I'm of the mind that the budget always includes the black ops, so it'll never succeed an audit because of "national security" reasons. The only way to reduce that gap would be, you know, stop pissing off foreign nations with wars and stuff.
Otherwise, it's not ever auditable. Just red tape.
It should always be auditable. You just need an auditor with security clearance and then don't release the results. Just say it passed or failed. Pretty sure it's just incompetence that they're not passing audits.
"Defense Department CFO Jules Hurst told Reuters an independent auditor found that financial statements for 14 of the Pentagon's 25 standalone reporting entities passed in the 2026 fiscal year, which ended in September, up from 11 the prior year. Those entities account for 56% of the department's assets and 86% of its liabilities.
...
The Pentagon as a whole was first audited in 2018 and has consistently failed to pass annual audits because of its system and accounting problems. Congress gave it 10 years to pass, which falls in the fiscal year starting in October 2027" [1].
This is better news than I thought it was. If they can get that up to 80% of assets and 80% of reporting entities by the deadline, it would seem fair to grant a one-year reprieve to 90% (2 units can fail), one more to 95% (1 unit can fail) and then require 99% thereafter or funding is sequestered.
You can choose not to pay soldiers, but every country whose politicians have ever tried it has found those politicians staring down gun barrels, or other time-appropriate weapons held by the soldiers.
I wish someone could explain to me why using old computer systems means you can't pass the audit. I'm not saying this isn't the reason and there is some other reason (e.g. widespread theft), but rather I'd like to connect the dots here. Surely there are many businesses with old systems and these manage to pass audits.
My understanding is that it's because they can't account for all spending/assets/liabilities, not because they've demonstrated meaningful fraud (I'm sure there was some degree of it however).
"ahh we don't have invoices for this $50m so we're not sure"
Vs
"you spent $50m on supercars for your admiralty?!"
It seems because time to learn how to pass an audit is running out:
> The Pentagon as a whole was first audited in 2018 and has consistently failed to pass annual audits because of its system and accounting problems. Congress gave it 10 years to pass, which falls in the fiscal year starting in October 2027.
Provided you vet the work, right? Certainly the legal field isn't similarly suffering from a massive influx of documents that cite wholly hallucinated case law, right?
Audit already doesn’t check every single transaction. AI means you can check more. Also, when something fails an audit, the needed data or decision log might still exist somewhere, and AI can dig through mountains of emails and files looking for the right information.
The solution to any auditing issue is to only approve funding the next year on fully audited programs. Can’t provide a full audit? Guess you don’t need the money
this doesn't seem inherently bad overall; the average number of deaths inflicted per soldier throughout their lifetime is far greater than 1, and more likely a reduction to pentagon funding would just manifest in a reduction to meddling(/strongarming) in overseas affairs in proportion to the reduction in means.
if (as a thought experiment, enforceability aside) every country signed a treaty limiting the proportion of their population they were allowed to have employed in military roles to half its current global average value, the result would be to halve the rate of loss of life with little else.
pouring less money into the machine that exists to fulfil geopolitical goals by violence doesn't result in an increase to violence, in the long term
It’s really not. We have budgets and they control where the money goes. Everyone needs money to run things. What you are suggesting is that one particular department should have unilateral authority to ignore budgetary concerns because their people are more important than the ones served by the other parts of our government. That’s definitely a position one can hold, but it is one that depends on your values, rather than one that is related to the question of whether the financial audits are important.
You're commenting this in the same week that the US loses the eradicated status on Measles and adds more preventable deaths to that statistic. And that's by its action, not just neglect. So yes - there are a few scenarios where the US government as a whole is just fine with some unnecessary deaths.
Naively, I'd say this problem looks like introducing syntax linters to a legacy codebase. Everyone knows you don't just turn them all on in CI, one day.
Say I am the head of my household in charge of family finances, and my 4 year old daughter throws a tantrum and requires me to submit paperwork about all my expenses.
American I.T. infrastructure is like America's physical infrastructure. Everyone went crazy building stuff back in the 60s and early 70s when the money was there, but nobody really thought about how to maintain it - and upgrade it - and smoothly obsolete it as necessary. Finances dry up; pretty soon you're maintaining systems held together with floppy disks, piano wire, and chewing gum.
Do you think DOGE isn't associating itself with AI because of the negative opinion? (of DOGE or AI, you pick)
Cause that would be a case for a single DOGE illuminate and a slew of agents, both having no clue what they're doing and caring little about consequences
If you read beyond the headlines, you'll see that they're making progress every year.
