gets messed up with weird dependency issues, messy dotfiles etc. i just wipe it and make a new one. I think I'm on my 4th or 5th distrobox by now, meanwhile the underlying system has been migrating smoothly since Fedora Atomic 39.
My issue is all still hardware. The VR headset is not supported and neither is my Audio out DAC/Amp. The issue is the companies that made them not Linux but it is still a real problem I have that looses functionality I use frequently. I also have the issue both screens are high refresh but different capabilities (one is 280hz and HDR capable the other is 165 and isn't HDR) and this just doesn't seem to work in cachyOS KDE well at all. I dual boot linux but I can't switch over permanently.
I switched to linux on my desktop PC, and was amazed how smooth the transition was for gaming (work always worked) after having run a server linux for 30 years, and trying desktop linux every decade or so before turning back.
Unfortunately I can't switch on my snapdragon x laptop without qualcomm being better at linux support, so I'm stuck with WSL there, which I assume Windows collects data from.
With ai is much easier, but ai tends to give wrong advice. It assume the wrong distro, wrong terminal, wrong tools installed, advices to install unnecessary duplicated tools, mixes distros, overkill advice that causes wide harm to solve minor problems. You need a careful prompt , describing your system and instructing to diagnose before advising solutions, and even then you have to ask what it does every instruction
You're not wrong that you need to be careful, but I didn't run into any of this.
I used Opus (can't remember which one, but it was recent) to start fresh recently and it worked pretty well, I even sent pics of my rig to diagnose why my fans weren't spinning and it wrote scripts to test my fans and it determined I just didn't plug it in, which ended up being true.
It property detected I was on Ubuntu and every command worked, minus some minor versioning hiccups.
I used opus to switch to cachyOS in a few hours, instead of taking a whole weekend. After I asked it to tweak the cpu performance levels, to increase game performance on energy saver, it ended up diagnosing that the RAM overclock I was using was pushing the RAM to an higher latency mode
Unfortunately, software developers haven't caught up, and many critical applications for some people just don't work well enough. For Linux to be viable for many people, they need to be able to just click on their application and for it to work. No fiddling involved. Even with fiddling, though, it's too easy to lose time and not come up with a solution.
This has to do with software developers not supporting it well enough; nothing's wrong with many of the distros.
This is changing rapidly. I was stuck on MacOS because I needed Lightroom and DJ apps. Today there are open source alternatives popping up that are very close to closing the gap for me.
As well as Affinity announcing Linux support soon.
The year of the Linux desktop is a meme because Linux desktop isn’t a fixed target where one day it’s suddenly viable. It’s a gradient where it becomes more viable for more people over time.
And I think AI boosting open source is a huge push towards making it viable.
"I'm sorry grandma, but that's because your keyring is out of date since the computer was off for so long. Oh but first you'll need to manually fix the date so ssl works" - problems nontechnical people will never be willing to deal with
As in, let them run an agent to do it for them? Cause sure as hell they won't copy paste commands into the terminal. And if they do they will bork their system:
Personally, I would never ever let an agent run arbitrary unvetted commands on a host holding valuable data (that's what disposable sandbox VMs are for).
But for a "grandma" type user who would happily fall for a Nigerian prince scam? I suspect adding Claude to the wheel group would not significantly increase their risk exposure.
I've been caught on considering switching from an M1 macbook pro to a framework linux laptop, but I'm not fully confident in whether linux is up to the "just works" state. I used to use linux on my laptop and desktop for a couple years, but when computers stopped being a hobby and started being a job, I didn't want to spend my evenings fiddling with driver issues.
At this point I don't use any computers much outside of work. I do most email and chat on my phone and have a reddit app that got the accessibility exemption and is ad/algorithm free. I pull out my laptop once a week or so and I am mostly just using chrome. I've considered switching to a tablet, but I have been thinking about going back to uni and I would need a laptop for that.
With how intermittently I'm even using a computer at all at this point, I don't want to have to be thinking about version updates every time I log in and it's nice to have something idiot-proof. I am comfortable with the terminal and have used linux in various contexts for a decade (though not on the desktop/laptop in the last 5 years), but maintaining my laptop is no longer a hobby.
I've been using a Framework 16 with Linux on it for 1.5 years now, and everything has been smooth. The only issue I had was a hardware issue, which I would have had on Windows as well.
The issue, if you're interested, was that earlier builds of the Framework 16, including mine, could flex just a little bit while closed if something was pressing on them, e.g. if they were in a backpack with a bunch of other things. This would result in the screen actually pressing keys on the keyboard when it flexed, causing the computer to wake out of sleep mode. (They've apparently fixed that in the past year with a different material for the laptop's metal frame, which flexes less, but I can't tell you from personal experience whether it works because I have kept my laptop). For original laptop owners, they released a BIOS update about six months ago that allowed the keyboard to turn off when in sleep mode, so that it wouldn't wake the computer anymore. That solved the issue for me.
So my personal recommendation is yes, buy a Framework laptop and run Linux on it. You won't be paying for a Windows license if you don't need one, unlike with most manufacturers where the price of a Windows license is baked into the price of the laptop. (Framework isn't the only one to offer you the option of not paying for Windows, thankfully).
I see others have recommended System76; I've never used them but they also have a good reputation.
You don’t need to buy a whole new laptop to get back into Linux. Dual boot it off your MacBook. Don’t get stuck in the idea you have to “abandon” Mac OS and go all in on Linux. You can have the best of both worlds.
I’ve done this with a few of my Mac devices over the years, I honestly would find myself booting into Linux more often than not.
I can recommend System76 for Linux machines that just work. They have their own distro (Ubuntu/Debian-based) that's tested with the hardware they ship, I've never had a single need to fiddle with drivers or anything else. As a product line they're a little weird in that they seem to work with whatever hardware they can get their hands on from OEMs, so there's not much look-and-feel consistency from model to model and generation to generation, but I can attest that the current-gen Lemur Pro is excellent.
> Unfortunately, software developers haven't caught up, and many critical applications for some people just don't work well enough. For Linux to be viable for many people, they need to be able to just click on their application and for it to work. No fiddling involved.
Others are already passionately debating whether Linux applications require fiddling or not.
But I would like to also add that the amount of "fiddling" involved with Windows applications has _massively_ increased over the past 10 years. Please sign in to continue. Please sync your cloud data. Please update to the latest version. Please agree to the new terms of use. We and our 84083 partners care about your privacy. Please confirm you are a human. Please set up your Microsoft® Authenticator®. We have updated your UI for a better experience, how do you like the new look? You have selected the 'classic experience', please share your feedback. Copilot® can help you draft an email. Copilot® can help you use Notepad. We have added a Copilot® key to your keyboard. Sorry, the servers cannot be reached, please retry later.
Linux has got better, whether that's enough can be argued. Windows has got so, so much worse.
Not as easy as it seems. I'm on a HP Laptop that basically cannot boot in Linux, because of problems with ACPI due to botched firmware, and HP does not want to fix it because they're crooks. Some people attempted to fix it, but the fixes are not comprehensive.
As someone that uses Linux since 1995, and UNIX in general since 1993, this is only true when using classical PC desktops, with laptops and NUCs it remains an adventure, depending on the hardware model.
No matter what trick I pulled, it could only boot from external disc, UEFI never acknowledged its existence, nor carefully prepared partitions for its consumption.
Eventually I had enough trying to make it happen, and into the recycling bin it went, I am not kidding, it was really sent into a recycling company.
If you're a person who regularly reboots your computer you might as well try a live USB of any distro or a few different ones. This is the whole Linux system written to a USB stick and ignoring your hard drive.
You make this at home by downloading one of the distros and overwriting a USB stick using one of various tools to do this. Note, it will overwrite the full contents of the USB stick and you'll have to reformat the stick to get it back to a normal state so you can put files on it again.
The main caveat would be to not care too much about hardware: if you're on a classic desktop or standard laptop setup it should be fine. Basically, if you could move to macos, you could move to linux as well.
If instead you're spending your life on a Surface Pro or a Z13, or some other alternative form factor, linux is probably not for you yet. It runs, but touch support and QOL for tablet mode is subpar at best.
I agree with this. Touch support is quite awkward, stylus support is especially worse since stylus is considered an absolutely positioned mouse than a type of touch. I'm using a Lenovo Ideapad 5, and the main reason why I have yet to switch fully (I have CachyOS on an external SSD) is due to the pen support and also shitty OneNote support (I'm supposed to use a browser??)
Which do you think is the best distro which maintains compatibility with all/most windows key strokes? Most importantly - Win-E for explorer, alt-tab for switching windows, ctrl-tab for switching tabs within a window. If I switch my home PC to linux, I will still need windows at work and can't afford to have different key bindings
Any distro with KDE would work in this scenario, because i had the same thought when i started with Linux. Kubuntu and Fedora's KDE spin are good options to get started.
For the shortcuts that don't exist or don't do what you want, you can trivially configure them. Example - ctrl+shift+esc doesn't bring up "task manager", but you can simply right click on KSystemMonitor in start menu and assign that shortcut.
I don't know every distro, but that fits Mint + Cinnamon. Win + E is file explorer. Alt+Tab switches Windows. You have a classic start menu. If you type task manager, the start menu points you to the system monitor (the equivalent of task manager). It has aliases for the typical Windows tools.
Also Mint + Cinnamon basically looks like Windows and it designed to be intuitively usable by Windows users.
KDE has these out of the box, so CachyOS (if you install it with KDE), MX Linux although I don't like that one, Debian + KDE, Fedora + KDE, Bazzite + KDE, and many many others.
Linux can be booted from USB - in fact, most of these installers are the full version of the same Linux. So for example if you download the CachyOS image, and boot it from USB, boom, you can now try CachyOS. I suggest you to try this, and to try dual-booting. That way, you won't lose your main system, should anything go wrong.
As a Debian main, I will always recommend Fedora for most other people. The end user experience on Fedora is more polished, and the hardware support is miles ahead from not having ancient software.
Or you use an atomic spin :) so far I've upgraded my system from Fedora 41 to 44. I only notice the update because after boot there's a new background image & a dialog window explaining the new features!
I swear there's like a manual for anti-linux posts that's resulted in people posting the same basic thing to reply to this since like 2008
"I daily drive every operating system known to man and the normies just aren't ready for this yet"
"Linux doesn't Just Work like [preferred corporate OS]" (lol, lmao)
Basically some flavor of "I am an enlightened computer nerd who knows that you must be a braingenius to use anything but the shareholder-approved device configurations". This is also the exact sales pitch microsoft makes when they sell hospitals, schools, and other institutions on letting them control their IT, as well as the basis of their advertising. "Your computer, simplified!" I don't buy that these people are speaking from a place of actually making a useful effort to help anyone.
Meanwhile, in reality I've been helping aunties, product managers, call center workers, and gamers use linux for several years and generally speaking there are enough desktop environment options that are learnable that generally these people are by and large happier after about a week or so. The tech companies have really been degrading the customer experience in pursuit of shiny objects, telemetry, lock-in, and ads. The bar is in hell.
I think the key to this success has been taking a different approach. A lot of people seem to say "You should do this better thing, here's a guide". Installing any linux distro is a lot more activation energy than using it, and people don't really know where to start. But getting people started requires:
1. Ask about what their use case for a computer is. You may even do a small amount of research about what's out there, if you're not already aware of what applications they're likely looking for. Most people who are used to being told what software to use are not used to looking. Despite being strongly of the opinion that most people's computing needs can be served by a linux distro, I have definitely done this for some people and said "this might not actually be possible yet, you may still need one computer to be a mac" or whatever for edge cases like very specific corporate software. Maybe have a few different DEs in mind that someone might want to use. One-size-fits-all is dumb. People's needs are different.
2. Let the person whose computer it is drive an install process, but be there to answer questions. The goal is for using the computer to be something they seldom if ever need direct assistance to do, and people get there a lot faster if they're touching the thing to set it up.
3. Have other people there. Make it a team endeavor. This makes frustrating things a lot more fun, and any messing with your computer is frustrating. If you're a computer toucher for a living, you get paid primarily to tolerate frustration while you get from a thing not working to it working.
This is hands-on, but the value someone gets out of control of their computer is worth the investment, for you and for them
Not to diminish NixOS, but what good do you believe is in there for the normal folks, besides precious disk space wasted, "everything that touches software installation" becoming orders of magnitudes slower, and more cognitive overhead?
I don't know that it can be recommended for a desktop OS, but I switched to using it for development VMs because of coding agents. I can let the agent manage things while I still have complete visibility to what it has done and ability to rollback. "Normal" people wouldn't be looking at the diffs but in terms of having reproducible configurations managed by an agent with trivial rollback when things don't work right I think they'd get the same value, if not more.
Also, it is completely inaccurate that everything touching software installation becomes "orders of magnitude slower". Some operations do take longer, but some operations are actually faster than other package managers such as homebrew.
Just as AI has advanced massively in the past two years, I think a lot of gamers would be shocked at how viable Linux is as a genuine gaming platform in 2026. I already have plans to switch from Windows to Linux, I even have Linux running from an external drive to play with it.
The vast vast majority of single player games are 100% perfect on Linux. Multiplayer still has lots of hiccups.
Praise Gabe. No seriously, you would not be saying this in 2026 had it not been for a singular person named Gabe Newell. Valve’s Proton initiative almost single handedly brought us this. I don’t use Steam, or really any Valve products or games, just as some observing third party it’s really hard to say that this would have happened had Valve not done the whole Proton thing
Before Valve gaming on Linux was limited to Super Tux Kart and a small number of ported games. Once steam came to Linux around 2013 you had a selection of indie games mostly Unity stuff that could export to Linux for free. But still almost all major games did not work.
Proton was the turning point where you went from specifically looking for Linux games to just assuming everything works.
Wine existed long before Valve poured money into it. It was nowhere near as reliable before DXVK existed, but you could play many commercial Windows games well-- you just couldn't expect nearly universal support.
I guess it depends on your definition of "play". I got many commercial games running after hours of tweaking using Wine. Many had graphics errors and performance issues but one could ~technically~ play them.
One definition of 'play' that's probably quite useful is 'have fun'. You can technically play many games at e.g. 15fps but for many games that is hardly enjoyable. Likewise for random crashes or audio issues or whatever. 'Technically playable' gives me Supreme Commander at 100x slowdown flashbacks.
Not to argue, because I agree that a buggy or crashing game isn't super fun.
However, I did have fun growing up and trying to debug what had gone wrong, searching forums and stack overflow for hints, figuring out the incantation of library versions and registry tweaks to let me play some random pirated "match-reveal" games on Slackware
It did exist, but you couldn't play most games you wanted to play. It could take months or even years—for AAA games—before you could play them. The performance was significantly worse. Today most games work on the release day and the performance is comparable to Windows.
Wow, this completely dismisses the work done by the Wine project before Proton and (perhaps controversial) products like Transgaming WineX/Cedega (which was a fork of Wine). A lot of popular games of the time worked with Cedega.
We can recognize the immersive role of Valve while also recognizing that there were quite successful efforts before that.
(Semi-related: anyone remember the good days of Loki Entertainment?)
Loki Entertainment, run by Sam Lantinga, author of SDL! Which I would argue did a lot for cross platform compatibility as well. We almost got world of warcraft for linux because of him (I added that to his wikipedia page).
Agreed, although Wine is a separate tech, Valve's contribution to it, also analogical Metal to DX on MacOs makes playing Windows games on non Windows platforms very easy and pleasant.
I don't remember last time I was using Windows daily. I only have one VM at home in VM Ware, unregistered, I launch once a month to compile one portable project that I dare to support Windows but Windows is not my first class citizen since 2011 or so...
This was the work of hundreds of people. My understanding is that the majority of it wasn't even done by Valve (they are not Linux experts after all) but rather commissioned by them and the actual work done by other companies.
All those experts deserve recognition, not just the billionaire at the top who said "let it be so".
Normally I’d agree with you. But Valve is a unique org that without Gabe would not be what it is. He made many pro-consumer anti-profit decisions. It’s worth a bit of praise.
I love Proton and use SteamOS daily, but I wouldn’t characterize the projects as “anti-profit.” I think Gabe correctly recognized the Windows monopoly and Microsoft Store as threats to his business. Microsoft wanted to recreate Apple’s App Store on their platform and take 30%.
I'd argue that GabeN has always had a broader sense of business and community respect overall, in the sense that valve doesn't only take but also gives, let people tinker with valve products, and doesn't immediately go ballistic.
Of course it is not entirely altruistic, some of it was fostered by his hatred of big M after working there, but it is baffling how much better than the competition they are ...
Now the question is how the company will do when he is gone, but I hope there is a general strategy and vision and a few guiding principles are enshrouded enough to survive him and valve doesn't go public, as soon as this happens, a lot of things are just going to go down...
I’d argue that you simply have absolutely no awareness of when you are being successfully marketed to. I’d argue that you are so used to not being the target market for things that you have mistaken this for being impervious to marketing, or being a “free thinker”. This is all just good marketing. Valve knows that gamers are skeptics that’re extremely sure of their intelligence. They therefore understand the importance of throwing the dog a bone at the right time, and playing the long game. There wouldn’t be anything special about this if it weren’t for the absolutely boneheaded cookie-cutter marketing strategies that work sufficiently well for mass-market products, that make this feel so comparatively fresh. It’s become increasingly prominent for products and services where developer-types are often organisational decision-makers. Go look at Tailscale’s marketing and business model. Go look at PostHog, whose marketing material capitalises on developer-types disliking sales and marketing people. It’s not sinister and it doesn’t mean that people in the organisation don’t care, but it’s just business. Good business, but just business. It’s not anti-profit, it’s it’s just… not making the most short-term boneheaded decision 100% of the time. Plenty of businesses do this.
I agree that in the long-term, it's obvious that these business strategies outperform the others. I agree that if you make users believe you are on their side, you will have a much more loyal userbase that stays in your ecosystem for longer. But I don't agree that it's just marketing, and I don't agree that being successfully marketed to means that it's a lie.
Good marketing tells the truth, as you want to hear it. Valve does. Do you remember "piracy isn't a pricing problem, it's a service problem"? That wasn't just marketing, it's true. You're "successfully marketed to" if you agree with that statement to such a degree that you associate with Valve and Steam over it. Does that mean you're not a "free thinker"? Does that mean you've been got?
One of the most important things in this day and age is choice. You should be allowed to choose things based on what you agree with. It is good that Valve exists, because no one else has this much agreement. No one else has their understanding. Treating it as simple marketing is an understatement. It's an underestimation. You're simplifying people to the point where their choice becomes invalid due to the very reasons it is valid!
I've been successfully marketed to many times in the past. Mostly by product placement, but also by sponsorship. Never by any banner or popup. I could say I'm impervious to advertising because it's not the advertising that convinced me. In all cases it was the product itself. It was self-evident. Maybe advertising is what got it in front of me, but in all cases I made the determination myself. I made the consideration myself.
I picked up Privacy.com from a sponsorship on The Modern Rogue. I picked up Ubiquiti/UniFi from many appearances across Linus Media Group. I picked up the LTT screwdriver, etc. It doesn't matter how I discovered them if the determination was still mine. That doesn't take away my agency or the significance of my decision. That doesn't mean I got got. And that doesn't mean all those products were dishonest.
Valve is the same way. They just are good. They've been good, and they'll most likely continue to be good. They're open. Honest. Transparent. They give back to open-source. They give you full root access to your own hardware that you purchased from them. I could go on and on. As much as you could say this is just a disingenuous marketing strategy and we've all been fooled... who cares?
> It’s not anti-profit, it’s it’s just… not making the most short-term boneheaded decision 100% of the time. Plenty of businesses do this.
Technically, yes, it's not fundamentally anti-profit - but the for-profitness we all hate is the short-term boneheaded decisionmaking you describe. Profit-on-paper over all else. It's refreshing to see businesses actually caring about customers as opposed to optimizing the report charts.
I'm very happy when marketing means competing for quality and customer satisfaction instead of the borderline-criminal behavior like Meta's and many others.
Everyone was told initially that capitalism works exactly this way and many would love to live in that world. Unfortunately we live in a spyware world with trashy race-to-the-bottom products. So proper business practices are met with gratitude and I don't see anything wrong with that. They do earn money from that, so what?
Earning money by providing your customers with high-quality products is not a bad thing.
They are threats to, his business, but also threats to us owning the software we use, to having freedom to pick a hardware platform. We won't benefit as Microsoft and the hardware companies try harder and harder to lock down the computer platform.
Gate is good for the world! That doesn't mean we have to see him as some kind of perfect person. He's doing good things for the world. Let's keep supporting him.
I wouldn't say it was "anti-profit". The decisions taken around Steam are intended to make it profitable.
It's just that it turns out you can make something extremely profitable - profitable enough to pay really expensive developers a lot of money to work on open-source software - without doing so in a way that makes customers hate you.
I don't mind "profitable". I *like* profitable. I don't like "profit over all else".
Steam Family Sharing lets anyone in your family play the games you bought, but only as many copies at once as you bought. If my wife owns a copy of game A and I start playing it on my account (which doesn't own a copy of game A), she can play game B on her account just fine. But if she loads up game A she's told "someone else from your Steam family is currently playing that game".
So it depends on what you mean by "simultaneous play". Game A and game B played at once, yes. Game A played by two people at once when you own one copy, no.
So standard per seat licensing? At least it sounds like you have a license to a particular release as long as you have it. I was reading Amazon doesn’t honor audiobook licenses sold but will bait and switch for cheaper audiobooks than what you bought.
What are you talking about? You absolutely can. I just checked to see if it was some new thing by opening a bunch of games at once, nope - no problems at all.
That also doesn't track with my experience. I enjoy playing 'idle' games every once in a while which generally entails having a bunch of games open at once. That dates back at least a decade.
Looking it up, the restriction that is/was there is that you can't run the same game simultaneously on the same account on different devices, unless the other devices are set to offline mode. I don't think that's particularly heinous.
Only one person can own a Steam account. You're mad that you can't let another user, who did not purchase your games, play the games you purchased while you play a game you purchased at the same time.
The praise here is the opposite of the broader CEO worship you speak of. People love Gabe because he's hell bent on making something good for consumers (rather than being hell bent on taking consumers money)
It's really easy to avoid the gambling aspects of CS so I think most people are ignoring it. And they really cracked down on all the 3rd party website that were encouraging it, as well as intentionally destroyed their skins market by allowing people to trade up lower quality skins. So I think it's fair to ignore the gambling.
It's pretty easy to ignore gambling. There's no banner ads pushing it on you, there's no prioritization of games with gambling in the marketplace or sales AFAIK, and unless you specifically seek out certain games you're not going to accidentally run into it. And the gambling that steam is involved with is only their in house games... which is only a small portion of the actual store right?
Wine already existed, and there were already a few companies trying to add polish to it, and there were already "living room" ui's, all before Valve, yet it is still true that the only reason it went from theory to reality is because Valve dug in and hauled it over the line, and the only reason Valve did that was because Gabe simply decided it was their way around MS and Sony and everyone else.
The comment gives credit to someone for doing something valuable. That is not worship. A worshipper might also do that, but so would a reasonable human.
I recognize countless people for countless things that I appreciate without worshipping any of them.
The company doing a large portion of the work posts on HN Who’s Hiring frequently. It makes me wonder if it’s impossible to get a job there, they aren’t actually hiring, or if turnover is insane.
I'm not sure why an established company like Valve would be posting on HN. I always figured the who is hiring threads around here are for yc companies that just graduated out.
I have seen many CEOs wreck companies. Believe it or not CEOs actually do make a difference. Without good ones your company will go nowhere and with bad one they get destroyed. They set the direction. So yes I do think he deserves credit. Don't understand the billionaire hatred.
Some people never re-evaluate their assumptions. They worked at a company with a lousy CEO, therefore all CEOs are lousy. If pressed, they would acknowledge that it's bad logic, but they've formed a habit of thinking "CEO = bad" and don't break those habits easily.
Other people have never thought about it much, defaulting to whatever attitudes they've picked up through cultural osmosis. And the only billionaires I see portrayed positively in broader US culture are Bruce Wayne and Tony Stark. Other than those two, it seems like the default Hollywood portrayal is "billionaire = bad". (I'd welcome more counterexamples, it's possible I'm wrong here because I just haven't seen the right movies; this is an impression rather than a solid argument).
And some people have a worldview that says wealth is a zero-sum game, therefore anyone rich must have gotten that wealth by exploiting the poor.
There are plenty of people who don't fit any of those thought patterns, of course. But all of them are thought patterns I've observed here and there among HN comments. (And on the broader Internet as well, naturally).
> And some people have a worldview that says wealth is a zero-sum game, therefore anyone rich must have gotten that wealth by exploiting the poor.
Wealth is not zero-sum, but it is created by work. When you collect a salary in exchange for work, it is because your employer deems that your work is worth more than your salary. Otherwise, it would not be a sound financial decision to employ you. There is literally no way to rise to the top without paying people less than you think their work is worth.
When many thousands of people create value in exchange for less money than their work is worth, that's how you get a billionaire.
You might say, "well it's your choice to work", but under capitalism, donating the surplus value of your work to an richer person is the only way to survive. As in, you will literally die if you don't. If you can somehow collect the required capital to start a company, you can try to compete, but now you're donating your surplus value to billionaire investors instead, and with much fewer protections. If you succeed, you are now the one depending on thousands of workers donating the surplus value of their work to you, and the cycle repeats.
The only way to break the cycle is to keep the coordination of many humans, but forgo the upwards flow of wealth to a few individuals. We used to do this with taxes, and it's a crude mechanism, but it worked. Collective ownership seems to work even better.
CEO worship is weird when they're anti-philanthropy, or invest in enshittifying products.
But when CEOs make the right decision, selflessly, why can't we celebrate it? The work Valve sponsored created competitive pressure that Windows never had before. Microsoft cannot rest on the laurels of DirectX anymore, which has been a concern from the entire GPU industry since the Xbox came out.
Yes, CodeWeavers and Wine deserve applause. They both accept financial contributions if you'd like to go further than just lip service, but something tells me you don't have the fuck-you money that Gabe lined his pockets with.
From the sources that I can find, Valve employs over 100 open source devs to work on Proton and Wine, and has a large contract with CodeWeavers. When I think about why Valve does it, my best guess is to long term break free of the Microsoft ecosystem. It seems logical.
It’s not a fork, AFAIK it’s a set of ‘experimental’ patches on top of Wine, but it’s work that eventually gets merged into the project when/if accepted by its maintainers.
I read it as each patch is based on the upstream, so it doesn't diverge over time. Maybe you could say it's a set of forks instead of a single fork, where each fork has exactly one patch...
Gabe praise is such an enduring exception in a culture that’s otherwise become a lot more understanding of the small overall role that leadership plays in things like this. I understand gamers lionising people like this because gamers by and large simply don’t understand tech, but let’s not bring this to HN please. This is especially frustrating as an (oft-touted by this same group of people!) feature of Valve as an organisation is the supposed extremely high degree of autonomy offered to ICs. So, which is it? Gabe Newell is just a guy. Gamers just love a hero.
You can make the argument they're extracting too much from developers, or have strong opinions on their cosmetics marketplace, but what they've consistently avoided for the 20 odd years of Steam is fleecing their customers.
A lot of their live service games are free, and cosmetics entirely detached from in-game benefits.
They have a huge entrenched customer base, and yet they don't force their customers to pay for things they don't want, and they still make tons of money hand over fist.
There's been a lesson there for publicly traded companies for decades, yet no one wants to learn.
I'm not very interested in where these decisions come from, but as Gabe has a controlling stake and it's a private company, one can assume he's at least not opposed to the decisions made.
That autonomy is a bit of a lie. It was discussed on HN when Valve's employee handbook "leaked". The tyranny of structurelessness - you still have power structures, just not formal ones. Whatever it is at Valve, Gabe Newell is the owner and there is no indication that he can't make stuff happen if he wants to.
We can also thank Microsoft and Bill Gates. The main reason Valve was forced to make Linus a viable option is because Microsoft decided to have a gaming store (Games for Windows) in 2006 to directly compete with Steam on Windows. Steam Machines was the first shot from Valve as a result. I’m happy that they didn’t stop even after that failure. IMO only a founder without a leash can do what Gabe has done.
Unfortunately this is the real answer. Valve saw the existential threat from Microsoft and knew they needed an escape hatch; that's Proton. Of course MS has been famously behind the curve on just about every market they've tried to tap into (lol Zune, Windows phone, Azure), but they're the still gatekeepers of PC gaming at the moment because every dev targets windows first. Valve is not developing Proton out of 'the goodness of their heart'. They're a multi-billion dollar corporation, not a person. Never forget that.