Applying accounting controls to a large complex organization that did not have them before and can't really stop to redo everything to meet standards is hard. No one expected it to happen quickly. Looks like the Pentagon thinks they're on track for a clean audit in 2028, which is only one year behind the Congress request, 10% overrun isn't too bad.
I wonder how quickly they would pass audits if entity budgets would automatically be shaved 5% for each failing year.
I'm of the mind that the budget always includes the black ops, so it'll never succeed an audit because of "national security" reasons. The only way to reduce that gap would be, you know, stop pissing off foreign nations with wars and stuff.
Otherwise, it's not ever auditable. Just red tape.
It should always be auditable. You just need an auditor with security clearance and then don't release the results. Just say it passed or failed. Pretty sure it's just incompetence that they're not passing audits.
I read that black budgets fall under a black budget category with a specific identified percentage. So that should already be acheckmark
"Defense Department CFO Jules Hurst told Reuters an independent auditor found that financial statements for 14 of the Pentagon's 25 standalone reporting entities passed in the 2026 fiscal year, which ended in September, up from 11 the prior year. Those entities account for 56% of the department's assets and 86% of its liabilities.
...
The Pentagon as a whole was first audited in 2018 and has consistently failed to pass annual audits because of its system and accounting problems. Congress gave it 10 years to pass, which falls in the fiscal year starting in October 2027" [1].
This is better news than I thought it was. If they can get that up to 80% of assets and 80% of reporting entities by the deadline, it would seem fair to grant a one-year reprieve to 90% (2 units can fail), one more to 95% (1 unit can fail) and then require 99% thereafter or funding is sequestered.
[1] https://www.reuters.com/business/aerospace-defense/pentagon-...
Is sequestering funding for the Pentagon realistic?
> Is sequestering funding for the Pentagon realistic?
Probably not. You can’t not pay soldiers. Or contractors on long-term work.
What you can do is increase the number of JAGs. Or maybe create a GAO to monitor the Pentagon for the Congress.
You can choose not to pay soldiers, but every country whose politicians have ever tried it has found those politicians staring down gun barrels, or other time-appropriate weapons held by the soldiers.
I wish someone could explain to me why using old computer systems means you can't pass the audit. I'm not saying this isn't the reason and there is some other reason (e.g. widespread theft), but rather I'd like to connect the dots here. Surely there are many businesses with old systems and these manage to pass audits.
My understanding is that it's because they can't account for all spending/assets/liabilities, not because they've demonstrated meaningful fraud (I'm sure there was some degree of it however).
"ahh we don't have invoices for this $50m so we're not sure"
Vs
"you spent $50m on supercars for your admiralty?!"
In my experience, audits tend to only fail when non-trivial amounts of theft or fraud are uncovered by the auditor.
"It's all a huge mess and records are so poor the auditor can't check" tends to just get a qualified pass.
>"It's all a huge mess and records are so poor the auditor can't check" tends to just get a qualified pass.
Sure, if you're the one paying the auditor.
If the .gov is auditing your stuff or it's any sort of predatory adversarial context like that it'd be a fail.
IDK how hostile this pentagon audit is. Probably toward the friendly end.
> Probably toward the friendly end
An auditor fucking with a Pentagon audit would be Arthur-Anderson level stupidity.
Here, let me fix that: "56% of the department's assets and 86% of its liabilities, we think. Because we haven't finished the audit."
Still, I'm impressed. I would have guessed the DoD would be extremely resistant to audit as a cultural matter
95% of units passing an audit can simply mean that all the theft and bribe payments have been moved to that last unaudited unit....
Anything less than a 100% audit pass might as well be zero.
why audit if failing doesn't matter ?
Because the Pentagon never passed an audit (it wasn't required to have them).
So they have to build up the infrastructure to actually be auditable, and this is a report that they're improving, not an unexpected failure.
It seems because time to learn how to pass an audit is running out:
> The Pentagon as a whole was first audited in 2018 and has consistently failed to pass annual audits because of its system and accounting problems. Congress gave it 10 years to pass, which falls in the fiscal year starting in October 2027.
Because we're tracking our ₊˚.⋆⋆⁺₊ progress ₊˚.⋆⋆⁺₊. 56% of assets were covered this year! /s
Why is AI involved in a financial audit? That seems weird to me, but I'm not an auditor.
> Why is AI involved in a financial audit?
Same reason it's useful in e-Discovery. You can run simple checks on massive quantities of data instead of just deep checks on a sample.
Provided you vet the work, right? Certainly the legal field isn't similarly suffering from a massive influx of documents that cite wholly hallucinated case law, right?