Valve is like the open-source Apple of gaming. Apple believes you own your data; Valve believes you own your hardware. You can see Apple as either privacy's last hope (as I do), or just a greedy manipulative capitalist empire, and the same goes for Valve.
Long story short, I think the goodness of their heart is actually a considerable factor in why they developed Proton the way they did, and especially out in the open. They weren't just trying to make money for themselves, they were trying to knock Windows down for everyone. Or rather, bring Linux up. Because they believe this choice should be available to everyone.
If they didn't truly believe that, there would be no reason to spend so much time and effort being open. You could say it's all a manipulative ploy for money anyway, but you could say that for anyone doing anything.
Apple and Valve aren’t good or bad. But I’m ride or die with them because my interests and their incentives have been aligned for the last decade. If those diverge then I’ll reconsider.
They’ve treated me well with their policies and I’ve treated them well with money. That’s all there is to it.
> You can see Apple as either privacy's last hope (as I do)
You mean, the same Apple that requires you to create an account with your first name, last name, date of birth, email and phone number so you can install software and updates on their platforms?
Why wouldn't any Linux or BSD distro be better at "privacy's last hope" than Apple?
Mostly because Linux makes everybody think you are a suspicious hacker or botnet. It's known for being sovereign, which causes everybody to block it and nobody to extend support for it. Apple doesn't have that reputation, in fact most people think strongly the opposite, which means it has extensive corporate support and trust. You do get strong privacy guarantees even if you object to the use of their services (which themselves still have strong privacy guarantees). And you get to enforce those strong privacy guarantees against the apps on your device, without losing access to the apps completely.
In practice, having access to that kind of stuff without your device also spying on you is a benefit that Linux doesn't always grant you. Not everybody needs that kind of stuff, but not everybody needs interaction at all. It takes some time and expense to get there, time and expense not everybody has yet.
I'm an avid gamer, fully made he switch earlier this year to CachyOS. Dota 2 is my main game, I get better FPS on Linux than I ever did on Windows. I play other games like PEAK, Risk of Rain 2, and Enshrouded no problem with my friends. I have been enjoying STALKER 2 on Linux as well, runs just fine.
The biggest barrier is kernel anti cheat, so no Call of Duty, Battlefield, etc. Luckily my friends don't play those AAA multiplayer games, protondb is a good resource to check which games can't run due to their anti cheat.
> I get better FPS on Linux than I ever did on Windows.
How is this actually possible? Wine is always going to add at least a little overhead because it has to translate system calls and such, right? And, well, I know Linux GPU drivers have improved a lot, but are they really better than the Windows drivers now?
Very few, if any modern games actually use WINE. In today's world, if you want a Linux build for your game, it's usually just a checkbox option in Unity/Unreal/Godot etc. A lot of games just have native Linux support. Those that don't use Proton, which is designed specifically to accelerate graphics calls.
As for faster, it's not that Linux does anything special to improve speeds, Windows is just genuinely that bad. Windows on its own consumes more resources than pretty much any Linux distro which means there's more compute for your game.
Again counter-intuitive: compatibility is better with Linux. I have some old games that won't play on modern Windows but work flawlessly under Linux.
There really is no good reason to use Windows other than being locked into Adobe software or whatever. Linux is just better in pretty much every sense.
I don’t think this is actually true. If anything native linux games have become less common after proton.
Native Linux builds used to have their own bugs like dynamically linked libraries which would go missing over time. While running a windows build in proton means any issue can be solved by the community rather than begging the publisher.
> Very few, if any modern games actually use WINE. In today's world, if you want a Linux build for your game, it's usually just a checkbox option in Unity/Unreal/Godot etc. A lot of games just have native Linux support.
Isn't Valve's own recommendation to target Windows and let Proton handle Linux compatibility?
> Those that don't use Proton, which is designed specifically to accelerate graphics calls.
I know, but Proton is just Valve's branch of Wine.
> are they really better than the Windows drivers now?
So a game I play (Path of Exile 2) started crashing after an Nvidia driver update on windows. It was really bad and they (GGG, the developers) couldn't figure out why. They created a workaround where the game wouldn't crash, but instead pause while the driver restarted. They made a video when it was finally fixed [0].
Anyway, I was on Linux at the time and completely fine. When I played with friends on windows, the instance would pause whilst their drivers restarted.
So I would say that for at least some games, it's definitely better. I also have an Nvidia card on Linux, which historically has been pretty awful.
Windows 11 has a lot of overhead with CPU and RAM from my experience (also compared to Windows 10). A minimal Arch/CachyOS setup is surprisingly light, especially for older hardware
One thing the other replies are missing, Valve publishes a native dota 2 build for Linux. The answer is probably either better drivers, less background sw, or one of the many possibilities in how valve chooses to build the binary
the key to wine, which siblings overlook, is that it doesn’t just translate syscalls. it’s a straight up fresh implementation of all the windows apis and dlls and the high level interfaces can decompose into efficient calls that provide the needed semantics
EAC Linux v2 is coming -- it sounds promising. I don't love having to disable custom kernel modules, but booting without them for gaming would be acceptable to me if I get to play some competitive FPS.
All of the major anti-cheat systems work on Linux if the developers allow it. Its the ring0 mandate that doesn't work, and that's a choice by the game devs. I sincerely hope that ring0 anticheat will never be made to work on Linux, because it shouldn't be a thing in the first place.
Video game companies have no business being in the kernel. Even security companies like Crowdstrike couldn't be trusted to write safe kernel code, so there's no way in hell I'm letting a game company poke holes in the most sensitive part of my system.
I wish companies just invested in machine learning anti cheat that would run server side so i didn't need to run some invasive garbage if I wanted to play flavor of the month multiplayer game once in a while with a group of friends
I am quite a serious 'gamer', having played professionally in the past and still now being #1 ranked in my country in League of Legends (arguably the most played competitive game in the world) even though I work fulltime. That being said, I tried doing the switch to Linux a few months back and I think for most people it will feel better, but unfortunately for me, where I put a lot of attention to detail, it was not. My core open issues at this moment were:
- FreeSync was a bit buggy to setup and triggered on weird applications when it shouldn't have (although I found workarounds to disable FreeSync trigger on certain applications).
- Most competitive games are not supported yet, thus I was forced to still have dual-boot setup.
- Graphics driver settings were not readily configurable (AMD Adrenalin e.t.c.), thus a lot of features required hacky ways to enable.
- RTSS not on Linux :( (had to use MangoHUD or native FPS caps per game). This differed per game so required some maintenance (sometimes Mango sufficient, sometimes in game sufficient, sometimes launch argument needed).
- The constant investigations of which version of Proton should I use for x-game bugs me. Even though I know I should not overthink it, every time I notice a game is not as performant as I expected it to be, I couldn't help testing different Proton flavors or versions. Windows has the automatic advantage that the performance you get is almost definitely the performance expected; there are no real tweaks that can be made.
For the most part it was still great, but if you are someone who overthinks things and pays attention to detail, there are just one-to-many little things that aren't quite right yet that bug you.
The country being Luxembourg ? You list two countries in your user page and one would be a much more impressive achievement than the other (but still impressive, I never had it in me to rank anything but bottom tier on any competitive game I tried)
Yes, I switched to Fedora in January and have been playing all sorts of games on an RTX 4080 via Steam, Heroic Games (Epic Games alternative launcher), Modrinth, emulators, etc. The only one I haven't tried is GTA V: Online as I've read it's not compatible due to anti-cheat.
Claude Code/Codex is very helpful for overcoming any transitions hurdles - pop open a shell, describe the problem, and a few moments later it's fixed up. I recommend maintaining a doc as one gets the new system setup so it can be easily reproduced and referenced later. Anytime I change a setting or install an app I find useful, it goes in the doc.
> GTA V: Online as I've read it's not compatible due to anti-cheat.
> Claude Code/Codex is very helpful for overcoming any transitions hurdles
I have successfully bypassed the anticheat of several games that refuse to run on Linux, notably Valve's own. It's possible, but Claude now refuses such tasks.
I was expecting to have a degraded gaming experience in general when I dropped Windows, but Steam/Proton is impressively good. It can actually beat Windows performance on load times for some games, since the translated Vulkan shaders are cached. I suspect the issue with multiplayer games isn't any technical limitation, but rather the anti-cheat systems not allowing it.
There's still a fair bit of tweaking involved in my experience especially if you want to game with HDR. It often doesn't just work out of the box, and fiddling around with config or launch options is not something I want to do even with the assistance of AI.
Getting closer for sure, but for now I stick with Windows for gaming.
I have Nvidia hardware also. I've heard things are better with Linux on the AMD side, so that could be a factor.
I use HDR because I have an OLED gaming monitor; It can certainly be a pain, but it's getting easier; these days it's typically a couple of flags to enable HDR and you're good. I don't mind setting it once for a game if I'm going to play it for a while. Other users will typically provide the right flags on ProtonDB.
That said, I'd rather spend all of my time tweaking configs and not getting to play the game than use Windows. It's been over a decade now since I touched Windows at all and gaming on Linux is so good now I expect to be able to play any game I want (I don't play multiplayer so anti-cheat isn't an issue).
> There's still a fair bit of tweaking involved in my experience especially if you want to game with HDR.
HDR in general is a bit of a pain on linux. I use Ubuntu 26 for work and Gnome has an HDR toggle but its HDR implementation is quite bad and leads to washed out colors and more.
Also scaling. On Windows I get a 150% option (for my 5120x2160 monitor) while on Gnome I only get integer scaling ones: 133% and 166%. The problem is, 133 is too small, 166 too big. 150 is perfect but for that I have to edit a config file manually which means I can't use the UI to change monitor stuff since that would revert my change.
I hate windows too but for certain tasks it's just much much better, at least for now. The windows auto-hdr feature works REALLY well comparatively.
I only rarely have to tweak settings, but I don't use HDR. I do use Nvidia and I've never had problems with it, just install the drivers and good to go.
It is surprising how playing games in linux is so straightforward (as long as it does not have anticheat though), but trying to open a standard document like pdf with some forms it is just a pain at least on Okular or libreoffice.
In windows you can get xpdf or foxit, that they don't offer perfect compatibility but never encountered an issue with forms. It does not seem to exist such a thing in linux, neither it looks like they are keen to solve it anytime soon.
Another issue is someone unsafely extracted a pendrive in windows. There is no easy way to read or write in that pendrive without a windows machine.
But if you have a pdf on a KDE default configuration it opens with okular not with firefox. I imagine that gnome would do the same with evince?
Those little nuances are often overlooked by people with more technical knowledge, but I can't set up a computer to, for example, my mom and forget about it.
Even if I do the extra mile to configure pdf with firefox, there is going to be another little thing like this. Yes it is solvable, but it should not need a workwaround.
The same way, that installing a local account in w11 is solvable, with a workaround. Workarounds should not be the solution.
Well, of course it's different. In one case, you're translating the Windows software, and in another case, you're trying to re-implement the software from scratch. The equivalent to Proton would be translating Microsoft Office instead of trying to rewrite it.
I understand the differences. It is mostly that with enough work, what was an herculean impossible task, is now a piece of cake. The Linux Desktop needs more of those Herculean to polish a bit more for other stuff.
Honestly I would say the game situation now is a problem solved.
Linux gaming was basically a hobby for so long until the muscle at Valve really brought things along. The only thing that sucks is the entire Linux UX for anyone who isn’t a computer person. But Valve is also really bringing that along, too.
Modern KDE (6.x) with OnlyOffice and Brave/firefox is a dramatically better experience for the 99% than Windows 11.
It’s incredible that the comparison of Windows 7 vs 2009’s Linux still remains the measure by which people judge the current status quo.
Seriously go onto either and try to:
- Edit a docx file (Windows: prepare for licensing fun)
- Set your audio output to use a Sonos or homepod (KDE: 2 clicks; Windows: impossible)
- Edit a PDF file (Windows: abandon all hope)
It’s rather analogous to trying to use a smart TV’s native interface vs an AppleTV. I guess if you want a slow, un-ergonomic, ad-ridden, half-baked experience…?
I would argue that most skilled technology professionals are sticking to Windows 10 for long as they can. I'm not sure where this Windows 7 /2009 Linux comparison is coming from, but at least on Windows 10 (and generally speaking):
Edit a DocX file
Why can't people just use the same OnlyOffice software you mentioned? There are so many tools and editors out there in this day and age.
Set audio output device
What's your point here? It takes two clicks for selecting an audio device from the desktop/task tray at least in Windows 7/10.
Edit a PDF file
I keep seeing this but, who in their right mind edits PDF files? Short of minor changes (e.g. signature stamps, secure sign, move/extract) PDF format is akin to a finished photo in photography. Better to edit the source document with your layers and everything than trying to adjust something that shouldn't be modified directly.
Even so, at least with modern, well designed documents Microsoft Office and other comparable tools have had the ability to open/modify/transform PDFs back to other formats and vice versa for some time. Absolutely wild comparisons, all things being equal.
> It takes two clicks for selecting an audio device from the desktop/task tray at least in Windows 7/10
I think the parent's point was more that you can't set a Sonos device to be an output device on Windows (or at least it won't automatically detect them and set them up for you as such), whereas on modern Linux this will Just Work.
there isn't really anything special about the docx format, it's literally just a zip file container with some XML blobs and the original doc document within in. The formatting fidelity of some text may get lost and/or images could be destroyed if you open it wrong, but the standard itself is fairly well understood and others have implemented it well by now.
My wife's gaming PC is NixOS with KDE and she doesn't seem to have a lot of issue with it. She's not really a computer person and hasn't had too much trouble navigating modern KDE at all, though granted she does have me for tech support if necessary.
I really don't think modern Linux is "nerd UI" anymore, at least KDE and Cinnamon are pretty approachable for non-software people.
We also live in the era of LLMs. One of the nastiest things about Linux in the past was the elitism/RTFM type stuff. The era of ATFLLM means basically anybody should be able to comfortably run Linux if they want.
> The only thing that sucks is the entire Linux UX for anyone who isn’t a computer person.
But also, most PC gamers are computer people, maybe not to quite the same extent as the average HN reader but certainly much more than the average person. Non-computer people play games on consoles.
I think you'd be shocked at how untrue this is. Most people under like, 30, who game on PC barely even understand folder structure. They just prefer PC either because of the games it offers (counter strike, for example) or the fact that you can get higher FPS than a console.
If that's the case they could just use Bazzite/SteamOS and call it a day, CS runs native on Linux.
Linux's real "issue" with gaming is that it doesn't support most non-Valve AAA multiplayer titles namely COD, Battlefield, Marvel Rivals, Overwatch, LoL, Valorant, among others.
Linux's issue is that its not user friendly. Has it become much, much more user friendly over the years? Absolutely! But in that same period of time Windows has only been more and more dumbed down.
Put yourself in the shoes of an iPad kid born in the mid 2000s. All they know is an app store and maybe a downloads folder (that isnt called a folder). They know windows, maybe they use it at their part time job or something, so they get a PC and install windows. Steam is the app store.
Lots of them genuinely have no idea about downloading random .exe files to install, file structure in a computer, or even getting drivers directly from the hardware manufacturer's website.
From that point of view, Linux, however simple, is extremely complex. The other compounding factor is that these younger people typically focus on f2p, GAAS type games. Warzone, Fortnite, and so on. All games that wont work on linux. So the proportion of a younger cohort playing games that just wont work on linux is higher than say, you or me.
> or the fact that you can get higher FPS than a console.
I mean, you're saying they know what FPS means, that's kind of a big deal.
I'd assume most also have some idea of what antialasing is, what VRAM is, and stuff like that. Because otherwise... I don't understand how you do anything? Are people just buying prebuilt PC's from Dell and using the default graphical settings?
I get most of my knowledge of this from both having younger family members and having gone back to uni, so speaking to uni age people whilst feeling like a boomer myself.
They've got no idea what AA is, but follow the rule of thumb that higher number = better. FPS matters as much as they notice the game feels better, but if you press them on their monitor refresh rate, they would have no idea.
They'll buy pre-built custom PCs from PC builders, or in my case, get a family member (me) to build it given a particular budget. Download steam, then hit install. Sometimes they'll change the graphics settings ingame but that typically comes to the pre-set settings profiles (low/med/high/ultra etc).
I honestly think people here saying they expect people to know what VRAM/AA is if they know what FPS means are just incredibly out of touch or trolling
I mean, the FPS counter is extremely common everywhere, every video/benchmark/measure is about how much FPS this or that is, why would a niche thing like AA/VRAM be known vs. the thing everyone talks about?
and I'm saying this because I'm pretty sure this has been a thing for like at least a decade now, it's not a new phenomenon
and I struggle to understand the whole "I don't understand how you do anything?"
like do people here really think that games require you to know every little thing under the graphics settings? surely Sony doesn't expect PlayStation users to know all that, so why would you need to on a PC?
I'm young, so I can't relate, but I feel like sometimes people here are incredibly proud to be old and out of touch, it's kind of like a rite of passage to be able to tell everyone that you have no idea what the new generations are like?
I just think while it's fine to not know everything, it's maybe not the best for you to be completely isolated and unaware of what's going on, and I'm talking more about stuff in general vs PC gaming
I don't think they're trolling, it's just really easy to overestimate how much the average person knows about a topic you're an expert in (good old https://xkcd.com/2501/).
Most of the techies here are so used to having their expertise (and being surrounded by other experts) that they don't even realize that things they can do in their sleep are black magic to the average person. Especially given how different the average person's experience with tech is today, compared to even just 15 years ago.
E.g. recently I was teaching an intern some C++ only to stumble on how to explain compiled binaries to someone whose primary experience with software was apps and with programming was Python scripts. For me, that understanding was built as a child screwing around in WinXP and trying to open exe files in notepad, so it caught me off-guard to realize that the defaults on modern OSs make such tinkering harder to stumble into.
This was true pre 2015 but it’s very much untrue today. Xbox died off PS5 has stagnated, PC gaming has been constantly growing and mobile has exploded.
By the numbers the average gamer plays on a phone.
What is terrible about Linux ui? I've used it for so long I can't step outside of and be objective. Hard to believe it's worse than win 11 or golden gate for any of the major desktop environments (only used kde for a while, though)
Some pain points. (It's tough for me too as I'm familiar and comfortable with it)
- Reliance on terminal
- Sudo system feels designed for servers and muti-user IT systems; is friction for PC use
- Software installation can be inconsistent and/or use CLI. Depends on the software; it's possible to make easy-install linux software, but some vendors make it complicated or require compiling from source for reasons I don't understand.
Desktop linux largely uses polkit and elevation dialogues, not sudo.
What have you needed to do with terminal? KDE (kubuntu etc) largely shouldn't, it's an option for power users, it shouldn't be something you are forced to interact with: similar to cmd or the windows registry... it exists but it's not like you are expected to interact with it.
I also haven't compiled software for myself in about a decade. But of course you are beholden to the package maintainers.
I can answer this concisely; not in the terms exactly you describe, but I hope sufficiently: What you describe is a different experience from what I have observed.
edit: I think I understand from reading context: I do not assume all software someone will use is available on the distro's package manager, or that I want to use the versions on the distro's package manager. I think these discussions sometimes get confused because there is mentality A: that you should only use software on your OS's app store, and B: That you should be able to run arbitrary software. I suspect you are A and I am B here, but am not sure.
I agree that if you only use included software or install software from your package manager, most of the pain points, including the ones I mentioned go away.
Every piece of software(1Password, my own, and others) that I wanted to install has required me to paste an incantation into the command line to install it. It is incredibly unfriendly to less technically inclined users.
It should be:
Download RPM package ->
Double click RPM package ->
Approved access elevation prompt ->
Done!
Instead it fails completely by either trying to open the package like an archive or opening it in Discover to show the package information with no option to install it.
Ideally you open “software centre” and there is a 1password you can just click “install” on, in fact: that is how it works. No need to use a web browser at all.
You’re applying Windows thinking to another OS. Maybe we should make dummy installers that are just links to package managers for refugees; you’d have the same problem going to a Mac, its only windows software that forces every application to have its own update lifecycle system in its own process.
I'm applying how mainstream operating systems work to Linux. Windows is easy, download the installer and run it. MacOS is also easy, download the disk image and copy the application to where ever.
My experience with Linux and installing applications has been a disaster. They fail to install from a downloaded RPM or DEB just by opening them. So the fallback is the command line which is already a failure for non-technical users. A simple "sudo dnf ..." is not too much to ask users to learn, but now they are being taught to copy and paste commands into the Terminal that they don't fully understand.
So, in that way they are similar- and you can download software, just barely anyone does that. Static binaries do work, but since almost nobody is embedding update methods in linux software I wouldn’t recommend it.
It's all beautiful until something doesn't work. Then you go find official website, read that "default repository contains old version, go add this repository instead, here are some magic commands to paste in terminal".
Indeed, I have the same gripes, even when using one of the more popular distros (Fedora).
From the top of my head, software I could not find in the main repos and had to resort to adding a COPR (= custom repo) for, install a downloadable .rpm, or worse use their suggested bash pipe install thingie:
- Docker
- VSCodium
- Joplin (note taker)
- GlobalProtect-openconnect
- AirVPN's client (yes, I know I can generate a openvpn config, but I think many users might not want to/be able to)
- Yadm
Some apps offer Flatpak installs as an alternative, but in many cases they are not maintained by the actual developers, but rather by a regular user/third party you have to trust.
In a nutshell, I don't find this particularly user friendly, and I don't think it can be expected of all users to understand the intricacies of the different linux package ecosystems and their implications, especially when the built-in GUI package managers do not always make it clear which source you are installing from (and why you would want a native package over a flatpak one for example).
Disclaimer, I still prefer using Linux, both for work and gaming, but I believe this is a major point of friction for many potential (new) users.
every year theres less and less of those is my point.
Docker is definitely “power user” software btw. If you can’t handle running commandlines you will almost assuredly have a really difficult time with docker itself on any platform.
That said, adding extra repos is possible in Ubuntu software center without a command line, I suspect Docker thinks it is catering for a demographic here.
This is not specifically docker issue, docker is just an example.
Installing 3rd party software on Linux is often painful - you rely on official distro maintainers(slow) or official vendor distribution(not easy) or third party source like AUR(may not work and you are trusting some random guy to not steal your bitcoin wallet)
True, true with terminal. Figure 90 percent is in browser these days, though. and can open a dpkg or whatever via file browser and so many things are available by appimage. But i suppose navigating even just releases on GitHub is beyond so many.
The Linux UI isn't terrible. It sucks for macOS and Windows users simply because they have to invest time into learning it. For non-computer people, they don't want to deal with change. For computer people, they don't want to discard the years they have invested into developing workflows. All of the laundry lists of bad UI choices in Linux are just that. If a Linux user were to do the same, the lists would be just as long.
There are other places where Linux is weak, particularly in application support. Not everyone is a developer or a gamer.
One thing I observed installing Ubuntu on one of my parents computers is they just never updated it. Normal users never update things and expect the computer to update itself.
This is almost incompatible with the average Linux user who froths with rage if you even suggest the option of automatic updates.
The foundation is unsuitable for non embedded/server environments. Everyone uses management tools so they can avoid maintaining FHS which is unsurprisingly one the first things Apple thrown out when transitioning to Unix.
Wake me up when KDE learns how to align things and how to be feature rich instead of button rich. Windows 11 is so bad it's almost on the level of Linux.
While I agree, and I have other minor criticisms (icons everywhere!), it's been so good for me in other areas I'm willing these things slip. I appreciate it for being an environment that is mature, has familiar defaults (to me), is not too opinionated and generally just gets out of my way.
People have been complaining about Windows ux for a while. It's so weird and ad-ridden today compared to where it was in 2010. Most Linux distros come with something people are familiar with and like, taking bits from Windows 7 or osx
> It’s also amazing having my dev environment be so close to the server environment I deploy on. Continuity and harmony.
this is definitely the best part for me. no need to worry about buggy WSL or whatever. once I booted in, I basically never went back. and probably never will considering how big of a mess Windows 11 is
Progress is being made on the multiplayer front (Epic games is getting Fortnite to work on Linux) but the issue isn't really a software one, it's a mismatch of goals:
- Linux users don't want companies to spy on them or harvest their data without consent
- Multiplayer game companies don't want cheaters to sabotage the community and cause a collapse in trust and paying customers
I swapped earlier this year to linux as my main. It plays most every game I play. The ones it doesn't are the ones that have certain kinds of anticheat (so mostly multiplayer). Things like dota2 have a native client and work great. However, it isn't seamless for windows games, I had all kinds of minor issues which all needed some kind of adjustment to settings. Luckily in the world of AI I can just my AI agent to diagnose and fix issues. I really like it. Linux is completely viable for most anything and hopefully with enough momentum we will see more people switching. Not that I'm anti microsoft, I still use it at work and have it set up really nicely for the things I do and it has a bit more "polish". I just think its just much better long term that the OS is open source and random marketing / executives can't hijack windows (or apple) OS to inject things people just hate.
Ironically, the mouse curve on linux for Dota 2 (a direct port to linux AFAIK) is the just the right kind of wrong that I still need to play it on windows. I've even had agents try to reproduce with a mounted copy of windows on the same computer and it got closer, but still not enough. Did you solve it?
Out of curiosity have you tried forcing the Windows version through Proton on Linux and seeing if it's a problem there? I've had to do this with CS in the past due to native bugs, could be an option if keeping Windows around is a pain
It is almost good, but not nearly close to Windows - even Valve own projects like CS2 work noticably worse than on windows(no Wayland support OOB, HDR issues, if you hack Wayland ON, then overlay does not work + only Windowed mode).
I only play single player games and they really are 100% perfect. The heaviest "AAA" game I've played recently is probably the Indiana Jones game. Played perfectly. No hiccups at all. Currently spending a lot of time with Starfield.
That said, it's always worth checking ProtonDB for compatability and tips for working around any problems, when they exist.
I deleted my Windows partition months ago, as I can play WoW Forever and Diablo 4 flawlessly on my Linux desktop box, no hacks, using the Battle.net launcher.
I even get higher FPS than on Windows though admittedly these are not the most demanding games.
All thanks to Valve (I launch them via the Steam launcher).
Yep I made the transition recently. I built a Steam Machine for the living room that should last into the PS6 era. And now my main PC dual boots into Linux. I just realized I never boot into Windows anymore, but I'm afraid of wiping it just yet. Maybe it's only a matter of time. My work PC still runs Windows unfortunately.
Linux has surprised me at how easy its been to use, especially compared to modern Windows. I highly recommend it. Also Bazzite if you're into gaming.
Well when you think about it, the Windows games are just calling out to library functions within Windows, that in turn often hook into library functions within maybe some vendor library that's part of a driver.
If you make those faster you make the game faster.
If all you're doing is slinging triangles at a GPU, then the faster you can do that - without having to ask other bits of the OS for help - the faster the game will draw.
I've been using CachyOS now for almost a year and it has been a very stable gaming environment. Granted, I don't play the latest FPS games. Mostly just World of Warcraft, Anno, and Civ.
The only weird issue I have is some websites, specifically banks just refuse me from logging in and give me a generic error or access denied. I pull up the same site on my macbook and it works fine.
Any time I tried desktop linux, I haven't seen anything that would make me want to use it daily over windows, even ignoring software compatibility issues. Windows sucks, but it sucks in a familiar way I can easily deal with so I can ignore its existence and just run the software I actually care about.
"the devil you know" is indeed a painful disincentive to switching, the natural lock-in effect of inertia is enormous and often understated.
Coupled with some major AAA's not working, I understand why people are reluctant to switch. It's a bit of a chicken and egg problem.
That said, it is hugely viable now, so you have a choice: surrender yourself to data mining and an increasingly hostile platform, or take the plunge and try.
I'm super happy that this choice exists, Microsoft no longer has us by the balls.
As long as the thing you're installing is on Steam.
The gymnastics you have to do to run non trivial games not on Steam, especially ones with installers can be insane. Adding a non steam game, running the installer, finding that the "add this to my desktop and start menu" options you selected in the installer did nothing, then adjusting the target of the non steam game you just added to be in ~/.local(which is hidden)/share/steam/steamapps/<literally some random number>/pfx/drive_c/Users/steamuser/AppData/Local/<some random subdir> and then finding the right .exe..., oh and don't forget to also set the directory or the game won't load correctly.
And god help you if that's not enough and you need protontricks.