Audit already doesn’t check every single transaction. AI means you can check more. Also, when something fails an audit, the needed data or decision log might still exist somewhere, and AI can dig through mountains of emails and files looking for the right information.
audits for many years, until ai, have traditionally run on sampling
why not? worked very well for my very complicated tax return.
isn't AI particularly good at extracting and organizing info from thousands of docs/sources?
It's ok. In America no one cares.
The solution to any auditing issue is to only approve funding the next year on fully audited programs. Can’t provide a full audit? Guess you don’t need the money
> Can’t provide a full audit? Guess you don’t need the money
This works great until a service member dies because their armor wasn't ordered, or the unit that got defunded is an oversight function.
this doesn't seem inherently bad overall; the average number of deaths inflicted per soldier throughout their lifetime is far greater than 1, and more likely a reduction to pentagon funding would just manifest in a reduction to meddling(/strongarming) in overseas affairs in proportion to the reduction in means.
if (as a thought experiment, enforceability aside) every country signed a treaty limiting the proportion of their population they were allowed to have employed in military roles to half its current global average value, the result would be to halve the rate of loss of life with little else.
pouring less money into the machine that exists to fulfil geopolitical goals by violence doesn't result in an increase to violence, in the long term
> this doesn't seem inherently bad overall
I don’t know any military families who would agree with this.
> this doesn't seem inherently bad overall
Sure, if you view soldiers' lives as abstract playthings.
You are probably living in the US or a Western country that benefits from those soldiers having died in the past.
> pouring less money into the machine that exists to fulfil geopolitical goals by violence doesn't result in an increase to violence, in the long term
So if US stops its defense funding, the Putins and Xis of the world will retreat and sing Kumbayah?
Remind me: did Hitler die because we end up defunding the military?
I mean, people die all the time because other government agencies cannot get funds for housing, healthcare, improvements to safety, …
A soldier dying because of government negligence is obviously different from a safety net not existing.
It’s really not. We have budgets and they control where the money goes. Everyone needs money to run things. What you are suggesting is that one particular department should have unilateral authority to ignore budgetary concerns because their people are more important than the ones served by the other parts of our government. That’s definitely a position one can hold, but it is one that depends on your values, rather than one that is related to the question of whether the financial audits are important.
Why should that matter? The US government is happy to throw lives away any other time for far stupider reasons.
That depends on the lives, reason, and government in question.
It actually isnt.
You're commenting this in the same week that the US loses the eradicated status on Measles and adds more preventable deaths to that statistic. And that's by its action, not just neglect. So yes - there are a few scenarios where the US government as a whole is just fine with some unnecessary deaths.
Naively, I'd say this problem looks like introducing syntax linters to a legacy codebase. Everyone knows you don't just turn them all on in CI, one day.
This gives me a great idea for a dystopian scifi - a country made up of nothing but auditors.
I think 40k came close to that one: https://warhammer40k.fandom.com/wiki/Adeptus_Administratum Billions of clerks, still capable of losing a few planets or worlds due to administrative errors.
black mirror basically did it with nosedive
Say I am the head of my household in charge of family finances, and my 4 year old daughter throws a tantrum and requires me to submit paperwork about all my expenses.
Would that work? What is the chance I'd comply?
This. The IRS. The FAA.
Facile complaint:
American I.T. infrastructure is like America's physical infrastructure. Everyone went crazy building stuff back in the 60s and early 70s when the money was there, but nobody really thought about how to maintain it - and upgrade it - and smoothly obsolete it as necessary. Finances dry up; pretty soon you're maintaining systems held together with floppy disks, piano wire, and chewing gum.
Inevitable comment, "what would happen to me if I failed an audit 9 years in a row with the IRS?"
I don't know. How many machine guns, missiles, and fighter jets do you have?
A few machine guns actually. Cant even cross state lines with them without notifying the ATF. Better bet im not allowed to lose them.
Do you think DOGE isn't associating itself with AI because of the negative opinion? (of DOGE or AI, you pick)
Cause that would be a case for a single DOGE illuminate and a slew of agents, both having no clue what they're doing and caring little about consequences
Ok cool, can we shut it down? Oh, we can't. Is anyone going to lose their jobs? Nope, can't do that either.
There's 0 incentive to ever fix this. It will all fail catastrophically together when the world stops wanting to buy US dollars.
If you read beyond the headlines, you'll see that they're making progress every year.
Applying accounting controls to a large complex organization that did not have them before and can't really stop to redo everything to meet standards is hard. No one expected it to happen quickly. Looks like the Pentagon thinks they're on track for a clean audit in 2028, which is only one year behind the Congress request, 10% overrun isn't too bad.