How the HECK am I going to convince a single person who's not spent the last 30 years of their life in front of a computer to switch to this? This is competing with "double click .exe, press next a few times, done". To any non-nerd, this kind of workflow is complete and utter madness and actually, even as a nerd, I completely agree with them. WTF.
The answer people seem to have come up with are launchers like Lutris which come with install scripts. Which would be great... if many of those weren't simply broken, or installed ancient versions of Wine and are generally, somehow, simply buggier than just running the game on plain ol' Proton as is.
It's usually console ports that have issues, otherwise all the PC games run great even with competitive with anti cheat. Valve has been doing god's work, Gabe deserves all the yachts.
Playing Windows games via Proton is no different from playing Amiga or Arcade games on Linux via the respective emulators, or translation layers.
Without Windows there are no Proton games, and the amount of studios that care about Linux native games outside Android NDK, is ridiculous low numbers.
Have you used Proton? It is not just an emulator, it is a full Windows API written for linux. And the amount of games that just work is huge. I know you know it.
Also, steam deck became a popular platform studios do optimize for.
I play on my laptop, desktop, the deck, my tv. My kid plays on the deck.
For all practical intents and purposes this IS gaming on linux.
Given that the outcome is the same: the code runs in a seamless manner, and people don't have to suffer through whatever closed-source OS vendor pushes onto them? Steam Deck sales speak for themselves, and the overall ecosystem benefits from it massively.
I mean, I barely remember the last time I deployed code into a non-virtualized environment. Binary translation, virtual machines, just-in-time recompilation - all fine with me as long as it works well.
Or, if we speak about games. Some early games made it supereasy to port games and game logic because of using a vm behind the scenes (Another World and Quake 1). Who cares?
Emulation and API translation makes running vintage titles trivial on Linux, and I don't remember my daugther complaining about this, ever. My collegue from sales plays his brutal soulslike on Steam Deck, and he doesn't really know what Linux is.
I have used Linux many times over its lifetime of existence, but always ended up going back to Windows for gaming, until I switched to Linux for the last time a couple of years ago. I am never going back again. Linux gaming is simply great, and Windows sucks worse than ever. I can run everything I want.
Which distro are you running? I tried Pop!_OS as a daily driver but I ran into regular problems like the window size acting up on games, my camera or audio failing on Zoom and remote desktop not working, so I got tired of attempting to fix it and went back to Windows. Windows has a lot of flaws, but they are predictable, while the Linux issues seen rather unpredictable.
Not OP but frankly Pop!_OS hasn't been good for a long time and I really do not think people should recommend it. It's notorious for being, frankly, very buggy.
If you're up for something completely different, I'd recommend Omarchy. If you just want a super solid desktop with KDE that'll feel familiar coming from Windows, CachyOS.
I am hitting a lot of issues with CachyOS as well, Linux just ridden with all types of bugs. One day it just panicked on every boot because of NULL-pointer dereference in BTRFS kernel driver.
Then I had bluez crashing when reconnecting BT headset. Then I had USB ports randomly pop off because of some bug in usb driver.
Now after some update I have broken sleep and one of my dispalys not coming back after waking up.
AFAIK, currently CachyOS(and Arch) DBuS server still built with debug setting which will crash your whole system if one of the userspace clients provide NULL-pointer as argument. Like, wtf??
This kind of issues are just so rarely hit on windows.
Disappointingly, some games (and even some publishers writ large) will deliberately block Linux users. Two recent examples:
- From everyone's favourite, EA, most of their bigger titles including Battlefield 2042 and Battlefield 6 don't work on Linux due to EA's anti-cheat settings.
- On the smaller studio side of the spectrum, Bulkhead, who develops WARDOGS, had a wild 180 around the time the game entered its open beta where the anticheat was configured to start blocking Linux users. This was a massive middle finger to the closed beta Linux testers and players. The stated reason on the official Discord framed Linux as some sort of hive for hackers and malware developers, which is as ignorant as it is insulting.
I might try it, I've usually had a bias towards modern settings for FPSes. I've heard good things, though.
Right now I'm on a break from traditional shooters, though, Deadlock's got most of my attention.
My point, in any case, is that some developers or publishers are operating from a point of either bad faith or truly staggering ignorance about Linux. HLL might be a good game but it doesn't change that the devs for a different game made a really weird call and publicly justified it in one of the dumbest ways I've ever seen.
This will sound hilarious, but I only have a windows PC for the purpose of PUBG. I have some friends who I've been playing with for almost a decade now, and some of them have moved a few timezones away, PUBG is the major way we get to connect on a regular basis so I've stuck with it. I really can't be bothered messing around with dual boot, the rest of my life is on my Mac. If I could just boot into linux and work/play I'd probably switch my life to linux again.
60 FPS is plenty, so I have no idea why you're complaining. Factorio should work great on Linux and the devs really work hard on it, so I would suggest submitting a bug report if you're having issues.
Hm, I may try Bazzite due to the atomic updates. Probably Deck mode because gamescope FTW. The one problem I've yet to solve is KVM (mostly the KM part), I need to get around to making that custom hardware device one of these days. Haven't heard of any solution that meets my requirements (wired ethernet, relative and absolute mouse input, macOS client)
I'm going to make an educated guess that by KVM, you're referring to remote desktop, rather than virtual machines or hardware video/input switchers, neither of the latter have any problems on any Linux distro. For basic remoting, the KDE-integrated RDP server works pretty well. If you want remoting good enough for gaming, Sunshine/Moonlight have you covered.
I'm not referring to remote desktop exactly, I'm referring to remote input. I already have a Thunderbolt capture card I use for viewing the video signal. I just need a keyboard and mouse input. Deskflow does that for me currently, but it's quite crashy and unstable, so I'd quite like to replace it. I figure the best way to do that would be to replace it with a hardware device, but I haven't found one I like, so I plan to make one. Note that I'm not talking about USB switches because my built-in keyboard and trackpad can't be plugged into that.
I already have remote everything else. I even have remote power & reset button! Gosh I love that thing. It's nice to give the PC a quick little reset before each gaming session.
If Affinity came to Linux I’d probably quit Windows. It’ll never happen now that it’s just Canva, but I need a better emulation package than I’ve figured out.
> The vast vast majority of single player games are 100% perfect on Linux. Multiplayer still has lots of hiccups.
The truth is if it can't play the 2026 AAA games on day 1, let alone games such as GTA 6 especially with multiplayer, then gamers won't even bother to switch or even touch Linux consoles such as the Steam Machine.
They even rather buy a supported console (Xbox or PS5) to play the game first just to wait for it to be on PC, which will be a year later.
By the time it reaches Linux or the Steam Machine, it would be roughly 3 years after.
Yes! And using local llm harnesses can greatly assist in configuration, troubleshooting and customization! I'm 100% on Linux (Arch) since february - no regrets.
This one seems to specifically target coding agents, but then, I'm sure they did targeted metrics gathering of specific categories of apps for years so I'm sure this is a nothingburger.
In all fairness I don't really care if Windows knows which agents or developer tools I use. I don't use agents, but am thinking about writing a dashboard/harness for agent management soon. My dev tools are Node, VS Code, git. Boom, there ya go.
As for switching to Linux the learning curve will vary with the user. I forced my wife onto Linux and it required about 30 minutes of training. She did not really know anything about Windows besides clicking on desktop icons, so with that 30 minutes of training is a power user compared to where she was. If you are a powershell guru with lots of Windows system management the learning curve will be greater, but systemD is great.
The biggest handicap is that the wife bought a new HP printer without checkout for support and the printer has no Linux drivers.
Don't do it in the settings, do it with group policy settings. Windows will not override those like it will "user" settings.
Computer Configuration > Administrative Templates > Windows Components > Data Collection and Preview Builds.
Allow diagnostic data -> set to 0
Group Policy Management Console, go to Computer Configuration > Administrative Templates > Windows Components > Data Collection and Preview Builds
Limit dump collection -> set to 0
The privacy.sexy site/scripts have further settings to disable the (numerous) other telemetry "features" in Win11. Careful, as the 'full bore' privacy setting locks things down so much that Windows won't detect whether it's connected to the internet because it disables the internet connectivity test to MS servers. This can interfere with windows update and, annoyingly, even some game stores. Origin, for example, will refuse to connect if Windows thinks it isn't connected to the internet.
Fwiw I've run a Win11 install for a couple years, set it off on day one, and it's still off.
Obviously I still agree that it's ridiculous that this is on by default etc etc, Microsoft bad, but N=1 I haven't seen them resetting settings anytime recently, and tbh I'm kinda curious whether y'all are talking from experience or just saying stuff.
It seems a bit unpredictable, possibly a bug. Most of my day 1 settings stuck, but for example OneDrive flipped itself back on about three times before it just stayed disabled. Colleagues I've asked about it said they had no issue getting it to stay off.
From there it's really just a half-step to forming a conspiracy theory that MS is doing it on purpose. About as reasonable as noticing things missing from a convenience store and wondering if maybe the person next door with 165 shoplifting convictions might be involved.
I've been a heavy macOS user for dev work since early adolescence. Before that I used FreeBSD, so I'm comfortable with the command line. (Yes, you read that right.) But it's been a while since I used anything other than macOS for serious development work. A lot of the shenanigans around macOS Tahoe made me seriously consider switching to Linux. Last month I finally got the gumption and set up a Linux desktop how I like it.
I see no reason why any developer, other than someone writing something for the Windows platform specifically, should not be using Linux over Windows. MacOS has a ton of polish in so many places—but then there are all these little paper cuts that keep coming: funny little bugs that interrupt work or make you scratch your head. Peeking over the garden wall into Windows' garden only seems worse. Linux by comparison is awesome! I look forward to spending my day on my Linux desktop.
Seriously, if you do dev work, do yourself a favor and boot up—I dunno, maybe Fedora Silverblue—on a separate partition and force yourself to work on it for a day or two. Use an LLM to diagnose issues as they come up. (I had some serious stability issues; Claude suggested it was a memory issue; running memtest86 told me I had bad RAM—fixing that and all problems went away.) You'll find that your system is quieter and less distracting.
I still don't think Linux is for "average users"—even though most people probably only need a web browser. But if you have gone anywhere near a command line in your life, it will be worth the switch.
> I see no reason why any developer, other than someone writing something for the Windows platform specifically, should not be using Linux over Windows.
I agree, but I think there's a big reason they do use windows. A lot of companies choose Windows for corporate IT. That's a decent enough choice if most of your company are non-devs working in email, excel and word etc.
In a big company, that often leaves developer using windows.
That's been the story whenever I've had to use windows professionally in the past anyway.
Things have changed though. It's not uncommon for non-technical people to have a working Linux desktop as their daily driver. The problems those people come up with (to me the actual "techie") is mostly related to web applications being shitty web applications. Nothing any browser or OS can do anything about.
And whenever I'm confronted with MS-Windows 11, I have trouble just right clicking a file. So then I have to hold down shift, but then the file isn't selected anymore so I get the wrong context menu, again. I wouldn't be able to adjust to Windows if my life depended on it.
> I still don't think Linux is for "average users"—even though most people probably only need a web browser. But if you have gone anywhere near a command line in your life, it will be worth the switch.
There are Linux distros like Ubuntu that are far simpler to use for the average user than Windows, especially nowadays that the average user is used to smartphones, where you go to a store and install an app with one click.
Windows is much more complex to use to me, I've installed Ubuntu to a lot of average users and the feedback they gave me was always that it was so simple to use compared to Windows, install programs with one click (yes, now Microsoft has its store but for most software you still need to go on the internet, download the installer, answer questions the average user has no clue what to respond, and hope to have downloaded the official installer and not a virus), there are no automatic updates that start without your consempt that will break your PC (you don't know how many people computer break after a Windows update), there are no viruses, no need to create an account just to be able to start using your computer, usually the stuff you connect (e.g. printers) doesn't require you to install a dedicated driver, and you can keep using your 15 years old PC just fine, no need to buy a new hardware every 4 or so years because Windows 11 needs 16Gb of RAM just to boot.
Unless you have the need to use particular proprietary software (which most user don't, since nowadays practically everything is web based and 99% of the stuff they use is the browser) there is no sense in using Windows.
All software that the average user wants is on the Microsoft Store which has been there since 2012 and has carried desktop programs since 2016. It doesn't need an account.
Except it's not true, there are a ton of popular open source apps that you find on almost any computer that are not available in the Microsoft Store, or are available with some limitations.
To use Windows 11 without a Microsoft account (and thus without connecting to the internet!) you need to open the command prompt trough a keyboard shortcut and type in a console command during the account creation process, surely something the average user knows how to do and doesn't assume that it's forced to create an account since there is no "Skip" option available in the UI.
I would not ever use Windows for development, but as a Linux user, collaborating with Mac and Windows devs, I found Mac to be an even worse platform. I worked on build systems for embedded and Mac was by far the most problematic platform. Windows at least has WSL2.
What do you use for corporate email? Many places use Outlook, and the web version is inferior. From I have seen in those envs, devs can use WSL2 or just run a VM with Linux desktop.
Hot take: Users (including devs) choose Macs because of prestige and premium feel, not really for technical reasons. Of course, often citing other reasons.
I use windows in work (games), and all my personal devices are Mac/iOS. I don’t want to spend _any_ of my spare time tinkering with why my WiFi drivers aren’t working, or if a specific GPU is compatible. That still rules out Linux (or at least it did in 2024 when I last properly looked). The sleeping, hibernating and power management side of windows is shocking - my work laptop will come out of my bag dead probably twice a week a the only way to make that not happen is to go through a full shut down and boot. This is with a think pad, and my previous dell xps at my last job had the same problem, as does my wife’s work laptop. The trackpad hardware is shocking, as are the drivers.
My MacBook Pro “just works”, and has a terminal and a clear favourite package manager (homebrew) that means it doesn’t get in the way. It’s alive when I want to use it, I just open/close the lid. It shares clipboard and browser state between my phone and Mac even on different browsers (safari/firefox). I’ve bought one every 6 years (my last one being an M1 Mac which is still snappier than the 64 core 256GB workstation that I have at my desk in work). It’s also no more expensive than a matching spec XPS, or Samsung phone
Macs are usually better supported in corporate environments. Desktop IT guys just want to check compliance boxes and go home, they are already annoyed they have to support some Macs so desktop Linux is out of the question.
This is unfortunate, but absolutely true for me too. My personal computer is a Linux ThinkPad and I am pretty happy with it. At work, having to meet clients and partners regularly, I stick to my MacBook Air pretty much for that reason alone. Not for prestige exactly, but it raises less eyebrows. So yes, a status thing, which is pretty sad.
--
The only other real reason to prefer MacBook Air specifically is that it has no fan at all and barely ever heats unless I really start doing crazy stuff on it. This is really nice. I still didn't find a good powerful Linux-capable laptop that won't try to lift off when I have it on my lap. I am considering a new Framework 13 Pro, though.
I've seen plenty of normal users opting for Macs just to get away from Windows. Linux is still a bridge too far for most without Best Buddy Tech Support™, since even just installing Linux is an enormous ask for a casual users, and the options for laptops with Linux preinstalled are slim and thus not something a causal user knows about. Macs make their offer on the same level that the users are on while being mainstream, so it's not hard for me to understand why they're taking that option.
Well, I just recently got my first Apple device, a (used) MacBook Air.
Indeed for technical reasons alone. Mainly because I develope while on the move a lot.
It is powerful enough for my dev work - and it does not have a fan. I can put it on dirty ground without dirt coming inside (no fan air slids). I can even leave it running overnight and not be bothered by fans starting and stopping. It has a very long battery life - and still way better performance than my thinkpad t480, which is just a loud electrical heating device in comparison.
So I really enjoy this device - despite being very annoyed by macOS. Linux on it would be amazing, but I am not willing to trade in battery life. But you are free to believe that this is "premium feel".
The hardware quality of macbooks is genuinely peerless though. People always have an answer for what the Windows or Linux equivalent supposedly is, but I've tried many of them over the years and they're never as good.
I've never even personally owned a mac, but it's good to give credit where it's due.
I think so too. Although consciously, I chose a mac pro recently for the same reason, and it really feels a league above the comparably priced products.
I like Linux Mint for basic use cases, but for anyone with more robust needs I'd recommend an alternative. Linux Mint still only uses X11, which means that a lot of reasonably common modern features such as HDR are unsupported.
I’d recommend CachyOS - it’s far more up to date, especially with nvidia drivers and the kernel, and with the default limine bootloader you can easily load a snapshot in case an update breaks something
+1 for Cachy. Arch, even though its reputation opposes this, is very friendly for newcomers because it bypasses the normal version-mismatch issues that tend to creep into the normal distros. You get the latest good version of everything instead of the best version three months ago and hope everything else was compiled against that.
Except that the Arch installation process is notoriously difficult/manual, even more so if you want a complete modern setup with disk encryption, secure boot, etc. The installer is supposed to help, but always crashed last time I tried to use it.
Of the big three base distros, Fedora is probably the best for gaming. It's straightforward to install relative to Arch, and the software packages are reasonably recent. Debian could also be viable on older hardware.
I can't speak to vanilla Arch, since I haven't tried their current installer, but CachyOS's installer is extremely simple to use, and does handle setting up full disk encryption. I suspect its ease of installation is part of why it has gotten popular among gamers switching from Windows.
CachyOS's installer does not, however, handle setting up secure boot, nor am I clear on what your "etc." covers, but you do end up with a fully featured desktop OS at the end
ive been meaning to swap my main desktop (still windows) to steamos. are i dont game too much. at least AAA but i like to make stuff that needs gfx. is there an argument against steamos which i think is a fedora fork?
SteamOS is based on Arch, not Fedora. I think it's Bazzite that it's based on Fedora. SteamOS isn't designed to run on hardware other that Valve's IIRC, Bazzite is basically the generic hardware version of it.
I'm running Cachy on my Laptop, debian on desktop, ubuntu for work. I just hate pacman's interface so much. The parameters are not intuitive and they refuse to stick in my head. Maybe I should look for a wrapper or have an LLM write one that makes it behave like apt.
I've been having a seamless dual-boot experience with Windows 11 and Linux Mint Debian Edition, LMDE7.
As a preface to those Mint instructions, in Windows Disk Management I shrink the main Windows partition by about 20GB to 50GB, this creates some new "unallocated space" immediately following the normal Windows C: volume.
Then create a "New Simple Volume" in that unallocated space, but do not assign a drive letter and do not format. This will be the sole Linux partition, no /swap, no /usr, none of that monkey business when you are not replacing Windows, merely adding Linux as an option to a "virtually unchanged" Windows PC. You want Linux to occupy a single partition just like Windows does. At the Command prompt in Windows Diskpart, next select the target HDD or SSD, then select the target Linux partition on that drive, and "SET ID=4F68BCE3-E8CD-4DB1-96E7-FBCAF984B709 which is the designator for Linux Root. Also in Diskpart you can select the EFI volume and assign an alphabetical letter to the EFI volume so you can see the hidden folders and back up the Windows-specific \EFI\Boot\bootx64.efi file contained within. Manipulating the "hidden" EFI files can only be done at the Command prompt (not the GUI) after assigning a drive letter like this, and after you reboot, that drive letter will be removed automatically and no more access to EFI unless you reassign a drive letter again in CMD.
Then boot to the LMDE7 USB drive so you can install Linux to the unformatted partition.
In the Mint install wizard you will have to choose the "Manual" partitioning & formatting option, which opens up infinite possibilities, but this simple dual-boot arrangement only takes a couple distinct settings. In the displayed list of partitions, select that unformatted volume as "root", indicated by the single slash "/", and choose to format it using ext2, ext3, or ext4. Then in the small fat32 boot partition (where the Windows boot files are already residing in the "hidden" \EFI\Microsoft\ folder), Do Not format this partition, but select it as the ideal location for the Linux boot files, and designate it as "/EFI/Boot".
That's it.
After completion, Linux will be completely independent from Windows. In the EFI boot volume there will be a new \EFI\debian\ folder alongside the \EFI\Microsoft\ folder. The only change to any Microsoft files (and it's a "big" one) is within the \EFI\Boot\ folder which is a common folder to all the OS's on that SSD. When first powered up, \EFI\Boot\ is the folder that the UEFI firmware searches for so it can execute \EFI\Boot\bootx64.efi which then boots the PC. On a plain Windows PC the bootx64.efi file is from Microsoft and points to \EFI\Microsoft\ then Windows boots normally. The Linux install process replaces bootx64.efi with a different bootx64.efi which points to \EFI\debian\ instead. This is also a good time to use Windows to back up the Debian-specific bootx64.efi file.
Fortunately, the Mint install process runs a Grub routine including os-prober, which as the name implies, probes for other OS's besides the Linux you are presently installing at the time. And auto-adds any OS's found, to the new Linux multi-boot menu. So it reliably picks up a regular Windows installation and adds an entry for that Windows to the Linux bootmenu. Basically that Windows bootentry points to the same old \EFI\Microsoft\ folder which is unchanged and then boots Windows normally when selected.
Unfortunately, os-prober has been commented out of the Grub files and the probe only functions upon OS installation. So when Grub itself is re-installed or updated at a later time, intentionally or not, os-prober no longer runs by default and Windows will be auto-removed from the Linux bootmenu and you wonder where it went. Windows is still there intact regardless and can be recovered by replacing the Linux bootx64.efi with the original Windows bootx64.efi that you backed up earlier. But that would give you no more menu access to Linux.
To avoid this deficiency in the default Grub files, in Linux you need to edit the \etc\default\grub file to uncomment (remove the # hashmark from) the GRUB_DISABLE_OS_PROBER=false line. This basically requires using sudo at the Linux command line since otherwise the file is read-only.
Serious question I have anytime people get upset about telemetry like this with Windows: why isn't there a similar level of outrage against Android, iOS, ChromeOS, Googlebook OS, and Mac?
The real outlier in all of this are Linux distros. Every other commercial OS is tracking a lot, but it seems like Windows is the only commercial OS people expect to not track you? There is no way Apple and Google don't know which apps people are using on their OSes too.
Google is the worst offender of this by far. They'll correlate data across every Google thing you do (every email, browser history, app usage, audio recordings, car driving habits, etc) and very effectively sell/manipulate you with ads based on that. Microsoft only wishes they were half as good at milking and monetizing tracking like Google.
Because Windows was not always like this. It has gotten much more telemetry "features" over the years, on top of generally user hostile changes, which upsets people.
The other OSes have always given the user less freedom, except for Android, which people are similarly outraging about, and dealing with that problem through custom roms.
I needed to clear my 100gb gmail to stop paying $4.99/mo, I knew they wouldn't let me, but figured if Gemini is going to ask me every day to connect to my gmail, I'll see if it can categorize and clean up my 21GB left over of email.
Nope. Can't function against bulk mail. Can only function on small searches, etc. No "Gemini, clean up my spam." lol.
Why is this 'news', or rather, voted up so highly? Everyone knows Microsoft collects an insane amount of telemetry. ETW isn't even that big of a deal. This ability is more for system administrators and enterprises to track tooling and diagnostic usage. It's interesting to see this telemetry is sent to Microsoft but in light of their Surface RTX and the Windows 11 developer mode, this should be expected so they can track if there's issues with the hardware, OS, or tools when reporting crashes and other things.
Because it’s easy to say “collects insane amounts of telemetry”. What’s actually interesting is what’s being collected: are they collecting the IDEs and coding agents you use? login and shutdown times? browser history? periodic screenshots? key strokes and mouse positions?
It is absolutely a big deal. The fact that they're still evil and doing evil things should be called out. They should be publically shamed until they stop doing evil things.
Anti-cheat has no business being in any kernel. It's the most sensitive part of your system, and if it gets pwned, every last part of your system down to the firmware is compromised and irrevocably trained. If Crowdstrike can't be trusted to make security software safe for the kernel, it's entirely insane to think that a video game company can do better. If a game refuses to run without kernel anti-cheat, you don't need it.
This is for high level competitive gamers, a small fraction of total gamers.
This is high profile because there is a lot of money involved, but even casual gamers don't want their fun to be ruined by cheaters. And they are definitely not going to travel and be provided equipment by the bronze league.
I don't know if it is still the case but "I play on console because I don't want to play with PC gamers, too many cheaters" was something I heard a few times, and not from competitive gamers.
I see this "development" as something extremely negative. The point of Linux is that is does not belong or is verified by some "authority." Anyone should be able to build their own kernel with whatever tweaks they want, for whatever reason.
This is less about what you do on your own machine, and more about whether you are allowed to access the Epic servers running multiplayer games.
I think if Epic effectively updates their policy from 'you may play Fortnite if you can attest you are running Windows or MacOS' to 'you may play Fortnite if you can attest you are running Windows, MacOS, standard Fedora, or standard Ubuntu' that's still a win, even if they will never be able to move to 'you may play Fortnite no matter what OS you are running'.
I see this point, and I'm of two minds on this. The best counterpoint I have is that if these anti-cheats come to Linux, and some Linuxes will be more popular as a result, that means a lot of compatibility and backports to the rest of the Linuxes as well, which is helpful to keep all of them relevant is desktop space.
Since Linux is not a singular platform like Windows or Macos, there is not way that this is damaging to Linux as a whole.
Not sure it is a good thing indeed. As long as attested systems don't have momentum, application developers (and their funders) that target Linux have an incentive not to use it. When the userbase mostly has an attestable configuration, a developer using it will only annoy (and exclude) those who explicitly don't want it... and are today running Linux, among others, for that very reason.
amen. as justifying not using Linux because some proprietary shit game with anti-cheat from companies like EA or Tencent shouldn't ever be a consideration to migrate
The idea of owing rent to the game lord just doesn't sit right with me, not to mention the latency. I would rather just play old games on moderated community servers.
If the server is located reasonably close to you (same country/state), you can expect a round trip latency of ~10ms, which is less than the latency of a top of the line competitive PC, and well under the limit of human perception for audio and visual feedback. So, viable in this universe.
In practice, there are a lot more variables, but under 40ms is achievable today with a good PC, a good connection, and a reasonably close server. That's good enough for all but the fastest games with competitive gameplay, and cloud gaming is generally considered a better experience than a low-end PC.
At least for AutoDesk products virtualisation might be viable with QEMU, that way you can dump Windows mostly but still keep it isolated in a VM until Wine catches up.
I thought Autodesk used to have a "hardware key" option for verifying licensing - you plug usb key of sorts (was looooong time ago) and license check goes against that hd token thing-y? Or was it some other CAD product, but the idea is the same.
Temper that excitement with the realization that even with AI agents doing all the heavy lifting, the *craft dev has spread too thinly to make much meaningful progress past what's been done so far. There comes a point where you have to move from the one-shot to giving specific, ongoing guidance to the agent. Also, with no corporate sponsors and using Claude for all this means that it's financially untenable to keep going like this.
Windows has been very slow to make a sandbox for AI agents - they launched MXC just a month ago (Oct 7) and Claude Code doesn't even support it yet. So we have people running un-sandboxed agents on Windows, or they use WSL instead. All of this to say, yes I hope they have some non-invasive telemetry to know what to prioritize, because the platform needs features like this pretty urgently.
Hopefully they won't forget about including an "off switch", because sandboxing is defeating the whole point of running agents on your machine in the first place.
When I get a new laptop/desktop I used to do dualboot with Linux where I still keep the original Windows around. Not anymore, I fully clean install just Linux.
I don't really need Windows for anything anymore and if something would come up, you can always run windows in a VM on Linux.
I still have a device with MacOs, but even with that one I'm switching to Omarchy as soon as they have good support (it's almost there).
Are there any charitable explanation for this? Attributing Windows breakage to an agent released with destructive behavior or poor guardrails for instance...
Analitics / metrics gathering, to answer questions like "how much are these tools used by our users". I'm confident they have similar categorizations for other types of applications - creative, gaming, browsers, etc.
What is a bit odd is that this distinction is made client-side, if it was just metrics they'd send the process + info to their data lake and sort it there.
Windows sending so much identifiable data would surely have raised further concerns once inevitably identified by security and privacy researchers. There’s no telling how securely this data is handled on the backend.
I wonder what sort of stuff Linux logs by default? How much stuff actually ever needs to be in say syslog? How much does it leak? And then every other log... Even things like bash history. Surely that is violation of privacy by default...
Syslog and bash history are defaults, and I cannot remember any instance when they were accessed and uploaded by any software.
Logging itself is not a violation of privacy when it doesn't leave your device. Of course it's a matter of expectations, for example logging keystrokes would be a weird thing, even if it didn't leave the device.
And of course the security of these logs is similar to other PCs, meaning, all of a user's software can interact with any other user-accessible resource silently. Aside from special cases like Qubes OS or custom AppArmor configs etc, software can just do whatever the system's user can do.
If we're looking at it from a forensic perspective, there is a lot to check, once you have access to the user folder. For example there's the cached thumbnails of most images that were once on the computer.
>Surely that is violation of privacy by default...
It is as much of a privacy violation as having a lot of private information in your own home...if you want to avoid something like that use linux distro build for that purpose like Tails, Whonix or Qubes.
You are in complete control of how much stuff it logs. There are distros that will run without any writable storage at all, some designed specifically to leave no trace.
add it to the list of millions of reasons ill never update from windows 10 LTSC. ive never ran into anything not working either. aside from msstore stuff, which is completely removed
I think some multiplayer games will refuse to run on it because the Windows 10 LTSC kernel is more likely to have some known vulnerabilities allowing code execution in the kernel.
now i run win11+wsl. all dev is wsl+emacs which drives native windows as needed for game builds. it's fine.
i operate a pvp online game, with both linux and windows clients: better.game/download.
i tried to drop the linux client to focus on windows, but there's always a few users who want linux, and tbh it's fine. server and original gui client are both linux, so it's easy.
i'd be surprised and impressed if microsoft understands what coding agent i'm using (i brought it from home). power to them if they do.
> what programs are running on an operating system actually makes sense for the kind of telemetry that should be collected
No.
Nobody, except I can decide what gets collected.
It's nothing. Nothing can be collected from my computer....unless they want to pay me back for the pro licenses I have that [should] make the system mine. And even then - no.
That's just the information we know Windows 11 collects. How much private information does Microsoft have access to because it's on a Windows system that can phone home?
Home users have zero reasons to use Windows in 2026.
Skip problematic distro Linux like Ubuntu which has become evil and semi-proprietary.
There are distros like Mint Cinnamon that are awesome. Based on Ubuntu but without all the mess from it with solid support and community. It has newer packages like Ubuntu but the security practices like Debian.
From internet to video editing, from writing docs to playing Steam games, it just works.
Office?? LibreOffice. You shouldn't be using Microsoft Office even on Windows.
LibreOffice is solid, 100% offline, free, and received massive donations during Microsoft drama on Friday.
The only downside is for folks who play Steam games with kernel anti-cheat, that is spyware anyway and you should not be playing such games to start with.
You can isolate Steam by installing its Flatpak version, even if you installed a game found to be compromised, Flatpak sandbox isolates it. Avoid installing the native DEB package which grants full access to the system files, if you get a game compromised that way, then yeah, you are screwed.
Windows is not different, if you have Steam running on your Windows PC and installed a compromised game, good luck haha
> Skip problematic distro Linux like Ubuntu which has become evil and semi-proprietary.
Someone who is just now switching from Microsoft because of their crappy UX probably isn’t choosing their operating system based on an ethical framework. They want a low-hassle OS, that’s all.
Maybe it really is time for a real, commercial-grade, competitor to Windows in the consumer-PC space, one that isn't Linux - think: Amiga, BeOS, NEXTSTEP, etc.
Much of what you say, like the fact that there are different distros and something called packages, makes an average person zone out and lose all interest. It sounds like you still have to think about the OS, whereas with Windows you do not
I'm primarily a linux user but I support my family's windows desktops and sooo many things on windows is problematic and difficult. You are just so used to its quirks and think of them as "normal".
My friend who is a windows power-user pointed me to these windows powershell cleaning scripts which runs all kinds of random clean-up commands that seem to change and need fixes all the time.
I will take my linux package manager any day of the week thank you.
How to install software on Windows: open some random shady website, find the correct download link among 20 fake ones that point to malware, open the installation wizard, make sure to uncheck all boxes for installing browser toolbars, click Next several times (being on the guard for more malware).
How to install software on Linux: open the software store, find the thing you want to install, click the install button, maybe enter your password.
Obviously the former is easier for the average user and doesn’t require thinking about the OS.
It's not about me. I can use Linux just fine. I'm referring to the promotion of Linux and how technical people see it vs how the normies do. It's a matter of perception that needs to be addressed.
> I recently asked AI to help me look through the latest Windows binaries for undocumented features and functionality.
Can you trust AI here though?
It seems to me as if people rely increasingly more on AI being honest to them.
How can they assume this is the case? Isn't AI more like a black box tool? You
depend on whatever code is used by the company upstream.
Because in many cases the answer the tool gives can be verified. For example, I often ask "What's the syntax in software ABC to do XYZ?" Then when the LLM spits out the syntax, I read the manpage (or online docs) for ABC, and double check that yes, the `--xyz` option was the right one. The LLM's answer is usually faster than scrolling through the manpage myself, reading 50 irrelevant options before I get to `--xyz`.
I've had one case where the LLM told me "You can do XYZ like this: (example)" and the online docs said "You can't do XYZ yet, we haven't added that feature, but when we do add it then this is how to do it: (example)". So I still double-check. But it's right 90+% of the time, and it saves me time since the LLM (running on massively parallel clusters of GPUs) can synthesize and associate words much faster than I can.
So that's why people are trusting the LLMs. Because they're usually right. You should never trust them 100%, though: always verify, whenever it's possible to verify, what they tell you.
This kind of invasiveness is why some companies have switched to professionally supported Linux based distros and run Microsoft Office desktop apps in VMs (in a way wholly transparent to the users) on those systems.
Windows 11 discloses this, and provides toggles for Required & Optional Diagnostic data. It also includes an app for you to browse the event entries .
The disclosure on Optional Diagnostic Data is shown with the UI control and is clear that website & app activity will be tracked, and that it can be turned off to no ill effect on the system functionality or security.
The article claims the data is always recorded, and if and only if your diagnostic sharing is off, it won’t upload it. That does not feel like a truthful interpretation of the data privacy toggle by Microsoft. Also, once you “decide” to re-enable sharing (aka. accidentally enable after an update) is there a high likelihood it will upload all of this previously collected data?
Helpful context (maybe). it still seems like a petty concern. a mountain out of a molehill. MS is very clear that it is tracking your EXEs, and the article is making a stink that they are recording "claude.exe" is running. NBD
No it's not because I haven't used Microsoft software since approx 2008. I was done after XP. I never looked back, one of the best changes I ever made.
It isn't a joke any more. Could be a half joke on earlier versions, but find a Windows 10 machine and try and disable defender for example. Oh sure you can disable in all the settings, it is still running in the background using significant resources if you check task or resource manager. Do group policy and registry edits, both from within and outside Microsoft's directions to disable it, still running. Powershell commands? Still running. Even as a power user that has used Windows since 3.1, it was difficult to actually accomplish and required resorting to random github scripts and programs run multiple times before it stopped. And im willing to bet that is only temporary. Next time I notice a big system stutter I can almost guarantee when I check task manger it will be one of the half dozen "defender" programs that decided to magically reenable itself.
it's been true since they added this sort of enhanced telemetry back in windows 10's early days. Such a shame that OSes have been monotonically getting worse since the high point in 2009
"A program that is inserted into a system, usually covertly, with the intent of compromising the confidentiality, integrity, or availability of the victim’s data, applications, or operating system or of otherwise annoying or disrupting the victim."
I guess we do need to keep seeing things like this on the front page just in case there is anyone who is not aware of Microsoft's stellar reputation for putting user security and experience first, but then again it does get old that about all you can say is Microslop gonna Microslop.
I just had to spend another 30 minutes removing "defender" because it was sucking up such resources and causing stuttering in various applications at random times. I did the exact same thing a few days ago going through group policies, registry settings, etc. Did it again today, still didn't work. Tried to do it through powershell which failed. Eventually resorted to random github scripts, which half failed, but once I used enough versions of them I finally got a boot today that it didn't load upon. Also tried to disable a bunch of other stuff through O&O Shutup, many of which still didn't work or reverted because Windows is such a clusterfark.
Like I almost wish I had a virus to break it, maybe that is what finally broke it after all these random scripts. But atleast I got my system CPU usage down below 5% while idling and doing nothing, and I haven't yet noticed any random 50% CPU usage spikes again, but you know I did all this a year or so ago too so it is perhaps just a matter of time.
I recently installed a lightweight windows by SanLex and it's a perfect freaking windows. There is zero bloat inside, zero telemetry, no onedrive, no copilot, no xbox apps, no microsoft store, no windows defender, no windows hello, no ads, a pristine, clean system. Not a pixel on the interface moves around on startup. Two icons in the dock. SanLex must be a Microsoft CEO really.
It's interesting how Silicon Valley/Redmond companies can "extract" data from their users but not use any of the data collected to actually improve or help their users with tasks in their systems...
As an example, pointed an LLM at my file/folder drive and it cleaned and organized every single file into folders, deleting all duplicates perfectly in the background without one issue, and also advised of 40 GB of old Docker tests which were not needed.
If you trust LLM to clean up disk without your input, you could just format whole drive and save some tokens. Because whatever data it holds can't be important, otherwise you wouldn't ever trust it to system that can go off the rails at any point.
Windows deserves criticism where it's due, but this sounds like nothing. If one of those programs crashes they could just end up in an error report upload dump anyway. If you didn't trust Microsoft, I don't see why this diagnostic changes anything. You can turn it off if you want to, though. You'd be surprised what some of the anti-cheat software sends that some games use, and you can't turn those off or the game won't run.
In the age we're entering, I'm not convinced that escaping to MacOS or to nix or any other system is any sort of guaranteed win. I saw MacOS doing similar analytics things to Windows, but trust is, it's private! MacOS also barely feels maintained. nix is a crapshoot and any distro you're thinking of using to get a workable desktop that lets users feel at home is already failed by that very goal. What's worse is that the nix ecosystem is rife with insane package managers that makes them even more ripe for getting plucked by AI in the upcoming years. It will also be even easier for AI to social engineer and get people on nix to install persistent bot networks and malware even if it only runs as a regular user to expand the computation footprint it has access to.
I'm not a fan of the always online cloud infrastructure integration that Windows has, but being realistic, if you want to use your computers the way you have been for the past couple decades then Microsoft's approach is the only realistic one in my opinion even though they have a long way to go still. I say that sadly. If you want true security and true privacy, you have to compute in a different way with greater limitations and I see almost nobody willing to do that. It's like the doctor and patient dilemma. Doctor tells you to stop doing this thing that's killing you, patient comes back in 3 years closer to death, because they don't change.
Given the situation Microsoft faces, it's impractical to automatically configure every home computer with some air gapped NSA secure configuration, because there would be far more outrage than any privacy advocates have ever put up. It's only gotten worse, because so much software only works with the internet and the internet has gotten so important that a lot of software is only useful with access to the internet.
Then you've got this battle between dying hard drives losing data, fires, floods, hurricanes and other natural disasters destroying your data versus backing it all up online, but opening yourself up to security risks that way. People like to think they have multiple backups, but then some storm takes out both of your backup locations, because they weren't distributed enough. If World War 3 happens, the data centers may become a huge target and even as distributed as they are, they can only take so much. Nature is eating at you from every direction.
If you think an operating system is a flaming piece of shit (because it is), you really should stop using it. Windows isn't as pervasive as capitalism, it's just a shitty piece of software/software ecosystem one can stop using on their personal machines.
They can stop using it unless they can’t. There are still a few situations and a few pieces of hardware or software that don’t really have other options that don’t cost considerable amounts of money.
For anyone on the fence about switching from Windows to Linux: it takes about a week, if that, of adjusting. If most of what you do is on the Web already (and the services you use provide a Web-based client), you have nothing to lose but your chains.
Take your pick - Ubuntu, Fedora, someone else mentioned Mint. All fine choices, no wrong answers.
As someone who owns and operaters Linux, Windows, and Mac systems at home, this just isn't true for a lot of people.
I have to keep my gaming PC as Windows because I can't play Madden, EA FC, or PUBG on my Linux machines nor my Steam Deck (unless I install windows). They all require kernel level anti-cheats that are only supported on Windows.
You also can't play a ton of other very popular games (that I don't happen to play, but millions do) like Call of Duty, Fortnite, League of Legends, Battlefield, etc. Those games have millions of players.
And this is just for gaming. There are plenty of other bits of software that don't run on Linux, even with all of the amazing work that has gone into compatibility tools like WINE.
I am not saying that many people shouldn't explore moving to Linux from Windows, but I don't think it is helpful to say everyone can switch without at least mentioning any of the reasons people can't.
You can still recommend that people switch, if people have their own specific reasons why they can't, they won't. It's not like anyone mandates that people switch.
For gaming, most games don't have issues. For the games that do, if enough people actually do switch, it gives more incentives for their publishers to make their games work on Linux without issues. We are also no longer starved for potential alternative games that are very similar and do work on Linux.
Most other software has very good alternatives by now.
So overall I do think it is reasonable to recommend people make the switch rather than stay a hostage of a system they don't like because some software providers refuse to offer an alternative on Linux. If you have specific reasons not to switch, don't switch.
When you advice people to switch, you should be transparent about the limitations.
What is the point of the advice if it doesn't give you any useful information?
There's a wide, wide, wide gap between "doesn't give any useful information" and "explicitly list all software and hardware that doesn't support Linux, like a medicine informational sheet".
Saying 'you should switch to Linux because it respects your privacy and doesn't frustrate you with ads' is perfectly reasonable advice. The details come later and are based on what that person needs (why even mention gaming DRM if the user isn't a gamer, for example?).
I feel this is the biggest problem with the Linux community.
-Linux is fully customizable!, they'll say.
Well, so it your house. You could move the kitchen and the bathroom, but it's not done over night, and you need the skills to do so.
That beeing said, I've made the switch about at year ago. I do miss some software, I havent gotten to play Battlefield 6 because of it, but i really don't miss Windows at all.
Not to mention, it's a pretty big commitment if you only have 1 or 2 drives and are replacing a Windows installation rather than dual-booting.
It's annoying to be told something "just works" when it doesn't, and lose what you already were using just fine.
Reverting back to Windows in this situation means a full reinstall and setting everything up again, which for some people is enough friction to deter them.
I'm sure that there are a number of games that don't work under Linux, but I've finally installed Arch on my gaming computer (I've been running Linux on laptops since the 90s) and in 6 months, I've encountered a total of 1 game that doesn't WFM so far.
I'd call this highly encouraging.
Also... I'm not sure I'd want any kind of kernel-level anti-cheat on my computer.
> I'm not sure I'd want any kind of kernel-level anti-cheat on my computer.
I think more people should say this part more loudly. Most games that don't work on Linux don't work because they can't install their ~spyware~ anti cheat on your computer.
If that was the lead, instead of "but X game doesn't work on Linux" the response might be "no, Y root kits don't work on Linux" there might be more incentive for folks to stop playing those games.
My experience on Linux is the same. The only thing that hasn’t worked (and better, at that) is stuff with kernel anticheat which I want off my machine as fast as possible anyways
You might be overestimating proportion of Windows users who play these games or rely on Adobe or similar. Most people just use the browser.
I agree, but then pose this: If they just use the browser, why does OS choice matter?
It doesn't, but tell that to my mom who bought a $1000 MacBook because her HP stopped working, then booted it up and decided instead to buy another HP (refurbished) because she didn't understand Mac.
I spent some time going through it with her but she just used to Windows
I switched my wife to Mint a couple of years ago and she had never had a single problem with it, because 99% of her computer usage is in the browser
Those kinds of users are dark matter, they've never heard of Linux (or if they did, for them it falls into the same category as pacemakers) and will never install it on their own.
Techies routinely overestimate how much the average users cares about tech internals.
https://xkcd.com/2501/
> You also can't play a ton of other very popular games (that I don't happen to play, but millions do) like Call of Duty, Fortnite, League of Legends, Battlefield
if these people don't start switching, there will be no incentives for developers to port games to Linux.
For every "popular" game that isn't supported there are 10000s of ones which are. Gamers are spoilt for choice. This isn't the hill you want to die on.
I have two win11 machines (desktop and laptop), an m5 mbp and a steam machine (soon a steam frame as well) - plus dual booting. Other than kernel-level anti cheats, built-in codecs and friction around game mods (which agents can nowadays _really_ take care of), non-win gaming is just fine, including on ARM (although I'd love it if non-AppleSilicon consumer archs would implement TSO mode and other good stuff - for everything else, x87sidecar et al).
I just hate how much they (MS) enshittified an otherwise perfectly good OS.
The fact that Linux-compatible software doesn't ask you to install kernel-level malware is a feature, not a shortcoming.
> but I don't think it is helpful to say everyone can switch without at least mentioning any of the reasons people can't.
Which is funny because you don't mention that Epic is working on a native Linux anticheat solution for Fortnite. There are tradeoff everywhere, but most of those tradeoff also apply to Windows. Do you want to deal with an OS that at every importune moment or would prefer to sacrifice a small part of what you do on your computer just to not have to deal with that?
I just don't ever play anything that isn't supported by my one and only operating system. It's not that hard to not do something
Does anyone know if anti-cheat on Linux is held back by any technical or licensing (meaning GPL) issues, or are game companies just not interested in even looking into it? I'd think that the Steam Deck would be making Linux popular enough to be worth porting them, but then again, Valve doesn't publish numbers on how many Steam Decks have sold, so maybe it's not that popular.
Technical issues is my understanding. There are Linux versions of many anti-cheat softwares, but they are a lot let effective than the Windows versions, so a lot of games turn Linux support off. But Epic Games recently started working on a new version of EasyAntiCheat for Linux that will supposedly be a lot more effective: https://onlineservices.epicgames.com/news/introducing-easy-a...
It'll mean you can't run a small, independent distro or even build your own kernel. When you choose to meet a publisher's demand for running kernel-level anti-cheat (yes, eBPF programs count), that system is no longer your PC; it's a console, albeit a Linux-based one.
Maybe it's something I'll do, but I'll probably have to dual-boot to do it on the machines I use the most, which means I might as well just devote a particular machine to consolehood. :-\
It still beats the hell out of running Windows, but I have mixed feelings about invasive/demanding software like this.
Anti-cheat has even less business being in the kernel than security software, and Crowdstrike proved that security companies can't be trusted to write safe kernel code. Any game that requires poking holes in the most sensitive part of your system is a game you can and should live without.
Yes. It's like participating in pro body building. Sure you get to be BIG, but you will have to shrink your balls and die at 35
Do those have more or less business being in your kernel than thousands of other random developers who, on average, have orders of magnitude less security experience than anticheat and antivirus developers?
Here's a buffet of vulnerable, signed drivers: https://www.loldrivers.io/drivers/e32bc3da-4db1-4858-a62c-6f...
It's easier to mod the Linux kernel in a way that would fool kernel-level anticheats, since the Linux kernel is both open-source and an extremely well-understood API surface.
With Windows anticheat the anticheat driver is using a well-defined API the kernel exposes to block other kernel drivers being loaded, but with Linux you can change the code implementing those types of APIs by compiling a custom kernel and editing the source code. With Windows such a custom kernel would be a significant reverse engineering effort.
> but with Linux you can change the code implementing those types of APIs by compiling a custom kernel and editing the source code.
If you allow customized kernels to be used then you've already lost. That would give you a similar level of access as running under a hypervisor which has been exploited and banned a long time ago.
Isn't the main issue for the lack of support on Linux the absence of centralized authority that would verify that each kernel/module is locked down enough to prevent "unauthorized" access to your own kernel, and certify/sign the entire boot chain - approved bootloaders, kernels, kernel modules that would allow anticheat to properly attest the boot state?
But that's a near impossible task that's at odds with the philosophy with the entire ecosystem. Support would probably have to be narrowed down to 1 boot loader that supports 1 heavily modified kernel with a short list of most commonly used kernel modules.
In principle, since a Linux system already allows you to choose a kernel to boot from in GRUB or similar, the games manufacturers could provide a signed DRM-enabled kernel and use the TPM/attestation path so the game would only run on their kernel.
Back in the day, for some games you'd put the game's 3.5" diskette in your A: drive and boot from that instead of into your normal OS. A side-effect of that was "kernel level" DRM.
Seeing how games are being decompiled left and right, I wonder how long it will keep being a significant reverse engineering effort to tackle Windows...
https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/
Go read about 10 random articles there, preferably from different years, and you will realize that Windows has a formal and informal API surface that's probably close to the size of our entire solar system.
There's a reason Wine is doing only mostly ok after 30+ years of continuous development and several commercial funding rounds.
AFAIK, Hunt: Showdown successfully uses some anticheat on Linux. But performance on Nvidia Linux is as bad as with f.ex. Cyberpunk, so I play it on A Windows instead.
On linux you(the end user) get the full source and ability to load or compile whatever kernel or kernel modules you want. So this avenue provides little utility to the anti-cheat vendors, the only reason they can pretend it works on windows, is that theoretically microsoft provides a known unchangeable kernel, and kernel modules are enumerated and signed, that is, impossible to hide and hard to install. Yeah, stop laughing, but that is what they hope to get out of it.
It's coming, I can't recall off-hand who was working on it, independent group or Proton adjacent development.
You could just not play those games. So many other things to do in this short life. You could be perfectly happy without those wastes of time.
Time you enjoy wasting is not necessarily wasted time.
Well, no one can tell the users what to do.
However, the lack of games in the early pre-2.6 days has been a boon to my career.
It's so easy to game on Linux, that next time I'll be setting up a new system I'm going to have separate users for gaming and for work/studying. It's just too easy to lose time playing Factorio, KSP, Total War, or any of the myriad indie games that somehow always work on Linux.
Like Songs of Syx, that didn't want to launch. But the demo worked. So I've set a local LLM to fix it. It just reverse engineered java code and created a fix. I followed it's work until I got overloaded with explanations how some graphic buffers were not correctly passed to the game launcher.
At the same time I joined devs' discord and reported how some rare Linux NVIDIA driver's issue could be fixed by adding an option to modify global vars that game is starting with. Next dev branch version had an editable file with global vars.
It's not that I don't like AAA games (tho I definitely stopped paying and quit League of Legends after they banned Linux to reduce amount of botters by some 5-10%). But it's a completely different experience of playing games where you can participate in the process of creation. And surprisingly, even though the Linux market is fragmented and requires lot of work to support small numbers of players (deb vs rpm vs arch, X11 vs Way, Nvidia vs AMD), when it comes to non-AAA games it's often that Linux players are not only accepted, but welcome.
Another reason to have separate users is to not give full system access to LLMs in a place where I have my personal stuff.
> set a local LLM to fix it
I tried that, but failed. Ollama wouldn't compile.
Could you please give some pointers how you got that LLM to work?
You could just not enjoy your life. A yes audio tools also don't work on Linux.
Seriously what a crazy comment
Vibes of "Pick another protein?! I'd rather pick another operating system..."
You could not use a computer at all! /s
It took me several months of extremely sporadic effort, but it did finally happen. The first big effort was just proving to myself that I could move my entire business over to Linux. The final thing was the archaic spreadsheet that I used for generating serial numbers from a Dymo label printer. That's now a Python script, and the labels print just fine.
And then I still discover pesky little things once in a while, but it seems like there's always a Linux solution. My main hobby, playing music, makes minimal use of a computer, just for moving files around and watching YouTube videos. My other hobbies, electronics and programming, already lend themselves to Linux better than Windows anyway.
I thought my son would be impressed, but he had already switched to Mac.
Can also recommend mint + cinnamon. You type task manager and it points you to the system monitor. You type cmd and it points you to the terminal. It is the little things that helps you adapt to get off your Windows muscle memory. Some things will work worse than on windows, some things work better. But you will be amazed how good a clean operating system can be without the immense shit Windows comes with these days.
Mint uses the Ubuntu package ecosystem and it does play all games I tried (there are some multiplayer games with anti-cheat "solutions" that won't work yet, you would need dual boot here).
If you want to play games, I recommend Steam + Lutris + Heroic (I use the latter for GOG + the single Epic game I have, works perfectly).
As someone who daily drives all 3 major operating systems... I could never recommend Linux to someone without big caveats.
I wish I could. I wish it could do everything well. But it just doesn't.
If all you do is web, then use your phone or a tablet. Windows isn't the right choice for that either.
> If all you do is web, then use your phone or a tablet.
Moving from windows device to a phone/table because it collects names of coding agents would be a perfect example of out of the frying pan to the fire, given the choice of OS we have for those.
If those caveats are not a big deal(depends on the person) compared to the privacy issues, linux is still a better option.
But what exactly can you _not_ do on linux that you would do easily on windows, when the user is a non-tech person?
For my Luddite Mum, ask the neighbour/friends or help with turning on her wifi/printing when she somehow presses the wrong thing.
I had her on Ubuntu for more than a decade. Unfortunately it became increasingly difficult so I've given up for now and she's back on windows.
May be I'm underestimating the problem but it should atleast be easier to solve if its just this?
Create a set of golden configs for WiFi/printer etc.
Add a cron job that resets the config to golden periodically or just create a noticeable icon on the desktop to reset those configs as required.
It worked pretty well for a long time and I was able to skip a few versions of windows which was nice.
Some more automation would probably have helped. I still needed to remotely fix problematic/broken updates etc. The automations should have worked but didn't for various reasons over the years.
Her broadband internet was flaky for long time which made it tricky. At some stage I put a pi zero in so I could check the connection without having to tell her where to click on the screen over the phone etc.
Living a continent or two away makes it tricky. Even the pi effectively needed an in-person upgrade to get it to Bookworm.
She will get better results asking a LLM vs her neighbors.
How does that work if she's turned the wifi off? :-)
https://ollama.com/ . I’m only half joking.
For non-gamers, the browser is the computer these days.
I prefer HTML5 games vibe coded with LLMs.
Err, no.
It's not perfect, but having AI to help debug makes things a LOT easier.
I switched my gaming machine to Bazzite a year ago or so, and it has literally worked just perfect since then. I think I've had one game crash, but that might have happened on Windows as well.
In retrospect, I should probably have gone Fedora or Ubuntu instead of Bazzite, as the immutable image setup is probably great for gaming but mostly gets in the way of other tasks, but I've been too lazy to reinstall it, and as I said, it works pretty well.
I just do my other tasks in a Ubuntu distrobox, with a separate $HOME.
If it ever gets messed up with weird dependency issues, messy dotfiles etc. i just wipe it and make a new one. I think I'm on my 4th or 5th distrobox by now, meanwhile the underlying system has been migrating smoothly since Fedora Atomic 39.
My issue is all still hardware. The VR headset is not supported and neither is my Audio out DAC/Amp. The issue is the companies that made them not Linux but it is still a real problem I have that looses functionality I use frequently. I also have the issue both screens are high refresh but different capabilities (one is 280hz and HDR capable the other is 165 and isn't HDR) and this just doesn't seem to work in cachyOS KDE well at all. I dual boot linux but I can't switch over permanently.
I switched to linux on my desktop PC, and was amazed how smooth the transition was for gaming (work always worked) after having run a server linux for 30 years, and trying desktop linux every decade or so before turning back.
Unfortunately I can't switch on my snapdragon x laptop without qualcomm being better at linux support, so I'm stuck with WSL there, which I assume Windows collects data from.
With ai is much easier, but ai tends to give wrong advice. It assume the wrong distro, wrong terminal, wrong tools installed, advices to install unnecessary duplicated tools, mixes distros, overkill advice that causes wide harm to solve minor problems. You need a careful prompt , describing your system and instructing to diagnose before advising solutions, and even then you have to ask what it does every instruction
You're not wrong that you need to be careful, but I didn't run into any of this.
I used Opus (can't remember which one, but it was recent) to start fresh recently and it worked pretty well, I even sent pics of my rig to diagnose why my fans weren't spinning and it wrote scripts to test my fans and it determined I just didn't plug it in, which ended up being true.
It property detected I was on Ubuntu and every command worked, minus some minor versioning hiccups.
I used opus to switch to cachyOS in a few hours, instead of taking a whole weekend. After I asked it to tweak the cpu performance levels, to increase game performance on energy saver, it ended up diagnosing that the RAM overclock I was using was pushing the RAM to an higher latency mode
Unfortunately, software developers haven't caught up, and many critical applications for some people just don't work well enough. For Linux to be viable for many people, they need to be able to just click on their application and for it to work. No fiddling involved. Even with fiddling, though, it's too easy to lose time and not come up with a solution.
This has to do with software developers not supporting it well enough; nothing's wrong with many of the distros.
This is changing rapidly. I was stuck on MacOS because I needed Lightroom and DJ apps. Today there are open source alternatives popping up that are very close to closing the gap for me.
As well as Affinity announcing Linux support soon.
I want to believe you, but this very closely echoes the "year of Linux" that's always been a year away...
The year of the Linux desktop is a meme because Linux desktop isn’t a fixed target where one day it’s suddenly viable. It’s a gradient where it becomes more viable for more people over time.
And I think AI boosting open source is a huge push towards making it viable.
I've found agents have solved most of this because they can do the fiddling.
"I'm sorry grandma, but that's because your keyring is out of date since the computer was off for so long. Oh but first you'll need to manually fix the date so ssl works" - problems nontechnical people will never be willing to deal with
That would be where the proposed solution the person you replied to comes in.
As in, let them run an agent to do it for them? Cause sure as hell they won't copy paste commands into the terminal. And if they do they will bork their system:
rm -rf /home/joe/123.mp3
User selects text, copy - pastes:
rm -rf /home/joe
Personally, I would never ever let an agent run arbitrary unvetted commands on a host holding valuable data (that's what disposable sandbox VMs are for).
But for a "grandma" type user who would happily fall for a Nigerian prince scam? I suspect adding Claude to the wheel group would not significantly increase their risk exposure.
I would phrase it differently: It's more about businesses neglecting a minority of users. It's seldom the developer's choice.
I've been caught on considering switching from an M1 macbook pro to a framework linux laptop, but I'm not fully confident in whether linux is up to the "just works" state. I used to use linux on my laptop and desktop for a couple years, but when computers stopped being a hobby and started being a job, I didn't want to spend my evenings fiddling with driver issues.
At this point I don't use any computers much outside of work. I do most email and chat on my phone and have a reddit app that got the accessibility exemption and is ad/algorithm free. I pull out my laptop once a week or so and I am mostly just using chrome. I've considered switching to a tablet, but I have been thinking about going back to uni and I would need a laptop for that.
With how intermittently I'm even using a computer at all at this point, I don't want to have to be thinking about version updates every time I log in and it's nice to have something idiot-proof. I am comfortable with the terminal and have used linux in various contexts for a decade (though not on the desktop/laptop in the last 5 years), but maintaining my laptop is no longer a hobby.
I've been using a Framework 16 with Linux on it for 1.5 years now, and everything has been smooth. The only issue I had was a hardware issue, which I would have had on Windows as well.
The issue, if you're interested, was that earlier builds of the Framework 16, including mine, could flex just a little bit while closed if something was pressing on them, e.g. if they were in a backpack with a bunch of other things. This would result in the screen actually pressing keys on the keyboard when it flexed, causing the computer to wake out of sleep mode. (They've apparently fixed that in the past year with a different material for the laptop's metal frame, which flexes less, but I can't tell you from personal experience whether it works because I have kept my laptop). For original laptop owners, they released a BIOS update about six months ago that allowed the keyboard to turn off when in sleep mode, so that it wouldn't wake the computer anymore. That solved the issue for me.
So my personal recommendation is yes, buy a Framework laptop and run Linux on it. You won't be paying for a Windows license if you don't need one, unlike with most manufacturers where the price of a Windows license is baked into the price of the laptop. (Framework isn't the only one to offer you the option of not paying for Windows, thankfully).
I see others have recommended System76; I've never used them but they also have a good reputation.
You don’t need to buy a whole new laptop to get back into Linux. Dual boot it off your MacBook. Don’t get stuck in the idea you have to “abandon” Mac OS and go all in on Linux. You can have the best of both worlds.
I’ve done this with a few of my Mac devices over the years, I honestly would find myself booting into Linux more often than not.
It's there. I bought a new Asus laptop last year, never even booted Windows on it. Went straight to CachyOS and everything worked out of the box.
The year of the Linux desktop is genuinely among us.
https://frame.work/linux
I can recommend System76 for Linux machines that just work. They have their own distro (Ubuntu/Debian-based) that's tested with the hardware they ship, I've never had a single need to fiddle with drivers or anything else. As a product line they're a little weird in that they seem to work with whatever hardware they can get their hands on from OEMs, so there's not much look-and-feel consistency from model to model and generation to generation, but I can attest that the current-gen Lemur Pro is excellent.
> Unfortunately, software developers haven't caught up, and many critical applications for some people just don't work well enough. For Linux to be viable for many people, they need to be able to just click on their application and for it to work. No fiddling involved.
Others are already passionately debating whether Linux applications require fiddling or not.
But I would like to also add that the amount of "fiddling" involved with Windows applications has _massively_ increased over the past 10 years. Please sign in to continue. Please sync your cloud data. Please update to the latest version. Please agree to the new terms of use. We and our 84083 partners care about your privacy. Please confirm you are a human. Please set up your Microsoft® Authenticator®. We have updated your UI for a better experience, how do you like the new look? You have selected the 'classic experience', please share your feedback. Copilot® can help you draft an email. Copilot® can help you use Notepad. We have added a Copilot® key to your keyboard. Sorry, the servers cannot be reached, please retry later.
Linux has got better, whether that's enough can be argued. Windows has got so, so much worse.
Not as easy as it seems. I'm on a HP Laptop that basically cannot boot in Linux, because of problems with ACPI due to botched firmware, and HP does not want to fix it because they're crooks. Some people attempted to fix it, but the fixes are not comprehensive.
Fedora KDE edition would be a better Windows desktop experience than Windows itself.
Would be? Is.
As someone that uses Linux since 1995, and UNIX in general since 1993, this is only true when using classical PC desktops, with laptops and NUCs it remains an adventure, depending on the hardware model.
Ubuntu and Fedora work great on Laptops and NUCs.
It surely do not on a Gigabyte Brix from 2025.
No matter what trick I pulled, it could only boot from external disc, UEFI never acknowledged its existence, nor carefully prepared partitions for its consumption.
Eventually I had enough trying to make it happen, and into the recycling bin it went, I am not kidding, it was really sent into a recycling company.
If you're a person who regularly reboots your computer you might as well try a live USB of any distro or a few different ones. This is the whole Linux system written to a USB stick and ignoring your hard drive.
You make this at home by downloading one of the distros and overwriting a USB stick using one of various tools to do this. Note, it will overwrite the full contents of the USB stick and you'll have to reformat the stick to get it back to a normal state so you can put files on it again.
The main caveat would be to not care too much about hardware: if you're on a classic desktop or standard laptop setup it should be fine. Basically, if you could move to macos, you could move to linux as well.
If instead you're spending your life on a Surface Pro or a Z13, or some other alternative form factor, linux is probably not for you yet. It runs, but touch support and QOL for tablet mode is subpar at best.
I agree with this. Touch support is quite awkward, stylus support is especially worse since stylus is considered an absolutely positioned mouse than a type of touch. I'm using a Lenovo Ideapad 5, and the main reason why I have yet to switch fully (I have CachyOS on an external SSD) is due to the pen support and also shitty OneNote support (I'm supposed to use a browser??)
Which do you think is the best distro which maintains compatibility with all/most windows key strokes? Most importantly - Win-E for explorer, alt-tab for switching windows, ctrl-tab for switching tabs within a window. If I switch my home PC to linux, I will still need windows at work and can't afford to have different key bindings
Any distro with KDE would work in this scenario, because i had the same thought when i started with Linux. Kubuntu and Fedora's KDE spin are good options to get started.
For the shortcuts that don't exist or don't do what you want, you can trivially configure them. Example - ctrl+shift+esc doesn't bring up "task manager", but you can simply right click on KSystemMonitor in start menu and assign that shortcut.
I don't know every distro, but that fits Mint + Cinnamon. Win + E is file explorer. Alt+Tab switches Windows. You have a classic start menu. If you type task manager, the start menu points you to the system monitor (the equivalent of task manager). It has aliases for the typical Windows tools.
Also Mint + Cinnamon basically looks like Windows and it designed to be intuitively usable by Windows users.
KDE has these out of the box, so CachyOS (if you install it with KDE), MX Linux although I don't like that one, Debian + KDE, Fedora + KDE, Bazzite + KDE, and many many others.
Linux can be booted from USB - in fact, most of these installers are the full version of the same Linux. So for example if you download the CachyOS image, and boot it from USB, boom, you can now try CachyOS. I suggest you to try this, and to try dual-booting. That way, you won't lose your main system, should anything go wrong.
Use Debian, or if you're more security minded use Fedora.
As a Debian main, I will always recommend Fedora for most other people. The end user experience on Fedora is more polished, and the hardware support is miles ahead from not having ancient software.
Yeah...
You "just" need to install a new Fedora system every 13 months and hope for the best..
Or you use an atomic spin :) so far I've upgraded my system from Fedora 41 to 44. I only notice the update because after boot there's a new background image & a dialog window explaining the new features!
UniversalBlue (business) and Bazzite (gamer extension) are exceptionally well distros.
My standard pet talk is "if my boomer parents could switch to Linux - so can you"
lol the exact message that led me to ruin the family computer with Linux 20 years ago
What about switching from Linux to Windows? I feel like I should give this new Windows thing a go some time.
I swear there's like a manual for anti-linux posts that's resulted in people posting the same basic thing to reply to this since like 2008
"I daily drive every operating system known to man and the normies just aren't ready for this yet"
"Linux doesn't Just Work like [preferred corporate OS]" (lol, lmao)
Basically some flavor of "I am an enlightened computer nerd who knows that you must be a braingenius to use anything but the shareholder-approved device configurations". This is also the exact sales pitch microsoft makes when they sell hospitals, schools, and other institutions on letting them control their IT, as well as the basis of their advertising. "Your computer, simplified!" I don't buy that these people are speaking from a place of actually making a useful effort to help anyone.
Meanwhile, in reality I've been helping aunties, product managers, call center workers, and gamers use linux for several years and generally speaking there are enough desktop environment options that are learnable that generally these people are by and large happier after about a week or so. The tech companies have really been degrading the customer experience in pursuit of shiny objects, telemetry, lock-in, and ads. The bar is in hell.
I think the key to this success has been taking a different approach. A lot of people seem to say "You should do this better thing, here's a guide". Installing any linux distro is a lot more activation energy than using it, and people don't really know where to start. But getting people started requires:
1. Ask about what their use case for a computer is. You may even do a small amount of research about what's out there, if you're not already aware of what applications they're likely looking for. Most people who are used to being told what software to use are not used to looking. Despite being strongly of the opinion that most people's computing needs can be served by a linux distro, I have definitely done this for some people and said "this might not actually be possible yet, you may still need one computer to be a mac" or whatever for edge cases like very specific corporate software. Maybe have a few different DEs in mind that someone might want to use. One-size-fits-all is dumb. People's needs are different.
2. Let the person whose computer it is drive an install process, but be there to answer questions. The goal is for using the computer to be something they seldom if ever need direct assistance to do, and people get there a lot faster if they're touching the thing to set it up.
3. Have other people there. Make it a team endeavor. This makes frustrating things a lot more fun, and any messing with your computer is frustrating. If you're a computer toucher for a living, you get paid primarily to tolerate frustration while you get from a thing not working to it working.
This is hands-on, but the value someone gets out of control of their computer is worth the investment, for you and for them
A comment out of Slashdot. This is why memes persist.
There are memes everywhere, for those who have but eyes to see
hard mode: nixos
Then you will never go back to non-declarative system ever again
Not to diminish NixOS, but what good do you believe is in there for the normal folks, besides precious disk space wasted, "everything that touches software installation" becoming orders of magnitudes slower, and more cognitive overhead?
I don't know that it can be recommended for a desktop OS, but I switched to using it for development VMs because of coding agents. I can let the agent manage things while I still have complete visibility to what it has done and ability to rollback. "Normal" people wouldn't be looking at the diffs but in terms of having reproducible configurations managed by an agent with trivial rollback when things don't work right I think they'd get the same value, if not more.
Also, it is completely inaccurate that everything touching software installation becomes "orders of magnitude slower". Some operations do take longer, but some operations are actually faster than other package managers such as homebrew.
yeah, i hear that since the 90s, no, just no.
Just as AI has advanced massively in the past two years, I think a lot of gamers would be shocked at how viable Linux is as a genuine gaming platform in 2026. I already have plans to switch from Windows to Linux, I even have Linux running from an external drive to play with it.
The vast vast majority of single player games are 100% perfect on Linux. Multiplayer still has lots of hiccups.
Praise Gabe. No seriously, you would not be saying this in 2026 had it not been for a singular person named Gabe Newell. Valve’s Proton initiative almost single handedly brought us this. I don’t use Steam, or really any Valve products or games, just as some observing third party it’s really hard to say that this would have happened had Valve not done the whole Proton thing
Before Valve gaming on Linux was limited to Super Tux Kart and a small number of ported games. Once steam came to Linux around 2013 you had a selection of indie games mostly Unity stuff that could export to Linux for free. But still almost all major games did not work.
Proton was the turning point where you went from specifically looking for Linux games to just assuming everything works.
Wine existed long before Valve poured money into it. It was nowhere near as reliable before DXVK existed, but you could play many commercial Windows games well-- you just couldn't expect nearly universal support.
Wine was already an excellent project before valve came into the picture.
> ... you could play many commercial Windows games well
But this is just not true.
I guess it depends on your definition of "play". I got many commercial games running after hours of tweaking using Wine. Many had graphics errors and performance issues but one could ~technically~ play them.
One definition of 'play' that's probably quite useful is 'have fun'. You can technically play many games at e.g. 15fps but for many games that is hardly enjoyable. Likewise for random crashes or audio issues or whatever. 'Technically playable' gives me Supreme Commander at 100x slowdown flashbacks.
Not to argue, because I agree that a buggy or crashing game isn't super fun.
However, I did have fun growing up and trying to debug what had gone wrong, searching forums and stack overflow for hints, figuring out the incantation of library versions and registry tweaks to let me play some random pirated "match-reveal" games on Slackware
Really, I had no issues, assuming you didn't use a toaster.
Wine involved hacking through so many obscure logs to figure out why some webview didn’t work or why some font not existing crashed everything.
It was viable for games if you were already an engineer.
And were willing to Tinker without promise of a running game by the end of the tinkering...
It did exist, but you couldn't play most games you wanted to play. It could take months or even years—for AAA games—before you could play them. The performance was significantly worse. Today most games work on the release day and the performance is comparable to Windows.
Wow, this completely dismisses the work done by the Wine project before Proton and (perhaps controversial) products like Transgaming WineX/Cedega (which was a fork of Wine). A lot of popular games of the time worked with Cedega.
We can recognize the immersive role of Valve while also recognizing that there were quite successful efforts before that.
(Semi-related: anyone remember the good days of Loki Entertainment?)
Loki Entertainment, run by Sam Lantinga, author of SDL! Which I would argue did a lot for cross platform compatibility as well. We almost got world of warcraft for linux because of him (I added that to his wikipedia page).
Didn't Loki Entertainment do Rune?
Windows games you mean.
Agreed, although Wine is a separate tech, Valve's contribution to it, also analogical Metal to DX on MacOs makes playing Windows games on non Windows platforms very easy and pleasant.
I don't remember last time I was using Windows daily. I only have one VM at home in VM Ware, unregistered, I launch once a month to compile one portable project that I dare to support Windows but Windows is not my first class citizen since 2011 or so...
Thank you, Gaben. Happy customer for 21 years.
CEO worship is weird and exhausting.
This was the work of hundreds of people. My understanding is that the majority of it wasn't even done by Valve (they are not Linux experts after all) but rather commissioned by them and the actual work done by other companies.
All those experts deserve recognition, not just the billionaire at the top who said "let it be so".
Normally I’d agree with you. But Valve is a unique org that without Gabe would not be what it is. He made many pro-consumer anti-profit decisions. It’s worth a bit of praise.
I love Proton and use SteamOS daily, but I wouldn’t characterize the projects as “anti-profit.” I think Gabe correctly recognized the Windows monopoly and Microsoft Store as threats to his business. Microsoft wanted to recreate Apple’s App Store on their platform and take 30%.
I'd argue that GabeN has always had a broader sense of business and community respect overall, in the sense that valve doesn't only take but also gives, let people tinker with valve products, and doesn't immediately go ballistic.
Of course it is not entirely altruistic, some of it was fostered by his hatred of big M after working there, but it is baffling how much better than the competition they are ...
Now the question is how the company will do when he is gone, but I hope there is a general strategy and vision and a few guiding principles are enshrouded enough to survive him and valve doesn't go public, as soon as this happens, a lot of things are just going to go down...
I’d argue that you simply have absolutely no awareness of when you are being successfully marketed to. I’d argue that you are so used to not being the target market for things that you have mistaken this for being impervious to marketing, or being a “free thinker”. This is all just good marketing. Valve knows that gamers are skeptics that’re extremely sure of their intelligence. They therefore understand the importance of throwing the dog a bone at the right time, and playing the long game. There wouldn’t be anything special about this if it weren’t for the absolutely boneheaded cookie-cutter marketing strategies that work sufficiently well for mass-market products, that make this feel so comparatively fresh. It’s become increasingly prominent for products and services where developer-types are often organisational decision-makers. Go look at Tailscale’s marketing and business model. Go look at PostHog, whose marketing material capitalises on developer-types disliking sales and marketing people. It’s not sinister and it doesn’t mean that people in the organisation don’t care, but it’s just business. Good business, but just business. It’s not anti-profit, it’s it’s just… not making the most short-term boneheaded decision 100% of the time. Plenty of businesses do this.
I agree that in the long-term, it's obvious that these business strategies outperform the others. I agree that if you make users believe you are on their side, you will have a much more loyal userbase that stays in your ecosystem for longer. But I don't agree that it's just marketing, and I don't agree that being successfully marketed to means that it's a lie.
Good marketing tells the truth, as you want to hear it. Valve does. Do you remember "piracy isn't a pricing problem, it's a service problem"? That wasn't just marketing, it's true. You're "successfully marketed to" if you agree with that statement to such a degree that you associate with Valve and Steam over it. Does that mean you're not a "free thinker"? Does that mean you've been got?
One of the most important things in this day and age is choice. You should be allowed to choose things based on what you agree with. It is good that Valve exists, because no one else has this much agreement. No one else has their understanding. Treating it as simple marketing is an understatement. It's an underestimation. You're simplifying people to the point where their choice becomes invalid due to the very reasons it is valid!
I've been successfully marketed to many times in the past. Mostly by product placement, but also by sponsorship. Never by any banner or popup. I could say I'm impervious to advertising because it's not the advertising that convinced me. In all cases it was the product itself. It was self-evident. Maybe advertising is what got it in front of me, but in all cases I made the determination myself. I made the consideration myself.
I picked up Privacy.com from a sponsorship on The Modern Rogue. I picked up Ubiquiti/UniFi from many appearances across Linus Media Group. I picked up the LTT screwdriver, etc. It doesn't matter how I discovered them if the determination was still mine. That doesn't take away my agency or the significance of my decision. That doesn't mean I got got. And that doesn't mean all those products were dishonest.
Valve is the same way. They just are good. They've been good, and they'll most likely continue to be good. They're open. Honest. Transparent. They give back to open-source. They give you full root access to your own hardware that you purchased from them. I could go on and on. As much as you could say this is just a disingenuous marketing strategy and we've all been fooled... who cares?
> It’s not anti-profit, it’s it’s just… not making the most short-term boneheaded decision 100% of the time. Plenty of businesses do this.
Technically, yes, it's not fundamentally anti-profit - but the for-profitness we all hate is the short-term boneheaded decisionmaking you describe. Profit-on-paper over all else. It's refreshing to see businesses actually caring about customers as opposed to optimizing the report charts.
> Plenty of businesses do this.
Not nearly enough imho.
I'm very happy when marketing means competing for quality and customer satisfaction instead of the borderline-criminal behavior like Meta's and many others.
Everyone was told initially that capitalism works exactly this way and many would love to live in that world. Unfortunately we live in a spyware world with trashy race-to-the-bottom products. So proper business practices are met with gratitude and I don't see anything wrong with that. They do earn money from that, so what?
Earning money by providing your customers with high-quality products is not a bad thing.
Gabe can win and we can win at the same time. So I agree, his actions are not necessarily anti-profit (whether in intention or reality).
They are threats to, his business, but also threats to us owning the software we use, to having freedom to pick a hardware platform. We won't benefit as Microsoft and the hardware companies try harder and harder to lock down the computer platform.
Gate is good for the world! That doesn't mean we have to see him as some kind of perfect person. He's doing good things for the world. Let's keep supporting him.
I wouldn't say it was "anti-profit". The decisions taken around Steam are intended to make it profitable.
It's just that it turns out you can make something extremely profitable - profitable enough to pay really expensive developers a lot of money to work on open-source software - without doing so in a way that makes customers hate you.
I don't mind "profitable". I *like* profitable. I don't like "profit over all else".
He is also the one decided you cant play multiple purchased games at the same time.
There is no technical limitation for this, only profit purpose.
It’s like the mirror opposite of “damning with faint praise”. I wonder if there’s a name for that? Praising with faint criticism?
Actually family sharing opens that back up.
Proton + Easy Refunds is what I care about.
Also, I thought Steam Family sharing allowed simultaneous play from shared libraries.
Steam Family Sharing lets anyone in your family play the games you bought, but only as many copies at once as you bought. If my wife owns a copy of game A and I start playing it on my account (which doesn't own a copy of game A), she can play game B on her account just fine. But if she loads up game A she's told "someone else from your Steam family is currently playing that game".
So it depends on what you mean by "simultaneous play". Game A and game B played at once, yes. Game A played by two people at once when you own one copy, no.
For the record, I'm 100% fine with that.
So standard per seat licensing? At least it sounds like you have a license to a particular release as long as you have it. I was reading Amazon doesn’t honor audiobook licenses sold but will bait and switch for cheaper audiobooks than what you bought.
> So standard per seat licensing?
Yes, precisely.
Not really work because you can only log in 1 account at same time on 1 computer.
What are you talking about? You absolutely can. I just checked to see if it was some new thing by opening a bunch of games at once, nope - no problems at all.
This changed relatively recently, in March 2024. Prior to that, playing a single game locked the account's entire library.
That also doesn't track with my experience. I enjoy playing 'idle' games every once in a while which generally entails having a bunch of games open at once. That dates back at least a decade.
Looking it up, the restriction that is/was there is that you can't run the same game simultaneously on the same account on different devices, unless the other devices are set to offline mode. I don't think that's particularly heinous.
Only one person can own a Steam account. You're mad that you can't let another user, who did not purchase your games, play the games you purchased while you play a game you purchased at the same time.
i'm mad because it can not do what physical games can.
for example, if i buy 2 game discs, and i own 2 machine, i should be able to boot up 2 games at the same time.
Steam does not allow that last time i check, there is work around like make 1 of machine "offline", but i'm not sure if that violate any ToS.
Yes. It's called "sharing".
I'm barely capable of playing one game at a time, so it works out great for me.
Well prepare for the future then, immortality is still not a given for most folks.
The praise here is the opposite of the broader CEO worship you speak of. People love Gabe because he's hell bent on making something good for consumers (rather than being hell bent on taking consumers money)
As long as you ignore gambling.
It's really easy to avoid the gambling aspects of CS so I think most people are ignoring it. And they really cracked down on all the 3rd party website that were encouraging it, as well as intentionally destroyed their skins market by allowing people to trade up lower quality skins. So I think it's fair to ignore the gambling.
It's pretty easy to ignore gambling. There's no banner ads pushing it on you, there's no prioritization of games with gambling in the marketplace or sales AFAIK, and unless you specifically seek out certain games you're not going to accidentally run into it. And the gambling that steam is involved with is only their in house games... which is only a small portion of the actual store right?
I know it's baked in there but due to my library choices I have literally never encountered the gambling aspects of the Valve ecosystem.
So is meaningless dismissal.
Refute the point by showing how it's not true.
Wine already existed, and there were already a few companies trying to add polish to it, and there were already "living room" ui's, all before Valve, yet it is still true that the only reason it went from theory to reality is because Valve dug in and hauled it over the line, and the only reason Valve did that was because Gabe simply decided it was their way around MS and Sony and everyone else.
The comment gives credit to someone for doing something valuable. That is not worship. A worshipper might also do that, but so would a reasonable human.
I recognize countless people for countless things that I appreciate without worshipping any of them.
The company doing a large portion of the work posts on HN Who’s Hiring frequently. It makes me wonder if it’s impossible to get a job there, they aren’t actually hiring, or if turnover is insane.
I'm not sure why an established company like Valve would be posting on HN. I always figured the who is hiring threads around here are for yc companies that just graduated out.
Because it’s free and easy?
I have seen many CEOs wreck companies. Believe it or not CEOs actually do make a difference. Without good ones your company will go nowhere and with bad one they get destroyed. They set the direction. So yes I do think he deserves credit. Don't understand the billionaire hatred.
> Don't understand the billionaire hatred.
Some people never re-evaluate their assumptions. They worked at a company with a lousy CEO, therefore all CEOs are lousy. If pressed, they would acknowledge that it's bad logic, but they've formed a habit of thinking "CEO = bad" and don't break those habits easily.
Other people have never thought about it much, defaulting to whatever attitudes they've picked up through cultural osmosis. And the only billionaires I see portrayed positively in broader US culture are Bruce Wayne and Tony Stark. Other than those two, it seems like the default Hollywood portrayal is "billionaire = bad". (I'd welcome more counterexamples, it's possible I'm wrong here because I just haven't seen the right movies; this is an impression rather than a solid argument).
And some people have a worldview that says wealth is a zero-sum game, therefore anyone rich must have gotten that wealth by exploiting the poor.
There are plenty of people who don't fit any of those thought patterns, of course. But all of them are thought patterns I've observed here and there among HN comments. (And on the broader Internet as well, naturally).
> And some people have a worldview that says wealth is a zero-sum game, therefore anyone rich must have gotten that wealth by exploiting the poor.
Wealth is not zero-sum, but it is created by work. When you collect a salary in exchange for work, it is because your employer deems that your work is worth more than your salary. Otherwise, it would not be a sound financial decision to employ you. There is literally no way to rise to the top without paying people less than you think their work is worth.
When many thousands of people create value in exchange for less money than their work is worth, that's how you get a billionaire.
You might say, "well it's your choice to work", but under capitalism, donating the surplus value of your work to an richer person is the only way to survive. As in, you will literally die if you don't. If you can somehow collect the required capital to start a company, you can try to compete, but now you're donating your surplus value to billionaire investors instead, and with much fewer protections. If you succeed, you are now the one depending on thousands of workers donating the surplus value of their work to you, and the cycle repeats.
The only way to break the cycle is to keep the coordination of many humans, but forgo the upwards flow of wealth to a few individuals. We used to do this with taxes, and it's a crude mechanism, but it worked. Collective ownership seems to work even better.
The Napoleonic wars were fought by millions and yet they're named after Napoleon for some reason
CEO worship is weird when they're anti-philanthropy, or invest in enshittifying products.
But when CEOs make the right decision, selflessly, why can't we celebrate it? The work Valve sponsored created competitive pressure that Windows never had before. Microsoft cannot rest on the laurels of DirectX anymore, which has been a concern from the entire GPU industry since the Xbox came out.
Yes, CodeWeavers and Wine deserve applause. They both accept financial contributions if you'd like to go further than just lip service, but something tells me you don't have the fuck-you money that Gabe lined his pockets with.
From the sources that I can find, Valve employs over 100 open source devs to work on Proton and Wine, and has a large contract with CodeWeavers. When I think about why Valve does it, my best guess is to long term break free of the Microsoft ecosystem. It seems logical.
Yes, but Gabe Newell wasn't a billionaire when he said "let it be so".
Multi-millionaire on the back of Half-Life and Counterstrike, but definitely not a billionaire.
Gabe didn't invent Wine, he just forked it.
Although they did finally get around to sponsoring some of the work.
It’s not a fork, AFAIK it’s a set of ‘experimental’ patches on top of Wine, but it’s work that eventually gets merged into the project when/if accepted by its maintainers.
> it’s a set of ‘experimental’ patches on top of Wine, but it’s work that eventually gets merged into the project when/if accepted by its maintainers.
So, a fork?
I read it as each patch is based on the upstream, so it doesn't diverge over time. Maybe you could say it's a set of forks instead of a single fork, where each fork has exactly one patch...
As much as the linux-next tree is a fork of torvalds' linux repo.
A fork assumes divergent development, not a unstable branch of the original product that eventually gets merged back.
Gabe praise is such an enduring exception in a culture that’s otherwise become a lot more understanding of the small overall role that leadership plays in things like this. I understand gamers lionising people like this because gamers by and large simply don’t understand tech, but let’s not bring this to HN please. This is especially frustrating as an (oft-touted by this same group of people!) feature of Valve as an organisation is the supposed extremely high degree of autonomy offered to ICs. So, which is it? Gabe Newell is just a guy. Gamers just love a hero.
You can make the argument they're extracting too much from developers, or have strong opinions on their cosmetics marketplace, but what they've consistently avoided for the 20 odd years of Steam is fleecing their customers.
A lot of their live service games are free, and cosmetics entirely detached from in-game benefits.
They have a huge entrenched customer base, and yet they don't force their customers to pay for things they don't want, and they still make tons of money hand over fist.
There's been a lesson there for publicly traded companies for decades, yet no one wants to learn.
I'm not very interested in where these decisions come from, but as Gabe has a controlling stake and it's a private company, one can assume he's at least not opposed to the decisions made.
>So, which is it?
tl;dr: Gaben is the boss
That autonomy is a bit of a lie. It was discussed on HN when Valve's employee handbook "leaked". The tyranny of structurelessness - you still have power structures, just not formal ones. Whatever it is at Valve, Gabe Newell is the owner and there is no indication that he can't make stuff happen if he wants to.
Nah, screw Gabe and his kiddie casinos.
We can also thank Microsoft and Bill Gates. The main reason Valve was forced to make Linus a viable option is because Microsoft decided to have a gaming store (Games for Windows) in 2006 to directly compete with Steam on Windows. Steam Machines was the first shot from Valve as a result. I’m happy that they didn’t stop even after that failure. IMO only a founder without a leash can do what Gabe has done.
Unfortunately this is the real answer. Valve saw the existential threat from Microsoft and knew they needed an escape hatch; that's Proton. Of course MS has been famously behind the curve on just about every market they've tried to tap into (lol Zune, Windows phone, Azure), but they're the still gatekeepers of PC gaming at the moment because every dev targets windows first. Valve is not developing Proton out of 'the goodness of their heart'. They're a multi-billion dollar corporation, not a person. Never forget that.
Valve is like the open-source Apple of gaming. Apple believes you own your data; Valve believes you own your hardware. You can see Apple as either privacy's last hope (as I do), or just a greedy manipulative capitalist empire, and the same goes for Valve.
Long story short, I think the goodness of their heart is actually a considerable factor in why they developed Proton the way they did, and especially out in the open. They weren't just trying to make money for themselves, they were trying to knock Windows down for everyone. Or rather, bring Linux up. Because they believe this choice should be available to everyone.
If they didn't truly believe that, there would be no reason to spend so much time and effort being open. You could say it's all a manipulative ploy for money anyway, but you could say that for anyone doing anything.
Apple and Valve aren’t good or bad. But I’m ride or die with them because my interests and their incentives have been aligned for the last decade. If those diverge then I’ll reconsider.
They’ve treated me well with their policies and I’ve treated them well with money. That’s all there is to it.
Right, you can see it both ways is my point. Or, you can simply see it how it is.
> You can see Apple as either privacy's last hope (as I do)
You mean, the same Apple that requires you to create an account with your first name, last name, date of birth, email and phone number so you can install software and updates on their platforms?
Why wouldn't any Linux or BSD distro be better at "privacy's last hope" than Apple?
Mostly because Linux makes everybody think you are a suspicious hacker or botnet. It's known for being sovereign, which causes everybody to block it and nobody to extend support for it. Apple doesn't have that reputation, in fact most people think strongly the opposite, which means it has extensive corporate support and trust. You do get strong privacy guarantees even if you object to the use of their services (which themselves still have strong privacy guarantees). And you get to enforce those strong privacy guarantees against the apps on your device, without losing access to the apps completely.
In practice, having access to that kind of stuff without your device also spying on you is a benefit that Linux doesn't always grant you. Not everybody needs that kind of stuff, but not everybody needs interaction at all. It takes some time and expense to get there, time and expense not everybody has yet.
Yes, thank we should, because without Windows Proton doesn't have games to run on top of it.
I'm an avid gamer, fully made he switch earlier this year to CachyOS. Dota 2 is my main game, I get better FPS on Linux than I ever did on Windows. I play other games like PEAK, Risk of Rain 2, and Enshrouded no problem with my friends. I have been enjoying STALKER 2 on Linux as well, runs just fine.
The biggest barrier is kernel anti cheat, so no Call of Duty, Battlefield, etc. Luckily my friends don't play those AAA multiplayer games, protondb is a good resource to check which games can't run due to their anti cheat.
> I get better FPS on Linux than I ever did on Windows.
How is this actually possible? Wine is always going to add at least a little overhead because it has to translate system calls and such, right? And, well, I know Linux GPU drivers have improved a lot, but are they really better than the Windows drivers now?
Very few, if any modern games actually use WINE. In today's world, if you want a Linux build for your game, it's usually just a checkbox option in Unity/Unreal/Godot etc. A lot of games just have native Linux support. Those that don't use Proton, which is designed specifically to accelerate graphics calls.
As for faster, it's not that Linux does anything special to improve speeds, Windows is just genuinely that bad. Windows on its own consumes more resources than pretty much any Linux distro which means there's more compute for your game.
Again counter-intuitive: compatibility is better with Linux. I have some old games that won't play on modern Windows but work flawlessly under Linux.
There really is no good reason to use Windows other than being locked into Adobe software or whatever. Linux is just better in pretty much every sense.
I don’t think this is actually true. If anything native linux games have become less common after proton.
Native Linux builds used to have their own bugs like dynamically linked libraries which would go missing over time. While running a windows build in proton means any issue can be solved by the community rather than begging the publisher.
> Very few, if any modern games actually use WINE. In today's world, if you want a Linux build for your game, it's usually just a checkbox option in Unity/Unreal/Godot etc. A lot of games just have native Linux support.
Isn't Valve's own recommendation to target Windows and let Proton handle Linux compatibility?
> Those that don't use Proton, which is designed specifically to accelerate graphics calls.
I know, but Proton is just Valve's branch of Wine.
Or if you're like me and your laptop/ GPU isn't yet supported by Linux well enough.
> Like, Wine does have to translate system calls and such, so it's always going to add some overhead, right?
Yes, of course. The key to understanding it is that this is still less overhead than Windows adds.
> are they really better than the Windows drivers now?
So a game I play (Path of Exile 2) started crashing after an Nvidia driver update on windows. It was really bad and they (GGG, the developers) couldn't figure out why. They created a workaround where the game wouldn't crash, but instead pause while the driver restarted. They made a video when it was finally fixed [0].
Anyway, I was on Linux at the time and completely fine. When I played with friends on windows, the instance would pause whilst their drivers restarted.
So I would say that for at least some games, it's definitely better. I also have an Nvidia card on Linux, which historically has been pretty awful.
[0] https://youtu.be/XDEJLOHcdWw?si=brA5x2QlwP-5TeWJ
Windows 11 has a lot of overhead with CPU and RAM from my experience (also compared to Windows 10). A minimal Arch/CachyOS setup is surprisingly light, especially for older hardware
One thing the other replies are missing, Valve publishes a native dota 2 build for Linux. The answer is probably either better drivers, less background sw, or one of the many possibilities in how valve chooses to build the binary
the key to wine, which siblings overlook, is that it doesn’t just translate syscalls. it’s a straight up fresh implementation of all the windows apis and dlls and the high level interfaces can decompose into efficient calls that provide the needed semantics
Some games are using directx to vulkan layers where vulkan drivers are better than directly using old directx. Hard to say for sure though.
Often because it's not a complete reimplementation and some functionality is skipped/silently missing.
EAC Linux v2 is coming -- it sounds promising. I don't love having to disable custom kernel modules, but booting without them for gaming would be acceptable to me if I get to play some competitive FPS.
Yup! Would switch immediately, if LOL would be supported. The anti cheat stuff is a pain for linux gaming. Hope this will change some day.
All of the major anti-cheat systems work on Linux if the developers allow it. Its the ring0 mandate that doesn't work, and that's a choice by the game devs. I sincerely hope that ring0 anticheat will never be made to work on Linux, because it shouldn't be a thing in the first place.
Video game companies have no business being in the kernel. Even security companies like Crowdstrike couldn't be trusted to write safe kernel code, so there's no way in hell I'm letting a game company poke holes in the most sensitive part of my system.
I wish companies just invested in machine learning anti cheat that would run server side so i didn't need to run some invasive garbage if I wanted to play flavor of the month multiplayer game once in a while with a group of friends
Counter-Strike
I am quite a serious 'gamer', having played professionally in the past and still now being #1 ranked in my country in League of Legends (arguably the most played competitive game in the world) even though I work fulltime. That being said, I tried doing the switch to Linux a few months back and I think for most people it will feel better, but unfortunately for me, where I put a lot of attention to detail, it was not. My core open issues at this moment were:
- FreeSync was a bit buggy to setup and triggered on weird applications when it shouldn't have (although I found workarounds to disable FreeSync trigger on certain applications).
- Most competitive games are not supported yet, thus I was forced to still have dual-boot setup.
- Graphics driver settings were not readily configurable (AMD Adrenalin e.t.c.), thus a lot of features required hacky ways to enable.
- RTSS not on Linux :( (had to use MangoHUD or native FPS caps per game). This differed per game so required some maintenance (sometimes Mango sufficient, sometimes in game sufficient, sometimes launch argument needed).
- The constant investigations of which version of Proton should I use for x-game bugs me. Even though I know I should not overthink it, every time I notice a game is not as performant as I expected it to be, I couldn't help testing different Proton flavors or versions. Windows has the automatic advantage that the performance you get is almost definitely the performance expected; there are no real tweaks that can be made.
For the most part it was still great, but if you are someone who overthinks things and pays attention to detail, there are just one-to-many little things that aren't quite right yet that bug you.
The country being Luxembourg ? You list two countries in your user page and one would be a much more impressive achievement than the other (but still impressive, I never had it in me to rank anything but bottom tier on any competitive game I tried)
Yes, I switched to Fedora in January and have been playing all sorts of games on an RTX 4080 via Steam, Heroic Games (Epic Games alternative launcher), Modrinth, emulators, etc. The only one I haven't tried is GTA V: Online as I've read it's not compatible due to anti-cheat.
Claude Code/Codex is very helpful for overcoming any transitions hurdles - pop open a shell, describe the problem, and a few moments later it's fixed up. I recommend maintaining a doc as one gets the new system setup so it can be easily reproduced and referenced later. Anytime I change a setting or install an app I find useful, it goes in the doc.
> GTA V: Online as I've read it's not compatible due to anti-cheat.
> Claude Code/Codex is very helpful for overcoming any transitions hurdles
I have successfully bypassed the anticheat of several games that refuse to run on Linux, notably Valve's own. It's possible, but Claude now refuses such tasks.
Which Valve own games refuse to run on Linux/Proton?
Source games (HL2, CS:GO, Left 4 Dead 2, TF2) don't run on Proton because of a VAC issue. At least didn't, until Codex worked its magic.
So you got VAC-banned likely because of cheating, and you bypassed it?
recommended tooling or models that could do the same thing now that Claude refuses?
Codex, GLM, Qwen, DeepSeek. Codex is increasingly refusing though, enshittification is real.
I was expecting to have a degraded gaming experience in general when I dropped Windows, but Steam/Proton is impressively good. It can actually beat Windows performance on load times for some games, since the translated Vulkan shaders are cached. I suspect the issue with multiplayer games isn't any technical limitation, but rather the anti-cheat systems not allowing it.
There's still a fair bit of tweaking involved in my experience especially if you want to game with HDR. It often doesn't just work out of the box, and fiddling around with config or launch options is not something I want to do even with the assistance of AI.
Getting closer for sure, but for now I stick with Windows for gaming.
I have Nvidia hardware also. I've heard things are better with Linux on the AMD side, so that could be a factor.
I use HDR because I have an OLED gaming monitor; It can certainly be a pain, but it's getting easier; these days it's typically a couple of flags to enable HDR and you're good. I don't mind setting it once for a game if I'm going to play it for a while. Other users will typically provide the right flags on ProtonDB.
That said, I'd rather spend all of my time tweaking configs and not getting to play the game than use Windows. It's been over a decade now since I touched Windows at all and gaming on Linux is so good now I expect to be able to play any game I want (I don't play multiplayer so anti-cheat isn't an issue).
> There's still a fair bit of tweaking involved in my experience especially if you want to game with HDR.
HDR in general is a bit of a pain on linux. I use Ubuntu 26 for work and Gnome has an HDR toggle but its HDR implementation is quite bad and leads to washed out colors and more.
Also scaling. On Windows I get a 150% option (for my 5120x2160 monitor) while on Gnome I only get integer scaling ones: 133% and 166%. The problem is, 133 is too small, 166 too big. 150 is perfect but for that I have to edit a config file manually which means I can't use the UI to change monitor stuff since that would revert my change.
I hate windows too but for certain tasks it's just much much better, at least for now. The windows auto-hdr feature works REALLY well comparatively.
I only rarely have to tweak settings, but I don't use HDR. I do use Nvidia and I've never had problems with it, just install the drivers and good to go.
It is surprising how playing games in linux is so straightforward (as long as it does not have anticheat though), but trying to open a standard document like pdf with some forms it is just a pain at least on Okular or libreoffice.
In windows you can get xpdf or foxit, that they don't offer perfect compatibility but never encountered an issue with forms. It does not seem to exist such a thing in linux, neither it looks like they are keen to solve it anytime soon.
Another issue is someone unsafely extracted a pendrive in windows. There is no easy way to read or write in that pendrive without a windows machine.
Most PDF forms work perfectly fine for me via Firefox on Linux, including saving the filled out copies.
But if you have a pdf on a KDE default configuration it opens with okular not with firefox. I imagine that gnome would do the same with evince?
Those little nuances are often overlooked by people with more technical knowledge, but I can't set up a computer to, for example, my mom and forget about it.
Even if I do the extra mile to configure pdf with firefox, there is going to be another little thing like this. Yes it is solvable, but it should not need a workwaround.
The same way, that installing a local account in w11 is solvable, with a workaround. Workarounds should not be the solution.
I fill every PDF form with Okular and have very rarely an issue with that. It doesn’t support XFA, but those are very rare.
Have you tried PDFCraft?
To be fair with you, no, I haven't tried.
Well, of course it's different. In one case, you're translating the Windows software, and in another case, you're trying to re-implement the software from scratch. The equivalent to Proton would be translating Microsoft Office instead of trying to rewrite it.
I understand the differences. It is mostly that with enough work, what was an herculean impossible task, is now a piece of cake. The Linux Desktop needs more of those Herculean to polish a bit more for other stuff.
Honestly I would say the game situation now is a problem solved.
Linux gaming was basically a hobby for so long until the muscle at Valve really brought things along. The only thing that sucks is the entire Linux UX for anyone who isn’t a computer person. But Valve is also really bringing that along, too.
Modern KDE (6.x) with OnlyOffice and Brave/firefox is a dramatically better experience for the 99% than Windows 11.
It’s incredible that the comparison of Windows 7 vs 2009’s Linux still remains the measure by which people judge the current status quo.
Seriously go onto either and try to:
- Edit a docx file (Windows: prepare for licensing fun)
- Set your audio output to use a Sonos or homepod (KDE: 2 clicks; Windows: impossible)
- Edit a PDF file (Windows: abandon all hope)
It’s rather analogous to trying to use a smart TV’s native interface vs an AppleTV. I guess if you want a slow, un-ergonomic, ad-ridden, half-baked experience…?
I would argue that most skilled technology professionals are sticking to Windows 10 for long as they can. I'm not sure where this Windows 7 /2009 Linux comparison is coming from, but at least on Windows 10 (and generally speaking):
Why can't people just use the same OnlyOffice software you mentioned? There are so many tools and editors out there in this day and age. What's your point here? It takes two clicks for selecting an audio device from the desktop/task tray at least in Windows 7/10. I keep seeing this but, who in their right mind edits PDF files? Short of minor changes (e.g. signature stamps, secure sign, move/extract) PDF format is akin to a finished photo in photography. Better to edit the source document with your layers and everything than trying to adjust something that shouldn't be modified directly.Even so, at least with modern, well designed documents Microsoft Office and other comparable tools have had the ability to open/modify/transform PDFs back to other formats and vice versa for some time. Absolutely wild comparisons, all things being equal.
> It takes two clicks for selecting an audio device from the desktop/task tray at least in Windows 7/10
I think the parent's point was more that you can't set a Sonos device to be an output device on Windows (or at least it won't automatically detect them and set them up for you as such), whereas on modern Linux this will Just Work.
For docx it's because "everyone" used word and loading docx in anything else messes with formatting
I edit things like "my resume" in both word and onlyoffice and see no formatting differences.
And I make heavy use of the featureset (fields, auto headers with different pages, custom styles...)
I consider onlyoffice to be better at editing word docs than word.
Once again: this isnt 2009.
there isn't really anything special about the docx format, it's literally just a zip file container with some XML blobs and the original doc document within in. The formatting fidelity of some text may get lost and/or images could be destroyed if you open it wrong, but the standard itself is fairly well understood and others have implemented it well by now.
My wife's gaming PC is NixOS with KDE and she doesn't seem to have a lot of issue with it. She's not really a computer person and hasn't had too much trouble navigating modern KDE at all, though granted she does have me for tech support if necessary.
I really don't think modern Linux is "nerd UI" anymore, at least KDE and Cinnamon are pretty approachable for non-software people.
Ubuntu is also very approachable for normies.
We also live in the era of LLMs. One of the nastiest things about Linux in the past was the elitism/RTFM type stuff. The era of ATFLLM means basically anybody should be able to comfortably run Linux if they want.
ATFLLM?
Ask the... in the spirit of RTFM.
KDE is now better than both Windows and Mac OS.
The frog has been boiled so much on those desktops people don't see how much they suck now.
> The only thing that sucks is the entire Linux UX for anyone who isn’t a computer person.
But also, most PC gamers are computer people, maybe not to quite the same extent as the average HN reader but certainly much more than the average person. Non-computer people play games on consoles.
>But also, most PC gamers are computer people
I think you'd be shocked at how untrue this is. Most people under like, 30, who game on PC barely even understand folder structure. They just prefer PC either because of the games it offers (counter strike, for example) or the fact that you can get higher FPS than a console.
If that's the case they could just use Bazzite/SteamOS and call it a day, CS runs native on Linux.
Linux's real "issue" with gaming is that it doesn't support most non-Valve AAA multiplayer titles namely COD, Battlefield, Marvel Rivals, Overwatch, LoL, Valorant, among others.
Linux's issue is that its not user friendly. Has it become much, much more user friendly over the years? Absolutely! But in that same period of time Windows has only been more and more dumbed down.
Put yourself in the shoes of an iPad kid born in the mid 2000s. All they know is an app store and maybe a downloads folder (that isnt called a folder). They know windows, maybe they use it at their part time job or something, so they get a PC and install windows. Steam is the app store.
Lots of them genuinely have no idea about downloading random .exe files to install, file structure in a computer, or even getting drivers directly from the hardware manufacturer's website.
From that point of view, Linux, however simple, is extremely complex. The other compounding factor is that these younger people typically focus on f2p, GAAS type games. Warzone, Fortnite, and so on. All games that wont work on linux. So the proportion of a younger cohort playing games that just wont work on linux is higher than say, you or me.
Can't play faceit on Linux because of the anti cheat
> or the fact that you can get higher FPS than a console.
I mean, you're saying they know what FPS means, that's kind of a big deal.
I'd assume most also have some idea of what antialasing is, what VRAM is, and stuff like that. Because otherwise... I don't understand how you do anything? Are people just buying prebuilt PC's from Dell and using the default graphical settings?
I get most of my knowledge of this from both having younger family members and having gone back to uni, so speaking to uni age people whilst feeling like a boomer myself.
They've got no idea what AA is, but follow the rule of thumb that higher number = better. FPS matters as much as they notice the game feels better, but if you press them on their monitor refresh rate, they would have no idea.
They'll buy pre-built custom PCs from PC builders, or in my case, get a family member (me) to build it given a particular budget. Download steam, then hit install. Sometimes they'll change the graphics settings ingame but that typically comes to the pre-set settings profiles (low/med/high/ultra etc).
I honestly think people here saying they expect people to know what VRAM/AA is if they know what FPS means are just incredibly out of touch or trolling
I mean, the FPS counter is extremely common everywhere, every video/benchmark/measure is about how much FPS this or that is, why would a niche thing like AA/VRAM be known vs. the thing everyone talks about?
and I'm saying this because I'm pretty sure this has been a thing for like at least a decade now, it's not a new phenomenon
and I struggle to understand the whole "I don't understand how you do anything?"
like do people here really think that games require you to know every little thing under the graphics settings? surely Sony doesn't expect PlayStation users to know all that, so why would you need to on a PC?
I'm young, so I can't relate, but I feel like sometimes people here are incredibly proud to be old and out of touch, it's kind of like a rite of passage to be able to tell everyone that you have no idea what the new generations are like?
I just think while it's fine to not know everything, it's maybe not the best for you to be completely isolated and unaware of what's going on, and I'm talking more about stuff in general vs PC gaming
I don't think they're trolling, it's just really easy to overestimate how much the average person knows about a topic you're an expert in (good old https://xkcd.com/2501/).
Most of the techies here are so used to having their expertise (and being surrounded by other experts) that they don't even realize that things they can do in their sleep are black magic to the average person. Especially given how different the average person's experience with tech is today, compared to even just 15 years ago.
E.g. recently I was teaching an intern some C++ only to stumble on how to explain compiled binaries to someone whose primary experience with software was apps and with programming was Python scripts. For me, that understanding was built as a child screwing around in WinXP and trying to open exe files in notepad, so it caught me off-guard to realize that the defaults on modern OSs make such tinkering harder to stumble into.
This was true pre 2015 but it’s very much untrue today. Xbox died off PS5 has stagnated, PC gaming has been constantly growing and mobile has exploded.
By the numbers the average gamer plays on a phone.
What is terrible about Linux ui? I've used it for so long I can't step outside of and be objective. Hard to believe it's worse than win 11 or golden gate for any of the major desktop environments (only used kde for a while, though)
Some pain points. (It's tough for me too as I'm familiar and comfortable with it)
Desktop linux largely uses polkit and elevation dialogues, not sudo.
What have you needed to do with terminal? KDE (kubuntu etc) largely shouldn't, it's an option for power users, it shouldn't be something you are forced to interact with: similar to cmd or the windows registry... it exists but it's not like you are expected to interact with it.
I also haven't compiled software for myself in about a decade. But of course you are beholden to the package maintainers.
I can answer this concisely; not in the terms exactly you describe, but I hope sufficiently: What you describe is a different experience from what I have observed.
edit: I think I understand from reading context: I do not assume all software someone will use is available on the distro's package manager, or that I want to use the versions on the distro's package manager. I think these discussions sometimes get confused because there is mentality A: that you should only use software on your OS's app store, and B: That you should be able to run arbitrary software. I suspect you are A and I am B here, but am not sure.
I agree that if you only use included software or install software from your package manager, most of the pain points, including the ones I mentioned go away.
I recently have been experimenting with Fedora.
Every piece of software(1Password, my own, and others) that I wanted to install has required me to paste an incantation into the command line to install it. It is incredibly unfriendly to less technically inclined users.
It should be:
Download RPM package ->
Double click RPM package ->
Approved access elevation prompt ->
Done!
Instead it fails completely by either trying to open the package like an archive or opening it in Discover to show the package information with no option to install it.
Ideally you open “software centre” and there is a 1password you can just click “install” on, in fact: that is how it works. No need to use a web browser at all.
You’re applying Windows thinking to another OS. Maybe we should make dummy installers that are just links to package managers for refugees; you’d have the same problem going to a Mac, its only windows software that forces every application to have its own update lifecycle system in its own process.
> You’re applying Windows thinking to another OS.
I'm applying how mainstream operating systems work to Linux. Windows is easy, download the installer and run it. MacOS is also easy, download the disk image and copy the application to where ever.
My experience with Linux and installing applications has been a disaster. They fail to install from a downloaded RPM or DEB just by opening them. So the fallback is the command line which is already a failure for non-technical users. A simple "sudo dnf ..." is not too much to ask users to learn, but now they are being taught to copy and paste commands into the Terminal that they don't fully understand.
Well, on MacOS they use the App Store largely.
So, in that way they are similar- and you can download software, just barely anyone does that. Static binaries do work, but since almost nobody is embedding update methods in linux software I wouldn’t recommend it.
It's all beautiful until something doesn't work. Then you go find official website, read that "default repository contains old version, go add this repository instead, here are some magic commands to paste in terminal".
Example: https://docs.docker.com/engine/install/ubuntu/
I mostly like the idea of package managers and repositories but it has its own problems.
Indeed, I have the same gripes, even when using one of the more popular distros (Fedora).
From the top of my head, software I could not find in the main repos and had to resort to adding a COPR (= custom repo) for, install a downloadable .rpm, or worse use their suggested bash pipe install thingie:
- Docker
- VSCodium
- Joplin (note taker)
- GlobalProtect-openconnect
- AirVPN's client (yes, I know I can generate a openvpn config, but I think many users might not want to/be able to)
- Yadm
Some apps offer Flatpak installs as an alternative, but in many cases they are not maintained by the actual developers, but rather by a regular user/third party you have to trust.
In a nutshell, I don't find this particularly user friendly, and I don't think it can be expected of all users to understand the intricacies of the different linux package ecosystems and their implications, especially when the built-in GUI package managers do not always make it clear which source you are installing from (and why you would want a native package over a flatpak one for example).
Disclaimer, I still prefer using Linux, both for work and gaming, but I believe this is a major point of friction for many potential (new) users.
every year theres less and less of those is my point.
Docker is definitely “power user” software btw. If you can’t handle running commandlines you will almost assuredly have a really difficult time with docker itself on any platform.
That said, adding extra repos is possible in Ubuntu software center without a command line, I suspect Docker thinks it is catering for a demographic here.
My point isn't that running commands is impossible.
It's that you're trading one problem (manually downloading things) for different problem (you don't know if what you get is what you want).
But you run docker… what do you think you’re doing when you execute `docker pull`?
This is not specifically docker issue, docker is just an example.
Installing 3rd party software on Linux is often painful - you rely on official distro maintainers(slow) or official vendor distribution(not easy) or third party source like AUR(may not work and you are trusting some random guy to not steal your bitcoin wallet)
More and more you can rely on Flatpak, which is often supported by the vendor.
True, true with terminal. Figure 90 percent is in browser these days, though. and can open a dpkg or whatever via file browser and so many things are available by appimage. But i suppose navigating even just releases on GitHub is beyond so many.
All those are actually not that painful now that we have LLMs. Any config I need done I just ask DeepSeek to do it
The Linux UI isn't terrible. It sucks for macOS and Windows users simply because they have to invest time into learning it. For non-computer people, they don't want to deal with change. For computer people, they don't want to discard the years they have invested into developing workflows. All of the laundry lists of bad UI choices in Linux are just that. If a Linux user were to do the same, the lists would be just as long.
There are other places where Linux is weak, particularly in application support. Not everyone is a developer or a gamer.
One thing I observed installing Ubuntu on one of my parents computers is they just never updated it. Normal users never update things and expect the computer to update itself.
This is almost incompatible with the average Linux user who froths with rage if you even suggest the option of automatic updates.
Huh? https://itsfoss.com/author/abhishek/
KDE is similar. Settings > updates then set your preferences.
The foundation is unsuitable for non embedded/server environments. Everyone uses management tools so they can avoid maintaining FHS which is unsurprisingly one the first things Apple thrown out when transitioning to Unix.
Wake me up when KDE learns how to align things and how to be feature rich instead of button rich. Windows 11 is so bad it's almost on the level of Linux.
> Wake me up when KDE learns how to align things.
While I agree, and I have other minor criticisms (icons everywhere!), it's been so good for me in other areas I'm willing these things slip. I appreciate it for being an environment that is mature, has familiar defaults (to me), is not too opinionated and generally just gets out of my way.
I agree, but LLMs have made the pain points MUCH easier to navigate over the past few years.
People have been complaining about Windows ux for a while. It's so weird and ad-ridden today compared to where it was in 2010. Most Linux distros come with something people are familiar with and like, taking bits from Windows 7 or osx
Yes. Steam has really contributed well to gaming on linux
Just a few days ago, I wanted to run WoW on linux. It was as simple as adding custom game (.exe) to steam and running it with proton.
I always kept Windows as a dual boot just in case I needed to play games but I no longer do
I switched to Linux almost by accident. I never even “made a decision”.
It’s been great. I will never go back. There are some driver issues sometimes, but they’ve all been fixed with time.
It’s also amazing having my dev environment be so close to the server environment I deploy on. Continuity and harmony.
> It’s also amazing having my dev environment be so close to the server environment I deploy on. Continuity and harmony.
this is definitely the best part for me. no need to worry about buggy WSL or whatever. once I booted in, I basically never went back. and probably never will considering how big of a mess Windows 11 is
Progress is being made on the multiplayer front (Epic games is getting Fortnite to work on Linux) but the issue isn't really a software one, it's a mismatch of goals:
- Linux users don't want companies to spy on them or harvest their data without consent
- Multiplayer game companies don't want cheaters to sabotage the community and cause a collapse in trust and paying customers
This mismatch cannot be solved with software.
I swapped earlier this year to linux as my main. It plays most every game I play. The ones it doesn't are the ones that have certain kinds of anticheat (so mostly multiplayer). Things like dota2 have a native client and work great. However, it isn't seamless for windows games, I had all kinds of minor issues which all needed some kind of adjustment to settings. Luckily in the world of AI I can just my AI agent to diagnose and fix issues. I really like it. Linux is completely viable for most anything and hopefully with enough momentum we will see more people switching. Not that I'm anti microsoft, I still use it at work and have it set up really nicely for the things I do and it has a bit more "polish". I just think its just much better long term that the OS is open source and random marketing / executives can't hijack windows (or apple) OS to inject things people just hate.
Ironically, the mouse curve on linux for Dota 2 (a direct port to linux AFAIK) is the just the right kind of wrong that I still need to play it on windows. I've even had agents try to reproduce with a mounted copy of windows on the same computer and it got closer, but still not enough. Did you solve it?
Out of curiosity have you tried forcing the Windows version through Proton on Linux and seeing if it's a problem there? I've had to do this with CS in the past due to native bugs, could be an option if keeping Windows around is a pain
It is almost good, but not nearly close to Windows - even Valve own projects like CS2 work noticably worse than on windows(no Wayland support OOB, HDR issues, if you hack Wayland ON, then overlay does not work + only Windowed mode).
The Windows versions of Valve games run much better than the native implementation under Proton on Linux, at least last time I tried CS2.
I only play single player games and they really are 100% perfect. The heaviest "AAA" game I've played recently is probably the Indiana Jones game. Played perfectly. No hiccups at all. Currently spending a lot of time with Starfield.
That said, it's always worth checking ProtonDB for compatability and tips for working around any problems, when they exist.
I now view Windows as a gaming API for Linux.
I deleted my Windows partition months ago, as I can play WoW Forever and Diablo 4 flawlessly on my Linux desktop box, no hacks, using the Battle.net launcher.
I even get higher FPS than on Windows though admittedly these are not the most demanding games.
All thanks to Valve (I launch them via the Steam launcher).
Yep I made the transition recently. I built a Steam Machine for the living room that should last into the PS6 era. And now my main PC dual boots into Linux. I just realized I never boot into Windows anymore, but I'm afraid of wiping it just yet. Maybe it's only a matter of time. My work PC still runs Windows unfortunately.
Linux has surprised me at how easy its been to use, especially compared to modern Windows. I highly recommend it. Also Bazzite if you're into gaming.
CachyOs runs many windows games faster than windows which is mad ;)
Well when you think about it, the Windows games are just calling out to library functions within Windows, that in turn often hook into library functions within maybe some vendor library that's part of a driver.
If you make those faster you make the game faster.
If all you're doing is slinging triangles at a GPU, then the faster you can do that - without having to ask other bits of the OS for help - the faster the game will draw.
>slinging triangles
Yeah and you could hit some stub in Wine/Proton and skip drawing shadows which will bump up your FPS ;)
I've been using CachyOS now for almost a year and it has been a very stable gaming environment. Granted, I don't play the latest FPS games. Mostly just World of Warcraft, Anno, and Civ.
The only weird issue I have is some websites, specifically banks just refuse me from logging in and give me a generic error or access denied. I pull up the same site on my macbook and it works fine.
Any time I tried desktop linux, I haven't seen anything that would make me want to use it daily over windows, even ignoring software compatibility issues. Windows sucks, but it sucks in a familiar way I can easily deal with so I can ignore its existence and just run the software I actually care about.
"the devil you know" is indeed a painful disincentive to switching, the natural lock-in effect of inertia is enormous and often understated.
Coupled with some major AAA's not working, I understand why people are reluctant to switch. It's a bit of a chicken and egg problem.
That said, it is hugely viable now, so you have a choice: surrender yourself to data mining and an increasingly hostile platform, or take the plunge and try.
I'm super happy that this choice exists, Microsoft no longer has us by the balls.
NB: I know very little regards linux and have not fully thought/researched this properly.
Install minimal linux on the bare metal. Using a VM with GPU pass through. (proper term for that which escapes me...)
It seems like it'd offer many benefits but is there a reason why this is not the common approach?
The problem is anti-cheat which pretty much all online games have.
Also, AI makes Linux vastly easier to use. An agent can help you understand how the system works and figure out issues easily.
As long as the thing you're installing is on Steam. The gymnastics you have to do to run non trivial games not on Steam, especially ones with installers can be insane. Adding a non steam game, running the installer, finding that the "add this to my desktop and start menu" options you selected in the installer did nothing, then adjusting the target of the non steam game you just added to be in ~/.local(which is hidden)/share/steam/steamapps/<literally some random number>/pfx/drive_c/Users/steamuser/AppData/Local/<some random subdir> and then finding the right .exe..., oh and don't forget to also set the directory or the game won't load correctly. And god help you if that's not enough and you need protontricks.
How the HECK am I going to convince a single person who's not spent the last 30 years of their life in front of a computer to switch to this? This is competing with "double click .exe, press next a few times, done". To any non-nerd, this kind of workflow is complete and utter madness and actually, even as a nerd, I completely agree with them. WTF.
The answer people seem to have come up with are launchers like Lutris which come with install scripts. Which would be great... if many of those weren't simply broken, or installed ancient versions of Wine and are generally, somehow, simply buggier than just running the game on plain ol' Proton as is.
Erm nothing stopping Steam or the games themselves from putting telemetry code in them.
It's usually console ports that have issues, otherwise all the PC games run great even with competitive with anti cheat. Valve has been doing god's work, Gabe deserves all the yachts.
Until it gets rid of Proton, no it isn't.
Playing Windows games via Proton is no different from playing Amiga or Arcade games on Linux via the respective emulators, or translation layers.
Without Windows there are no Proton games, and the amount of studios that care about Linux native games outside Android NDK, is ridiculous low numbers.
Have you used Proton? It is not just an emulator, it is a full Windows API written for linux. And the amount of games that just work is huge. I know you know it.
Also, steam deck became a popular platform studios do optimize for.
I play on my laptop, desktop, the deck, my tv. My kid plays on the deck.
For all practical intents and purposes this IS gaming on linux.
Yes, exactly " Windows API written for linux", meaning it runs Windows games, not Linux games.
That is like saying MAME is gaming on Linux.
Sure one gets to play games on Linux, games that were designed for other operating systems.
And? Does it matter, practically speaking?
Given that the outcome is the same: the code runs in a seamless manner, and people don't have to suffer through whatever closed-source OS vendor pushes onto them? Steam Deck sales speak for themselves, and the overall ecosystem benefits from it massively.
I mean, I barely remember the last time I deployed code into a non-virtualized environment. Binary translation, virtual machines, just-in-time recompilation - all fine with me as long as it works well.
Or, if we speak about games. Some early games made it supereasy to port games and game logic because of using a vm behind the scenes (Another World and Quake 1). Who cares?
Emulation and API translation makes running vintage titles trivial on Linux, and I don't remember my daugther complaining about this, ever. My collegue from sales plays his brutal soulslike on Steam Deck, and he doesn't really know what Linux is.
I switched ten months ago and I'll never go back.
I have used Linux many times over its lifetime of existence, but always ended up going back to Windows for gaming, until I switched to Linux for the last time a couple of years ago. I am never going back again. Linux gaming is simply great, and Windows sucks worse than ever. I can run everything I want.
Which distro are you running? I tried Pop!_OS as a daily driver but I ran into regular problems like the window size acting up on games, my camera or audio failing on Zoom and remote desktop not working, so I got tired of attempting to fix it and went back to Windows. Windows has a lot of flaws, but they are predictable, while the Linux issues seen rather unpredictable.
Not OP but frankly Pop!_OS hasn't been good for a long time and I really do not think people should recommend it. It's notorious for being, frankly, very buggy.
If you're up for something completely different, I'd recommend Omarchy. If you just want a super solid desktop with KDE that'll feel familiar coming from Windows, CachyOS.
Ubuntu derivatives are pretty bad. Try CachyOS or Bazzite.
I am hitting a lot of issues with CachyOS as well, Linux just ridden with all types of bugs. One day it just panicked on every boot because of NULL-pointer dereference in BTRFS kernel driver.
Then I had bluez crashing when reconnecting BT headset. Then I had USB ports randomly pop off because of some bug in usb driver.
Now after some update I have broken sleep and one of my dispalys not coming back after waking up.
AFAIK, currently CachyOS(and Arch) DBuS server still built with debug setting which will crash your whole system if one of the userspace clients provide NULL-pointer as argument. Like, wtf??
This kind of issues are just so rarely hit on windows.
> Multiplayer still has lots of hiccups.
Vanishingly few by volume. Popularity is unfortunately a different story, but still few.
Disappointingly, some games (and even some publishers writ large) will deliberately block Linux users. Two recent examples:
- From everyone's favourite, EA, most of their bigger titles including Battlefield 2042 and Battlefield 6 don't work on Linux due to EA's anti-cheat settings.
- On the smaller studio side of the spectrum, Bulkhead, who develops WARDOGS, had a wild 180 around the time the game entered its open beta where the anticheat was configured to start blocking Linux users. This was a massive middle finger to the closed beta Linux testers and players. The stated reason on the official Discord framed Linux as some sort of hive for hackers and malware developers, which is as ignorant as it is insulting.
Instead of Battlefield how about Hell Let Loose? Runs in Linux and it's the best Battlefield game I've played since BF2!
I might try it, I've usually had a bias towards modern settings for FPSes. I've heard good things, though.
Right now I'm on a break from traditional shooters, though, Deadlock's got most of my attention.
My point, in any case, is that some developers or publishers are operating from a point of either bad faith or truly staggering ignorance about Linux. HLL might be a good game but it doesn't change that the devs for a different game made a really weird call and publicly justified it in one of the dumbest ways I've ever seen.
and we should play more single player + local hot seat and multi-controller games. Online went too much into wrong direction already.
Depends on the multiplayer, MMOs often work fine, that's all I play and no complaints
It is genuinely so much better. The only major issue (imo) is new releases are rarely supported.
It’s far more common for a new release to have Linux support than not. This has been the case for years.
Soon as PUBG is on Linux, I can kill my windows pc. Cant wait.
How much PUBG do you play, dual boot?
It'll let you have cleaner and optimized for PUBG only Windows then too.
This will sound hilarious, but I only have a windows PC for the purpose of PUBG. I have some friends who I've been playing with for almost a decade now, and some of them have moved a few timezones away, PUBG is the major way we get to connect on a regular basis so I've stuck with it. I really can't be bothered messing around with dual boot, the rest of my life is on my Mac. If I could just boot into linux and work/play I'd probably switch my life to linux again.
I would love to but cyberpunk ran barely at 60fps vs 150fps on windows. Factorio was unplayable. Ubuntu 24. So it just boot to windows 10 to game.
60 FPS is plenty, so I have no idea why you're complaining. Factorio should work great on Linux and the devs really work hard on it, so I would suggest submitting a bug report if you're having issues.
I dropped Windows a long time ago. I don't have any games that Proton won't play, even BG3 ran great. Linux is a first class gaming platform now.
As soon as SteamOS supports Nvidia, I'm gone from Windows (except to play ARC Raiders)
Try Bazzite or CachyOS. They offer most of the same experience and support Nvidia.
Hm, I may try Bazzite due to the atomic updates. Probably Deck mode because gamescope FTW. The one problem I've yet to solve is KVM (mostly the KM part), I need to get around to making that custom hardware device one of these days. Haven't heard of any solution that meets my requirements (wired ethernet, relative and absolute mouse input, macOS client)
I'm going to make an educated guess that by KVM, you're referring to remote desktop, rather than virtual machines or hardware video/input switchers, neither of the latter have any problems on any Linux distro. For basic remoting, the KDE-integrated RDP server works pretty well. If you want remoting good enough for gaming, Sunshine/Moonlight have you covered.
I'm not referring to remote desktop exactly, I'm referring to remote input. I already have a Thunderbolt capture card I use for viewing the video signal. I just need a keyboard and mouse input. Deskflow does that for me currently, but it's quite crashy and unstable, so I'd quite like to replace it. I figure the best way to do that would be to replace it with a hardware device, but I haven't found one I like, so I plan to make one. Note that I'm not talking about USB switches because my built-in keyboard and trackpad can't be plugged into that.
I already have remote everything else. I even have remote power & reset button! Gosh I love that thing. It's nice to give the PC a quick little reset before each gaming session.
If Affinity came to Linux I’d probably quit Windows. It’ll never happen now that it’s just Canva, but I need a better emulation package than I’ve figured out.
> It’ll never happen now that it’s just Canva
https://x.com/Affinity/status/2117276850795790442
I know it's a bit of a meme but honestly take a look at ArtCraft - PhotoCraft is now at the point where it's basically good enough for most people.
But also yes, as another commenter noted, Affinity is coming to Linux.
> The vast vast majority of single player games are 100% perfect on Linux. Multiplayer still has lots of hiccups.
The truth is if it can't play the 2026 AAA games on day 1, let alone games such as GTA 6 especially with multiplayer, then gamers won't even bother to switch or even touch Linux consoles such as the Steam Machine.
They even rather buy a supported console (Xbox or PS5) to play the game first just to wait for it to be on PC, which will be a year later.
By the time it reaches Linux or the Steam Machine, it would be roughly 3 years after.
The default now is to release simultaneously on Xbox/Playstation/PC, with PC including proton support.
Claude will have GTA6 running on Linux with better than console performance real fast.
All of those accounts will be banned for running stuff outside the license.
Yes! And using local llm harnesses can greatly assist in configuration, troubleshooting and customization! I'm 100% on Linux (Arch) since february - no regrets.
ubuntu?
So does Intel, AMD, and NVIDIA drivers; they collect what executable name and paths you run; unless you opt out.
Most Chrome configs end up persisting full browser history and clickstreams inside a Google account.
If you use Debian and opt-in to popularity contest; it may collect and send similar info depending on how you installed these coding agents.
The Debian example is not comparable. Its opt in, verifiably anonymous, its only their own packagers.
This one seems to specifically target coding agents, but then, I'm sure they did targeted metrics gathering of specific categories of apps for years so I'm sure this is a nothingburger.
In all fairness I don't really care if Windows knows which agents or developer tools I use. I don't use agents, but am thinking about writing a dashboard/harness for agent management soon. My dev tools are Node, VS Code, git. Boom, there ya go.
As for switching to Linux the learning curve will vary with the user. I forced my wife onto Linux and it required about 30 minutes of training. She did not really know anything about Windows besides clicking on desktop icons, so with that 30 minutes of training is a power user compared to where she was. If you are a powershell guru with lots of Windows system management the learning curve will be greater, but systemD is great.
The biggest handicap is that the wife bought a new HP printer without checkout for support and the printer has no Linux drivers.
For those who didn't read the article, here's the key bit:
Dev tools are tracked and can be sent up if you enable optimal telemetry (default on).
Turn it off with: Settings → Privacy & security → Diagnostics & feedback.
Don't do it in the settings, do it with group policy settings. Windows will not override those like it will "user" settings.
Computer Configuration > Administrative Templates > Windows Components > Data Collection and Preview Builds.
Allow diagnostic data -> set to 0
Group Policy Management Console, go to Computer Configuration > Administrative Templates > Windows Components > Data Collection and Preview Builds
Limit dump collection -> set to 0
The privacy.sexy site/scripts have further settings to disable the (numerous) other telemetry "features" in Win11. Careful, as the 'full bore' privacy setting locks things down so much that Windows won't detect whether it's connected to the internet because it disables the internet connectivity test to MS servers. This can interfere with windows update and, annoyingly, even some game stores. Origin, for example, will refuse to connect if Windows thinks it isn't connected to the internet.
And when Windows updates and enables the setting again:
Turn it off with: Settings → Privacy & security → Diagnostics & feedback.
Fwiw I've run a Win11 install for a couple years, set it off on day one, and it's still off.
Obviously I still agree that it's ridiculous that this is on by default etc etc, Microsoft bad, but N=1 I haven't seen them resetting settings anytime recently, and tbh I'm kinda curious whether y'all are talking from experience or just saying stuff.
It seems a bit unpredictable, possibly a bug. Most of my day 1 settings stuck, but for example OneDrive flipped itself back on about three times before it just stayed disabled. Colleagues I've asked about it said they had no issue getting it to stay off.
From there it's really just a half-step to forming a conspiracy theory that MS is doing it on purpose. About as reasonable as noticing things missing from a convenience store and wondering if maybe the person next door with 165 shoplifting convictions might be involved.
I've been a heavy macOS user for dev work since early adolescence. Before that I used FreeBSD, so I'm comfortable with the command line. (Yes, you read that right.) But it's been a while since I used anything other than macOS for serious development work. A lot of the shenanigans around macOS Tahoe made me seriously consider switching to Linux. Last month I finally got the gumption and set up a Linux desktop how I like it.
I see no reason why any developer, other than someone writing something for the Windows platform specifically, should not be using Linux over Windows. MacOS has a ton of polish in so many places—but then there are all these little paper cuts that keep coming: funny little bugs that interrupt work or make you scratch your head. Peeking over the garden wall into Windows' garden only seems worse. Linux by comparison is awesome! I look forward to spending my day on my Linux desktop.
Seriously, if you do dev work, do yourself a favor and boot up—I dunno, maybe Fedora Silverblue—on a separate partition and force yourself to work on it for a day or two. Use an LLM to diagnose issues as they come up. (I had some serious stability issues; Claude suggested it was a memory issue; running memtest86 told me I had bad RAM—fixing that and all problems went away.) You'll find that your system is quieter and less distracting.
I still don't think Linux is for "average users"—even though most people probably only need a web browser. But if you have gone anywhere near a command line in your life, it will be worth the switch.
> I see no reason why any developer, other than someone writing something for the Windows platform specifically, should not be using Linux over Windows.
I agree, but I think there's a big reason they do use windows. A lot of companies choose Windows for corporate IT. That's a decent enough choice if most of your company are non-devs working in email, excel and word etc.
In a big company, that often leaves developer using windows.
That's been the story whenever I've had to use windows professionally in the past anyway.
Things have changed though. It's not uncommon for non-technical people to have a working Linux desktop as their daily driver. The problems those people come up with (to me the actual "techie") is mostly related to web applications being shitty web applications. Nothing any browser or OS can do anything about.
And whenever I'm confronted with MS-Windows 11, I have trouble just right clicking a file. So then I have to hold down shift, but then the file isn't selected anymore so I get the wrong context menu, again. I wouldn't be able to adjust to Windows if my life depended on it.
> I still don't think Linux is for "average users"—even though most people probably only need a web browser. But if you have gone anywhere near a command line in your life, it will be worth the switch.
There are Linux distros like Ubuntu that are far simpler to use for the average user than Windows, especially nowadays that the average user is used to smartphones, where you go to a store and install an app with one click.
Windows is much more complex to use to me, I've installed Ubuntu to a lot of average users and the feedback they gave me was always that it was so simple to use compared to Windows, install programs with one click (yes, now Microsoft has its store but for most software you still need to go on the internet, download the installer, answer questions the average user has no clue what to respond, and hope to have downloaded the official installer and not a virus), there are no automatic updates that start without your consempt that will break your PC (you don't know how many people computer break after a Windows update), there are no viruses, no need to create an account just to be able to start using your computer, usually the stuff you connect (e.g. printers) doesn't require you to install a dedicated driver, and you can keep using your 15 years old PC just fine, no need to buy a new hardware every 4 or so years because Windows 11 needs 16Gb of RAM just to boot.
Unless you have the need to use particular proprietary software (which most user don't, since nowadays practically everything is web based and 99% of the stuff they use is the browser) there is no sense in using Windows.
All software that the average user wants is on the Microsoft Store which has been there since 2012 and has carried desktop programs since 2016. It doesn't need an account.
Except it's not true, there are a ton of popular open source apps that you find on almost any computer that are not available in the Microsoft Store, or are available with some limitations.
To use Windows 11 without a Microsoft account (and thus without connecting to the internet!) you need to open the command prompt trough a keyboard shortcut and type in a console command during the account creation process, surely something the average user knows how to do and doesn't assume that it's forced to create an account since there is no "Skip" option available in the UI.
I would not ever use Windows for development, but as a Linux user, collaborating with Mac and Windows devs, I found Mac to be an even worse platform. I worked on build systems for embedded and Mac was by far the most problematic platform. Windows at least has WSL2.
What do you use for corporate email? Many places use Outlook, and the web version is inferior. From I have seen in those envs, devs can use WSL2 or just run a VM with Linux desktop.
Hot take: Users (including devs) choose Macs because of prestige and premium feel, not really for technical reasons. Of course, often citing other reasons.
I use windows in work (games), and all my personal devices are Mac/iOS. I don’t want to spend _any_ of my spare time tinkering with why my WiFi drivers aren’t working, or if a specific GPU is compatible. That still rules out Linux (or at least it did in 2024 when I last properly looked). The sleeping, hibernating and power management side of windows is shocking - my work laptop will come out of my bag dead probably twice a week a the only way to make that not happen is to go through a full shut down and boot. This is with a think pad, and my previous dell xps at my last job had the same problem, as does my wife’s work laptop. The trackpad hardware is shocking, as are the drivers.
My MacBook Pro “just works”, and has a terminal and a clear favourite package manager (homebrew) that means it doesn’t get in the way. It’s alive when I want to use it, I just open/close the lid. It shares clipboard and browser state between my phone and Mac even on different browsers (safari/firefox). I’ve bought one every 6 years (my last one being an M1 Mac which is still snappier than the 64 core 256GB workstation that I have at my desk in work). It’s also no more expensive than a matching spec XPS, or Samsung phone
Macs are usually better supported in corporate environments. Desktop IT guys just want to check compliance boxes and go home, they are already annoyed they have to support some Macs so desktop Linux is out of the question.
This is unfortunate, but absolutely true for me too. My personal computer is a Linux ThinkPad and I am pretty happy with it. At work, having to meet clients and partners regularly, I stick to my MacBook Air pretty much for that reason alone. Not for prestige exactly, but it raises less eyebrows. So yes, a status thing, which is pretty sad.
--
The only other real reason to prefer MacBook Air specifically is that it has no fan at all and barely ever heats unless I really start doing crazy stuff on it. This is really nice. I still didn't find a good powerful Linux-capable laptop that won't try to lift off when I have it on my lap. I am considering a new Framework 13 Pro, though.
I've seen plenty of normal users opting for Macs just to get away from Windows. Linux is still a bridge too far for most without Best Buddy Tech Support™, since even just installing Linux is an enormous ask for a casual users, and the options for laptops with Linux preinstalled are slim and thus not something a causal user knows about. Macs make their offer on the same level that the users are on while being mainstream, so it's not hard for me to understand why they're taking that option.
Well, I just recently got my first Apple device, a (used) MacBook Air.
Indeed for technical reasons alone. Mainly because I develope while on the move a lot.
It is powerful enough for my dev work - and it does not have a fan. I can put it on dirty ground without dirt coming inside (no fan air slids). I can even leave it running overnight and not be bothered by fans starting and stopping. It has a very long battery life - and still way better performance than my thinkpad t480, which is just a loud electrical heating device in comparison.
So I really enjoy this device - despite being very annoyed by macOS. Linux on it would be amazing, but I am not willing to trade in battery life. But you are free to believe that this is "premium feel".
For a long time OS X/macOS has been more reliable than Linux in a professional setting.
Also you require a Mac to do iOS development, which gives you access to the most lucrative smartphone app store.
The hardware quality of macbooks is genuinely peerless though. People always have an answer for what the Windows or Linux equivalent supposedly is, but I've tried many of them over the years and they're never as good.
I've never even personally owned a mac, but it's good to give credit where it's due.
I think so too. Although consciously, I chose a mac pro recently for the same reason, and it really feels a league above the comparably priced products.
https://linuxmint-installation-guide.readthedocs.io/
I like Linux Mint for basic use cases, but for anyone with more robust needs I'd recommend an alternative. Linux Mint still only uses X11, which means that a lot of reasonably common modern features such as HDR are unsupported.
Linux Mint 27 is scheduled for December and will offer a Wayland session. Though I believe Xorg is still the default.
I’d recommend CachyOS - it’s far more up to date, especially with nvidia drivers and the kernel, and with the default limine bootloader you can easily load a snapshot in case an update breaks something
+1 for Cachy. Arch, even though its reputation opposes this, is very friendly for newcomers because it bypasses the normal version-mismatch issues that tend to creep into the normal distros. You get the latest good version of everything instead of the best version three months ago and hope everything else was compiled against that.
Except that the Arch installation process is notoriously difficult/manual, even more so if you want a complete modern setup with disk encryption, secure boot, etc. The installer is supposed to help, but always crashed last time I tried to use it.
Of the big three base distros, Fedora is probably the best for gaming. It's straightforward to install relative to Arch, and the software packages are reasonably recent. Debian could also be viable on older hardware.
I can't speak to vanilla Arch, since I haven't tried their current installer, but CachyOS's installer is extremely simple to use, and does handle setting up full disk encryption. I suspect its ease of installation is part of why it has gotten popular among gamers switching from Windows.
CachyOS's installer does not, however, handle setting up secure boot, nor am I clear on what your "etc." covers, but you do end up with a fully featured desktop OS at the end
CachyOS completely solves the installer issue.
ive been meaning to swap my main desktop (still windows) to steamos. are i dont game too much. at least AAA but i like to make stuff that needs gfx. is there an argument against steamos which i think is a fedora fork?
SteamOS is based on Arch, not Fedora. I think it's Bazzite that it's based on Fedora. SteamOS isn't designed to run on hardware other that Valve's IIRC, Bazzite is basically the generic hardware version of it.
I'm running Cachy on my Laptop, debian on desktop, ubuntu for work. I just hate pacman's interface so much. The parameters are not intuitive and they refuse to stick in my head. Maybe I should look for a wrapper or have an LLM write one that makes it behave like apt.
I've been having a seamless dual-boot experience with Windows 11 and Linux Mint Debian Edition, LMDE7.
As a preface to those Mint instructions, in Windows Disk Management I shrink the main Windows partition by about 20GB to 50GB, this creates some new "unallocated space" immediately following the normal Windows C: volume.
Then create a "New Simple Volume" in that unallocated space, but do not assign a drive letter and do not format. This will be the sole Linux partition, no /swap, no /usr, none of that monkey business when you are not replacing Windows, merely adding Linux as an option to a "virtually unchanged" Windows PC. You want Linux to occupy a single partition just like Windows does. At the Command prompt in Windows Diskpart, next select the target HDD or SSD, then select the target Linux partition on that drive, and "SET ID=4F68BCE3-E8CD-4DB1-96E7-FBCAF984B709 which is the designator for Linux Root. Also in Diskpart you can select the EFI volume and assign an alphabetical letter to the EFI volume so you can see the hidden folders and back up the Windows-specific \EFI\Boot\bootx64.efi file contained within. Manipulating the "hidden" EFI files can only be done at the Command prompt (not the GUI) after assigning a drive letter like this, and after you reboot, that drive letter will be removed automatically and no more access to EFI unless you reassign a drive letter again in CMD.
Then boot to the LMDE7 USB drive so you can install Linux to the unformatted partition.
In the Mint install wizard you will have to choose the "Manual" partitioning & formatting option, which opens up infinite possibilities, but this simple dual-boot arrangement only takes a couple distinct settings. In the displayed list of partitions, select that unformatted volume as "root", indicated by the single slash "/", and choose to format it using ext2, ext3, or ext4. Then in the small fat32 boot partition (where the Windows boot files are already residing in the "hidden" \EFI\Microsoft\ folder), Do Not format this partition, but select it as the ideal location for the Linux boot files, and designate it as "/EFI/Boot".
That's it.
After completion, Linux will be completely independent from Windows. In the EFI boot volume there will be a new \EFI\debian\ folder alongside the \EFI\Microsoft\ folder. The only change to any Microsoft files (and it's a "big" one) is within the \EFI\Boot\ folder which is a common folder to all the OS's on that SSD. When first powered up, \EFI\Boot\ is the folder that the UEFI firmware searches for so it can execute \EFI\Boot\bootx64.efi which then boots the PC. On a plain Windows PC the bootx64.efi file is from Microsoft and points to \EFI\Microsoft\ then Windows boots normally. The Linux install process replaces bootx64.efi with a different bootx64.efi which points to \EFI\debian\ instead. This is also a good time to use Windows to back up the Debian-specific bootx64.efi file.
Fortunately, the Mint install process runs a Grub routine including os-prober, which as the name implies, probes for other OS's besides the Linux you are presently installing at the time. And auto-adds any OS's found, to the new Linux multi-boot menu. So it reliably picks up a regular Windows installation and adds an entry for that Windows to the Linux bootmenu. Basically that Windows bootentry points to the same old \EFI\Microsoft\ folder which is unchanged and then boots Windows normally when selected.
Unfortunately, os-prober has been commented out of the Grub files and the probe only functions upon OS installation. So when Grub itself is re-installed or updated at a later time, intentionally or not, os-prober no longer runs by default and Windows will be auto-removed from the Linux bootmenu and you wonder where it went. Windows is still there intact regardless and can be recovered by replacing the Linux bootx64.efi with the original Windows bootx64.efi that you backed up earlier. But that would give you no more menu access to Linux.
To avoid this deficiency in the default Grub files, in Linux you need to edit the \etc\default\grub file to uncomment (remove the # hashmark from) the GRUB_DISABLE_OS_PROBER=false line. This basically requires using sudo at the Linux command line since otherwise the file is read-only.
Windows 11 is probably collecting a lot more data and phoning it home.
Serious question I have anytime people get upset about telemetry like this with Windows: why isn't there a similar level of outrage against Android, iOS, ChromeOS, Googlebook OS, and Mac?
The real outlier in all of this are Linux distros. Every other commercial OS is tracking a lot, but it seems like Windows is the only commercial OS people expect to not track you? There is no way Apple and Google don't know which apps people are using on their OSes too.
Google is the worst offender of this by far. They'll correlate data across every Google thing you do (every email, browser history, app usage, audio recordings, car driving habits, etc) and very effectively sell/manipulate you with ads based on that. Microsoft only wishes they were half as good at milking and monetizing tracking like Google.
Because Windows was not always like this. It has gotten much more telemetry "features" over the years, on top of generally user hostile changes, which upsets people.
The other OSes have always given the user less freedom, except for Android, which people are similarly outraging about, and dealing with that problem through custom roms.
Because Microsoft doesn't hide it.
https://learn.microsoft.com/en-gb/windows/privacy/required-d...
That's easy, at least the first four:
Android and iOS: smartphones are surveillance devices anyway, and everyone expects it.
ChromeOS and Googlebook OS: the cloud is the selling point. Of course it sends all your data to Google.
Mac, I suppose, gets off the hook as long as the telemetry is branded as security support infrastructure.
I needed to clear my 100gb gmail to stop paying $4.99/mo, I knew they wouldn't let me, but figured if Gemini is going to ask me every day to connect to my gmail, I'll see if it can categorize and clean up my 21GB left over of email.
Nope. Can't function against bulk mail. Can only function on small searches, etc. No "Gemini, clean up my spam." lol.
What are they even doing with all that data? You'd think from having so much user data that they'd be using it to create a better product
Hell Microsoft is probably collecting data on what color my pee was this morning
It's agentic era, the respond should include "I've already order you some water (from our partner brand) on Amazon"
I am afraid that I can’t trust any commercial AI output in few years because of getting manipulated
Probably not last Friday
Why is this 'news', or rather, voted up so highly? Everyone knows Microsoft collects an insane amount of telemetry. ETW isn't even that big of a deal. This ability is more for system administrators and enterprises to track tooling and diagnostic usage. It's interesting to see this telemetry is sent to Microsoft but in light of their Surface RTX and the Windows 11 developer mode, this should be expected so they can track if there's issues with the hardware, OS, or tools when reporting crashes and other things.
Because it’s easy to say “collects insane amounts of telemetry”. What’s actually interesting is what’s being collected: are they collecting the IDEs and coding agents you use? login and shutdown times? browser history? periodic screenshots? key strokes and mouse positions?
It is absolutely a big deal. The fact that they're still evil and doing evil things should be called out. They should be publically shamed until they stop doing evil things.
Seems like a non-story. A company is collecting data on users to improve its competitive advantage with its own offerings
I pray for the day Linux gets real anti cheat and autodesk products run there
Anti-cheat has no business being in any kernel. It's the most sensitive part of your system, and if it gets pwned, every last part of your system down to the firmware is compromised and irrevocably trained. If Crowdstrike can't be trusted to make security software safe for the kernel, it's entirely insane to think that a video game company can do better. If a game refuses to run without kernel anti-cheat, you don't need it.
Anti cheat needs to consist of competitive g*mers traveling somewhere for LAN play on clean equipment provided by whatever league
This is for high level competitive gamers, a small fraction of total gamers.
This is high profile because there is a lot of money involved, but even casual gamers don't want their fun to be ruined by cheaters. And they are definitely not going to travel and be provided equipment by the bronze league.
I don't know if it is still the case but "I play on console because I don't want to play with PC gamers, too many cheaters" was something I heard a few times, and not from competitive gamers.
linux will never get any anti cheat worth mention, by design
This is changing now! Fortnite is confirmed to come to Linux:
https://www.theverge.com/games/1010808/epic-fortnite-linux-a...
Easy Anti-Cheat Linux v2 is coming along, with some distros working on support for it (e.g. CachyOS).
https://wiki.cachyos.org/configuration/easy_anti_cheat/
I see this "development" as something extremely negative. The point of Linux is that is does not belong or is verified by some "authority." Anyone should be able to build their own kernel with whatever tweaks they want, for whatever reason.
This is less about what you do on your own machine, and more about whether you are allowed to access the Epic servers running multiplayer games.
I think if Epic effectively updates their policy from 'you may play Fortnite if you can attest you are running Windows or MacOS' to 'you may play Fortnite if you can attest you are running Windows, MacOS, standard Fedora, or standard Ubuntu' that's still a win, even if they will never be able to move to 'you may play Fortnite no matter what OS you are running'.
I see this point, and I'm of two minds on this. The best counterpoint I have is that if these anti-cheats come to Linux, and some Linuxes will be more popular as a result, that means a lot of compatibility and backports to the rest of the Linuxes as well, which is helpful to keep all of them relevant is desktop space.
Since Linux is not a singular platform like Windows or Macos, there is not way that this is damaging to Linux as a whole.
That's your freedom.
But what about freedom of other people? Should they be able to play only with "verified" peers?
Because cheats are a serious issue and playing a game with cheaters is simply not fun.
Not sure it is a good thing indeed. As long as attested systems don't have momentum, application developers (and their funders) that target Linux have an incentive not to use it. When the userbase mostly has an attestable configuration, a developer using it will only annoy (and exclude) those who explicitly don't want it... and are today running Linux, among others, for that very reason.
amen. as justifying not using Linux because some proprietary shit game with anti-cheat from companies like EA or Tencent shouldn't ever be a consideration to migrate
Current anti-cheat is all broken now with AI tools. The only solution is game streaming, which would work on Linux.
Damn, I never thought of that approach. There may be yet be hope for multiplayer shooters.
Either the ownership issue or the latency issue are enough to kill this idea on its own.
No, because game streaming adds unnecessary latency, its exactly the opposite you want for multiplayer shooters.
Multiplayer shooters are totally ruined by hackers currently. >50% chance of encountering a hacker in Wardogs on a given game.
I can't see any other solution coming.
Demand that they bring private servers back. We can manage our own communities better than they can.
The idea of owing rent to the game lord just doesn't sit right with me, not to mention the latency. I would rather just play old games on moderated community servers.
I bet there could be a machine learning anti-cheat that can just detect subtle player inputs that are unnatural.
There are, like Valve's VACnet. It's just not as good as other anti-cheats.
Is game streaming even viable in this economy? (i.e. with all computing resources going to AI). I think xbox even limited playtime recently.
Not that I'd want to stream my games, of course :-)
It's not viable in this universe. We need FTL communication for streaming gaming to not suck ass.
If the server is located reasonably close to you (same country/state), you can expect a round trip latency of ~10ms, which is less than the latency of a top of the line competitive PC, and well under the limit of human perception for audio and visual feedback. So, viable in this universe.
In practice, there are a lot more variables, but under 40ms is achievable today with a good PC, a good connection, and a reasonably close server. That's good enough for all but the fastest games with competitive gameplay, and cloud gaming is generally considered a better experience than a low-end PC.
even 20ms of local latency rules out entire genres of games, no thanks
Maybe use a free AutoDesk alternative. I refuse to pay for AutoDesk.
They have a network effect for my work and proprietary file types
At least for AutoDesk products virtualisation might be viable with QEMU, that way you can dump Windows mostly but still keep it isolated in a VM until Wine catches up.
Fusion does not run at all outside of native windows, it relies a lot on hardware acceleration despite being some variation of a web app.
Actually Fusion works great on Linux (https://codeberg.org/cryinkfly/Autodesk-Fusion-360-on-Linux).
I ran this daily back when I needed Fusion for work this summer.
Is Wine/Proton not an option? People run all kinds of games on Linux with hardware acceleration.
For some it isn't. I prefer Solid Edge over AutoDesk Fusion/Inventor though Solid Edge isn't supported with Wine or Proton.
Solid Edge does work well in a VM on a 2020 MacBook Pro with a Windows guest, though.
Solid Edge does have a Community Edition, so it's easily possible to check if it works on a particular setup.
I also pray for the day that hardware vendors publish open specs, so that proper drivers exist on Linux.
I thought Autodesk used to have a "hardware key" option for verifying licensing - you plug usb key of sorts (was looooong time ago) and license check goes against that hd token thing-y? Or was it some other CAD product, but the idea is the same.
Get excited, clean room AutoCAD on Linux is happening.
https://github.com/storytold/cadcraft
Temper that excitement with the realization that even with AI agents doing all the heavy lifting, the *craft dev has spread too thinly to make much meaningful progress past what's been done so far. There comes a point where you have to move from the one-shot to giving specific, ongoing guidance to the agent. Also, with no corporate sponsors and using Claude for all this means that it's financially untenable to keep going like this.
I'm running fusion 360 on Cachyos so it's at least partially there :-)
Autodesk's moat is gone.
Reverse engineer their file format and we can say that. They still have anti competitive proprietary file formats and crazy strong network effect
anticheat -> signed kernels/attestation -> corporate-blessed linux builds -> eventually get the same diseases as W11.
So uh, maybe just stay on windows?
Hard no to kernel level anti cheat.
Windows has been very slow to make a sandbox for AI agents - they launched MXC just a month ago (Oct 7) and Claude Code doesn't even support it yet. So we have people running un-sandboxed agents on Windows, or they use WSL instead. All of this to say, yes I hope they have some non-invasive telemetry to know what to prioritize, because the platform needs features like this pretty urgently.
Hopefully they won't forget about including an "off switch", because sandboxing is defeating the whole point of running agents on your machine in the first place.
For anyone used to the Windows desktop GUI experience, Kubuntu is pretty much the same on the Linux side.
I realized this year that I don’t use Windows-only apps any more so I can finally ditch my dual-OS life. Found Kubuntu. It’s really really great!
If your excuse is that you’re “too used to the interface”, you should stay.
There is nothing they want more than you sitting back, relinquishing control in comfort.
When I get a new laptop/desktop I used to do dualboot with Linux where I still keep the original Windows around. Not anymore, I fully clean install just Linux. I don't really need Windows for anything anymore and if something would come up, you can always run windows in a VM on Linux. I still have a device with MacOs, but even with that one I'm switching to Omarchy as soon as they have good support (it's almost there).
Are there any charitable explanation for this? Attributing Windows breakage to an agent released with destructive behavior or poor guardrails for instance...
Analitics / metrics gathering, to answer questions like "how much are these tools used by our users". I'm confident they have similar categorizations for other types of applications - creative, gaming, browsers, etc.
What is a bit odd is that this distinction is made client-side, if it was just metrics they'd send the process + info to their data lake and sort it there.
Windows sending so much identifiable data would surely have raised further concerns once inevitably identified by security and privacy researchers. There’s no telling how securely this data is handled on the backend.
I wonder what sort of stuff Linux logs by default? How much stuff actually ever needs to be in say syslog? How much does it leak? And then every other log... Even things like bash history. Surely that is violation of privacy by default...
Syslog and bash history are defaults, and I cannot remember any instance when they were accessed and uploaded by any software.
Logging itself is not a violation of privacy when it doesn't leave your device. Of course it's a matter of expectations, for example logging keystrokes would be a weird thing, even if it didn't leave the device.
And of course the security of these logs is similar to other PCs, meaning, all of a user's software can interact with any other user-accessible resource silently. Aside from special cases like Qubes OS or custom AppArmor configs etc, software can just do whatever the system's user can do.
If we're looking at it from a forensic perspective, there is a lot to check, once you have access to the user folder. For example there's the cached thumbnails of most images that were once on the computer.
Logging is not the issue, reporting is.
>Surely that is violation of privacy by default...
It is as much of a privacy violation as having a lot of private information in your own home...if you want to avoid something like that use linux distro build for that purpose like Tails, Whonix or Qubes.
You are in complete control of how much stuff it logs. There are distros that will run without any writable storage at all, some designed specifically to leave no trace.
turn it off Go to Settings → Privacy & security → Diagnostics & feedback and turn off "Send optional diagnostic data"
This is only logical to expect. A lot of things you can do for privacy if you care about that! (including using linux, setting up tailscale/qurl)
add it to the list of millions of reasons ill never update from windows 10 LTSC. ive never ran into anything not working either. aside from msstore stuff, which is completely removed
I think some multiplayer games will refuse to run on it because the Windows 10 LTSC kernel is more likely to have some known vulnerabilities allowing code execution in the kernel.
I imagine its costing you a pretty penny, running an Enterprise LTSC edition of Win10 that is still supported in some way.
no, its free. why would i pay ms for support i dont need? lol. this is my personal machine, not my business terminal
counterpoint. i used to main linux: arch+dwm.
now i run win11+wsl. all dev is wsl+emacs which drives native windows as needed for game builds. it's fine.
i operate a pvp online game, with both linux and windows clients: better.game/download.
i tried to drop the linux client to focus on windows, but there's always a few users who want linux, and tbh it's fine. server and original gui client are both linux, so it's easy.
i'd be surprised and impressed if microsoft understands what coding agent i'm using (i brought it from home). power to them if they do.
Understanding what programs are running on an operating system actually makes sense for the kind of telemetry that should be collected.
> what programs are running on an operating system actually makes sense for the kind of telemetry that should be collected
No. Nobody, except I can decide what gets collected. It's nothing. Nothing can be collected from my computer....unless they want to pay me back for the pro licenses I have that [should] make the system mine. And even then - no.
Does this data show up in Diagnostic Data Viewer?
All of it does.
This might be the last drop
That's just the information we know Windows 11 collects. How much private information does Microsoft have access to because it's on a Windows system that can phone home?
Home users have zero reasons to use Windows in 2026.
Skip problematic distro Linux like Ubuntu which has become evil and semi-proprietary.
There are distros like Mint Cinnamon that are awesome. Based on Ubuntu but without all the mess from it with solid support and community. It has newer packages like Ubuntu but the security practices like Debian.
From internet to video editing, from writing docs to playing Steam games, it just works.
Office?? LibreOffice. You shouldn't be using Microsoft Office even on Windows.
LibreOffice is solid, 100% offline, free, and received massive donations during Microsoft drama on Friday.
The only downside is for folks who play Steam games with kernel anti-cheat, that is spyware anyway and you should not be playing such games to start with.
You can isolate Steam by installing its Flatpak version, even if you installed a game found to be compromised, Flatpak sandbox isolates it. Avoid installing the native DEB package which grants full access to the system files, if you get a game compromised that way, then yeah, you are screwed.
Windows is not different, if you have Steam running on your Windows PC and installed a compromised game, good luck haha
> Skip problematic distro Linux like Ubuntu which has become evil and semi-proprietary.
Someone who is just now switching from Microsoft because of their crappy UX probably isn’t choosing their operating system based on an ethical framework. They want a low-hassle OS, that’s all.
> They want a low-hassle OS, that’s all.
Maybe it really is time for a real, commercial-grade, competitor to Windows in the consumer-PC space, one that isn't Linux - think: Amiga, BeOS, NEXTSTEP, etc.
Mint is not any less “low-hassle” than Windows.
Much of what you say, like the fact that there are different distros and something called packages, makes an average person zone out and lose all interest. It sounds like you still have to think about the OS, whereas with Windows you do not
I'm primarily a linux user but I support my family's windows desktops and sooo many things on windows is problematic and difficult. You are just so used to its quirks and think of them as "normal".
My friend who is a windows power-user pointed me to these windows powershell cleaning scripts which runs all kinds of random clean-up commands that seem to change and need fixes all the time.
I will take my linux package manager any day of the week thank you.
How to install software on Windows: open some random shady website, find the correct download link among 20 fake ones that point to malware, open the installation wizard, make sure to uncheck all boxes for installing browser toolbars, click Next several times (being on the guard for more malware).
How to install software on Linux: open the software store, find the thing you want to install, click the install button, maybe enter your password.
Obviously the former is easier for the average user and doesn’t require thinking about the OS.
>How to install software on Linux: open the software store, find the thing you want to install
Oh please don't let me start on the "app store"
First, it does not contain all the software, a lot of software still require you to go to vendor page.
Second, it's sometime not official. The package on app store could be community maintain.
Third, due to the 2nd reason, the package could be outdated, and there is no easy way to know this.
And that does not include the whole "snap, flatpack, appimage" that is randomly mixed on appstore, and each package can behave a little different.
There is reason no one use Windows appstore.
>It sounds like you still have to think about the OS, whereas with Windows you do not
So stick with Windows giving all of your data to Microsoft and ignore my comment :)
It's not about me. I can use Linux just fine. I'm referring to the promotion of Linux and how technical people see it vs how the normies do. It's a matter of perception that needs to be addressed.
> I recently asked AI to help me look through the latest Windows binaries for undocumented features and functionality.
Can you trust AI here though?
It seems to me as if people rely increasingly more on AI being honest to them. How can they assume this is the case? Isn't AI more like a black box tool? You depend on whatever code is used by the company upstream.
Because in many cases the answer the tool gives can be verified. For example, I often ask "What's the syntax in software ABC to do XYZ?" Then when the LLM spits out the syntax, I read the manpage (or online docs) for ABC, and double check that yes, the `--xyz` option was the right one. The LLM's answer is usually faster than scrolling through the manpage myself, reading 50 irrelevant options before I get to `--xyz`.
I've had one case where the LLM told me "You can do XYZ like this: (example)" and the online docs said "You can't do XYZ yet, we haven't added that feature, but when we do add it then this is how to do it: (example)". So I still double-check. But it's right 90+% of the time, and it saves me time since the LLM (running on massively parallel clusters of GPUs) can synthesize and associate words much faster than I can.
So that's why people are trusting the LLMs. Because they're usually right. You should never trust them 100%, though: always verify, whenever it's possible to verify, what they tell you.
Windows Defender was quarantining text config files from Codex so persistently that I considered disabling it permanently.
This kind of invasiveness is why some companies have switched to professionally supported Linux based distros and run Microsoft Office desktop apps in VMs (in a way wholly transparent to the users) on those systems.
Windows 11 discloses this, and provides toggles for Required & Optional Diagnostic data. It also includes an app for you to browse the event entries .
The disclosure on Optional Diagnostic Data is shown with the UI control and is clear that website & app activity will be tracked, and that it can be turned off to no ill effect on the system functionality or security.
The article claims the data is always recorded, and if and only if your diagnostic sharing is off, it won’t upload it. That does not feel like a truthful interpretation of the data privacy toggle by Microsoft. Also, once you “decide” to re-enable sharing (aka. accidentally enable after an update) is there a high likelihood it will upload all of this previously collected data?
Helpful context (maybe). it still seems like a petty concern. a mountain out of a molehill. MS is very clear that it is tracking your EXEs, and the article is making a stink that they are recording "claude.exe" is running. NBD
It’s also something Enterprises are explicitly paying to understand: who is using agents, and what data are they allowing them access to.
It's just the .exe , not the prompts. not the context .
And ... Microsoft is disclosing exactly that.
Been using NixOS and haven’t looked back
NixOS really is bliss especially with agents. There are so many classes of problems you just cannot experience.
It’s crazy how little of the Linux mindshare NixOS has for how incredibly well positioned it is for the next 5 years.
No it's not because I haven't used Microsoft software since approx 2008. I was done after XP. I never looked back, one of the best changes I ever made.
nothing is protected , they always spy
I sometimes jokingly say "Windows is spyware", but perhaps it's not that far off...
It isn't a joke any more. Could be a half joke on earlier versions, but find a Windows 10 machine and try and disable defender for example. Oh sure you can disable in all the settings, it is still running in the background using significant resources if you check task or resource manager. Do group policy and registry edits, both from within and outside Microsoft's directions to disable it, still running. Powershell commands? Still running. Even as a power user that has used Windows since 3.1, it was difficult to actually accomplish and required resorting to random github scripts and programs run multiple times before it stopped. And im willing to bet that is only temporary. Next time I notice a big system stutter I can almost guarantee when I check task manger it will be one of the half dozen "defender" programs that decided to magically reenable itself.
it's been true since they added this sort of enhanced telemetry back in windows 10's early days. Such a shame that OSes have been monotonically getting worse since the high point in 2009
https://https://csrc.nist.gov/glossary/term/malware
"A program that is inserted into a system, usually covertly, with the intent of compromising the confidentiality, integrity, or availability of the victim’s data, applications, or operating system or of otherwise annoying or disrupting the victim."
I guess we do need to keep seeing things like this on the front page just in case there is anyone who is not aware of Microsoft's stellar reputation for putting user security and experience first, but then again it does get old that about all you can say is Microslop gonna Microslop.
Maybe if we leave it on they'll learn that no-one is using copilot
I just had to spend another 30 minutes removing "defender" because it was sucking up such resources and causing stuttering in various applications at random times. I did the exact same thing a few days ago going through group policies, registry settings, etc. Did it again today, still didn't work. Tried to do it through powershell which failed. Eventually resorted to random github scripts, which half failed, but once I used enough versions of them I finally got a boot today that it didn't load upon. Also tried to disable a bunch of other stuff through O&O Shutup, many of which still didn't work or reverted because Windows is such a clusterfark.
Like I almost wish I had a virus to break it, maybe that is what finally broke it after all these random scripts. But atleast I got my system CPU usage down below 5% while idling and doing nothing, and I haven't yet noticed any random 50% CPU usage spikes again, but you know I did all this a year or so ago too so it is perhaps just a matter of time.
Microsoft needs to die.
I recently installed a lightweight windows by SanLex and it's a perfect freaking windows. There is zero bloat inside, zero telemetry, no onedrive, no copilot, no xbox apps, no microsoft store, no windows defender, no windows hello, no ads, a pristine, clean system. Not a pixel on the interface moves around on startup. Two icons in the dock. SanLex must be a Microsoft CEO really.
"And unless you have opted out of the “optional” diagnostic data (which is enabled by default), the data is uploaded to Microsoft."
This detail is not unimportant I guess.
Optional diagnostic data includes some data. Well, I opted out of it during first setup, so I'll be fine.
It's really incredible and totally off-brand for Microsoft to actually respect privacy setting and not upload telemetry when opted out.
Wait, is there anything you do on a Windows 11 machine that is not collected and sent over for processing?
Apparently it’s not only Chinese tech that is phoning home beyond acceptable performance telemetry related to the sole product itself.
Oof spying on how successful their competition is.
Just yeet the spyware. Developing on linux is much nicer anyway
That's one way to get very skewed data. Determine programming tool use but only from the population that uses Windows with optional telemetry enabled.
It's just prefiltered. If you're smart enough to disable telemetry, you're not part of the market segment they're interested in.
Why is anyone using windows in 2026
> Windows 11 is collecting data
I mean if you use Windows for anonymity you're doing it wrong. Windows is a product for Microsoft, not for you.
History shows every Windows version had been a spyware. Still it's the most beloved around the world.
Now it's not called Windows because of the boxes on the screen. It's called Windows as it's looking into your soul to suck the life from you.
Hint: it’s not copilot!
It's interesting how Silicon Valley/Redmond companies can "extract" data from their users but not use any of the data collected to actually improve or help their users with tasks in their systems...
As an example, pointed an LLM at my file/folder drive and it cleaned and organized every single file into folders, deleting all duplicates perfectly in the background without one issue, and also advised of 40 GB of old Docker tests which were not needed.
2026 still waiting for Windows to work this out.
If you trust LLM to clean up disk without your input, you could just format whole drive and save some tokens. Because whatever data it holds can't be important, otherwise you wouldn't ever trust it to system that can go off the rails at any point.
And in other news: "Flaming Pile of Shit Continues to Burn"
Even if Windows 11 wasn't doing it, Fortinet and other vendors of corporate spyware are doing it, also.
So the justification goes, if corporate spyware vendors do it, OS vendors can do it too.
The AI wars are fully ON, folks. That local power is being targetted by many significant corporate overlords.
And how is this news? This is to be fully expected already for a long time.
In case you forget.
if they didnt spy on me id expect that to be news.
Microsoft acting unethically?
No shit sherlock! Every company now is doing the same.
No it is not.
Windows deserves criticism where it's due, but this sounds like nothing. If one of those programs crashes they could just end up in an error report upload dump anyway. If you didn't trust Microsoft, I don't see why this diagnostic changes anything. You can turn it off if you want to, though. You'd be surprised what some of the anti-cheat software sends that some games use, and you can't turn those off or the game won't run.
In the age we're entering, I'm not convinced that escaping to MacOS or to nix or any other system is any sort of guaranteed win. I saw MacOS doing similar analytics things to Windows, but trust is, it's private! MacOS also barely feels maintained. nix is a crapshoot and any distro you're thinking of using to get a workable desktop that lets users feel at home is already failed by that very goal. What's worse is that the nix ecosystem is rife with insane package managers that makes them even more ripe for getting plucked by AI in the upcoming years. It will also be even easier for AI to social engineer and get people on nix to install persistent bot networks and malware even if it only runs as a regular user to expand the computation footprint it has access to.
I'm not a fan of the always online cloud infrastructure integration that Windows has, but being realistic, if you want to use your computers the way you have been for the past couple decades then Microsoft's approach is the only realistic one in my opinion even though they have a long way to go still. I say that sadly. If you want true security and true privacy, you have to compute in a different way with greater limitations and I see almost nobody willing to do that. It's like the doctor and patient dilemma. Doctor tells you to stop doing this thing that's killing you, patient comes back in 3 years closer to death, because they don't change.
Given the situation Microsoft faces, it's impractical to automatically configure every home computer with some air gapped NSA secure configuration, because there would be far more outrage than any privacy advocates have ever put up. It's only gotten worse, because so much software only works with the internet and the internet has gotten so important that a lot of software is only useful with access to the internet.
Then you've got this battle between dying hard drives losing data, fires, floods, hurricanes and other natural disasters destroying your data versus backing it all up online, but opening yourself up to security risks that way. People like to think they have multiple backups, but then some storm takes out both of your backup locations, because they weren't distributed enough. If World War 3 happens, the data centers may become a huge target and even as distributed as they are, they can only take so much. Nature is eating at you from every direction.
People complain about Window$. And continue to use it. Funny.
“Hrrrrrm, you hate capitalism and yet you live inside it! Hrrrmmmm”
Switching your operating system is about 10 orders of magnitude easier than moving to a different country.
Yeah because socialists are too comfortable with their worthless NGO jobs to move to North Korea.
What? North Korea is not socialist at all. Or do you also believe it is democratic because NK says so?
If you think an operating system is a flaming piece of shit (because it is), you really should stop using it. Windows isn't as pervasive as capitalism, it's just a shitty piece of software/software ecosystem one can stop using on their personal machines.
They can stop using it unless they can’t. There are still a few situations and a few pieces of hardware or software that don’t really have other options that don’t cost considerable amounts of money.